用戶登錄
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 國際學校 YCIS耀中 vs 法國國際FIS 國際部
發新帖回覆
查看: 2304|回覆: 18
go

YCIS耀中 vs 法國國際FIS 國際部

Rank: 1


30
發表於 18-1-15 00:59 |顯示全部帖子

歡迎中文/英文意見

Any thoughts on the two schools? We weigh our pros and cons and still in a deadlock. We understand that comparing these two schools is comparing apple and orange,we are a French-Chinese family. We are currently only considering these two schools.

We want our child to be fluent in English & Mandarin, while hold basic communicative level in French. Not taking into account costs difference and locations, here's part of the list:

YCIS

- Bilingual teaching (with emphasis in Mandarin in the primary years)

- Through-train school

- Students take both IGCSE & the IB in high school

- Recent average IB exam score is 35 (year 12)

- There is no ranking in the school, to avoid the competitive mentality. Are the parent-teacher meetings sufficient to motivate and help kids achieve desirable results in public exams?

FIS

- English teaching with French and very little Mandarin

- Through-train school

- Students take both IGCSE & the IB in high school

- Recent average IB exam score is 35 (year 12)

- Kids receive minimum Mandarin exposure. Here in HK, can they still achieve a level of fluency in Mandarin (Read and understand the news, write comments about a news topic, for example) via outside, supplementary Mandarin classes, both from FIS (Extracurricular class) and outside help?

I have heard good and not so positive comments about both schools, but they are never compared on the same page. Any constructive thoughts and experience sharing are welcome. Thank you!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2436
發表於 18-1-15 10:33 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Dear-Valerie 於 18-3-28 18:13 編輯

del.

Rank: 4


658
發表於 18-1-15 11:33 |顯示全部帖子
我曾經報過YCIS,最後withdraw,因為太多單一國家學生,我個人好唔種意,多到一個程度,學校直頭唔肯講有幾多,咁我覺得好唔國際

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2436
發表於 18-1-15 11:47 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Dear-Valerie 於 18-3-28 18:13 編輯

del.

Rank: 6Rank: 6


7739
發表於 18-1-15 12:00 |顯示全部帖子

回覆樓主:

如樓主focus是中文水平,耀中应优勝過fis, 其他如ib成績不能單看平均分去比較,ib 第一第二語文和數學有分级別,平均分並不能反映出來。另外,耀中中學部是private independent school, student mix 是最少70% local,這是否配合你要求?我不是說PIS有問題,我孩子也是讀PIS, 最重要是你要求什麼。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4336
發表於 18-1-15 12:03 |顯示全部帖子
If you only aim at basic French verbal communication but fluent in Mandarin, of course, you should go for YCIS. One Mandarin class  per week is just for fun in FIS.

Rank: 4


658
發表於 18-1-15 18:34 |顯示全部帖子
Dear-Valerie 發表於 18-1-15 11:47
回覆 islychiang 的帖子

的確係香港人內地人佔多數. 不過int'l schs主要提供外國課程同埋外籍教師.
我幫expat做school enrol,我唔可以話少咗外國人,只係好集中某啲學校,相對shanghai ycis其實香港ycis真係太多中國同香港人

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2436
發表於 18-1-15 18:48 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Dear-Valerie 於 18-3-28 18:13 編輯

del.

Rank: 4


658
發表於 18-1-15 21:57 |顯示全部帖子
Dear-Valerie 發表於 18-1-15 18:48
回覆 islychiang 的帖子

內地的int'l schs好似多數只俾foreigners入讀? 有外國passport的內地人都未必受理 ...
其實內地係唔可以有dual citizenship,所以有外國passport一定會收,但通常有外國passport都唔會留係內地,呢個係國情,所以佢地既is係真is, 講番ycis,相比,上海reputation係好過香港,或者呢個同歷史有關,香港太多30年過外既IS,但大陸唔多,所以相對唔覺得ycis發展得比其他香港is好

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2436
發表於 18-1-15 22:48 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Dear-Valerie 於 18-3-28 18:13 編輯

del.

Rank: 6Rank: 6


8006
發表於 18-1-15 22:57 |顯示全部帖子
islychiang 發表於 18-1-15 18:34
我幫expat做school enrol,我唔可以話少咗外國人,只係好集中某啲學校,相對shanghai ycis其實香港ycis真係 ...

咁香港的expats通常喜歡讀邊間?
其實我見通常重中文的外國人都自然比較少,所以想「國際」定「中文」,自己要稔清楚。ESF其實而家都相對多左local人。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2436
發表於 18-1-16 00:32 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Dear-Valerie 於 18-3-28 18:13 編輯

del.

Rank: 4


658
發表於 18-1-16 09:08 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 islychiang 於 18-1-16 09:12 編輯
964000 發表於 18-1-15 22:57
咁香港的expats通常喜歡讀邊間?
其實我見通常重中文的外國人都自然比較少,所以想「國際」定「中文」,自 ...

主要睇黎自邊個國家,因為CIRCUR唔同,HKIS一定係大熱,熱到我地MON定佢地唔好限制呢間,HKA口啤幾好,英制就一定ESF同KELLETT,STAMFORD開始都有啲人選,如果法星德就通常去番自己個間,其實我冇做過去YCIS反而重中文去KCIS都重有,反而上海我地有做去YCIS

Rank: 4


658
發表於 18-1-16 09:12 |顯示全部帖子
Dear-Valerie 發表於 18-1-16 00:32
剛剛去睇YCIS 2017 uni acceptance.
其他國家我唔熟, 但英國Top 10都有齊
唔係話佢入唔到好學校,只係咁單一收咁多大陸人,班房文化好難唔變單一,呢個係我唔想既,我重文化多少少,如果係單一文化,我其實可以選擇番LS重岩啲

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2436
發表於 18-1-16 09:21 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Dear-Valerie 於 18-3-28 18:14 編輯

del.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


415
發表於 18-1-16 12:23 |顯示全部帖子
Dear-Valerie 發表於 18-1-16 00:32
剛剛去睇YCIS 2017 uni acceptance.
其他國家我唔熟, 但英國Top 10都有齊

同哈羅一樣有多少是一路讀上來,而入到top U的有多少,還是最後幾年轉入來的. 值得考慮一下

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2436
發表於 18-1-16 13:54 |顯示全部帖子
本帖最後由 Dear-Valerie 於 18-3-28 18:14 編輯

del.

Rank: 2


32
發表於 18-2-10 22:22 |顯示全部帖子

May I ask for opinion?
My son born on nov 2013, we got offer from FIS reception class 2018/19, also got offer from Renaissance Collage year 1 class?
Personally RCHK is not my first priority, we like shatin junior more but we didn’t even have a chance to do interview.
For now, we accepted FIS offer but just realized Reception class is equal to K2 standard. What shall I do ? Anyone can give me some insight pls? Tks

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4336
發表於 18-2-10 23:25 |顯示全部帖子
Kittyyoyo 發表於 18-2-10 22:22
May I ask for opinion?
My son born on nov 2013, we got offer from FIS reception class 2018/19, als ...

FIS 做大B 有咩唔好呢?

FIS 最大問題係中文太少,一星期一堂寥勝於冇。RC 中文好過很多國際學校。


你需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 註冊