英華與黃笏南哪間好些？不考慮地點學費

KikiDaddy

hkpapa852 發表於 17-7-21 15:45
黃笏南校務報告既用詞係"大學課程", 咩叫"大學課程"呢?

可能計埋AD/HD, SF Degree, SF AD/HD......

I got the WFN data from its School Profile: -

http://aerodrive.twghwfns.edu.hk/~wfnchp/publication/profile/prospectus_2017.pdf

On page 20, " The percentage of our students getting an offer from thelocal universities through the Joint University Programme Admissions System (JUPAS) has been exceeding 50% throughout the past three years, with at least 40% of them receiving an offer of a degree programme."

This sentence does have some ambiguity as 40% is not clear whether it is of all the S6 students or of those 50% students receiving the offer from JUPAS. However, it is more likely to be 40% of all the S6 students can get JUPAS degree offers base on their  above 5 % and 3322+2 %.

hkpapa852

KikiDaddy 發表於 17-7-21 16:12
I got the WFN data from its School Profile: -

http://aerodrive.twghwfns.edu.hk/~wfnchp/publication ...

睇番校務報告:
http://www.twghwfns.edu.hk/sch_reports/annual_sch_report/annual_sch_report_1516.pdf

當中話升讀本地大學課程有53%, 而家Prospectus中講JUPAS offer >50%, ~40%係degree.

不過唔好忘記, JUPAS degree中, 亦包括部份 OU 既自資學士課程, 同埋一堆 SSSDP 課程

似乎, Prospectus 既說話証明了, 黃笏南校務報告中既"大學課程", 都係語言偽術

KikiDaddy

hkpapa852 發表於 17-7-21 16:41
睇番校務報告:
http://www.twghwfns.edu.hk/sch_reports/annual_sch_report/annual_sch_report_1516.pdf

Agreed. It is better to compare the DSE results which should be more objective. Unfortunately, not all schools are willing to disclose their DSE results transparently.

papapabababa81

hkpapa852 發表於 17-7-21 15:45
黃笏南校務報告既用詞係"大學課程", 咩叫"大學課程"呢?

可能計埋AD/HD, SF Degree, SF AD/HD......

本帖最後由 papapabababa81 於 17-7-21 17:49 編輯

我朋友喺英華做，佢話5+ 比WFN 嘅21.38%嘅高，但佢話學校強調所有數據係confidential，不能公開。

P.S. 都唔明點解英華咁低調唔公開，如果朋友所講係真實，其實英華成績都好好。引用權威hkpapa852嘅準則，學校成績都at least B1b啦。(可能個個都係狀元探花先肯公佈)

KikiDaddy

papapabababa81 發表於 17-7-21 17:49
本帖最後由 papapabababa81 於 17-7-21 17:57 編輯

本帖最後由 papapabababa81 於 17-7-21 17:49 編輯

https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=3299561&page=37#pid43986664

This is the unofficial YWC 2016 DSE results posted on EK. >5 % for 4 core subject is 22.4%. Since credit rate of YWC science subjects are quite good, the overall > 5% should be above 25%, which is slightly better than WFN.

Bear in mind, WFN DSE results has dropped a bit since it moved to the temporary campus in Shatin. If the comparison is for a longer period, say 3 to 5 years, I believe the DSE results of YWC and WFN would be pretty close.   

golfwu

sumsung26 發表於 17-7-20 14:44
朋友仔仔派入黃笏南，叩門入了英華，如不考慮學費地點，哪間優勝點？

每年黃笏南和英華都有30%左右比例入三大，主要你仔仔肯努力，無論邊一間中學入到三大就OK！

ICbaby

papapabababa81 發表於 17-7-21 13:18
本帖最後由 papapabababa81 於 17-7-21 13:18 編輯

睇係咩成長背景嘅人啦

又關成長背景事?你都好狗眼!

王家爸爸

papapabababa81 發表於 17-7-21 12:36
華英學術成績好好，但運動係咪佢強項？

華英運動當然無咁好

王家爸爸

讀書既主要目的係讀書，運動只係配菜，千萬不要「妹仔大過主人婆」。

王家爸爸

little_yolky 發表於 17-7-21 11:29
但英華無搬校舎既客觀因素喎...............但我唔鐘意WFN個新校舎, 顏色好深沉。 ...

英華有親生仔因素，未知情況有嘜唔同，但係坊間偏向睇好。
都係嗰句，讀書係讀書，係睇鍾唔鍾意間學校，唔係睇鍾唔鍾意間校舎。

jigsaw

ICbaby 發表於 17-7-22 02:05
又關成長背景事?你都好狗眼!

佢應該冇惡意嘅，英華、皇仁、華仁....係一般老牌傳統名校，好似地利亞、威靈頓…老牌飛仔學校，老一輩實識。華英、迦密、林護、鄧顯、曾肇添…係地區勁校，論成績比好多傳統名校勁。
宜家家長資訊多咗，可能好多人寧願入地區名校㖭。
有人鍾意LV、Gucci....亦有人識揀Sonia Rykiel同issey miyake嘅

2jkidsfather

jigsaw 發表於 17-7-22 15:18
佢應該冇惡意嘅，英華、皇仁、華仁....係一般老牌傳統名校，好似地利亞、威靈頓…老牌飛仔學校，老一輩實 ...

我識地利亞、威靈頓…老牌飛仔學校，但我唔係老一輩
你係???

papapabababa81

jigsaw 發表於 17-7-22 15:18
佢應該冇惡意嘅，英華、皇仁、華仁....係一般老牌傳統名校，好似地利亞、威靈頓…老牌飛仔學校，老一輩實 ...

That's what I meant. Thanks

5kin

回覆 jigsaw 的帖子

威靈頓摺咗，費事幫佢翻案；
地利亞仲响度，20年前唔好唔代表依家一樣差，
各人心目中嘅「出色，叻」學校一樣有讀書差、誤入歧途嘅學生；
心目中排名好後嘅學校一樣可以培養出人材。


世事無絕對，就算一間往績100%入資助學士學位，
無人可以擔保呀邊個邊個個仔/女入到讀，
6年後唔會打爛學校嘅招牌

sumsung26

更新：朋友仔仔去咗英華注冊，仲有提供奬學金俾佢

little_yolky

2jkidsfather 發表於 17-7-22 17:43
我識地利亞、威靈頓…老牌飛仔學校，但我唔係老一輩
你係???

好彩你反應快, 差D講咗我都識添！ 呢兩間學校邊度架? 唔識既?

ICbaby

sumsung26 發表於 17-7-27 17:27
更新：朋友仔仔去咗英華注冊，仲有提供奬學金俾佢

請問為何入S1学校会提拱奖学金比学生?
見有直資又系咁

LJ3981

ICbaby 發表於 17-7-28 14:27
本帖最後由 ICbaby 於 17-7-28 14:28 編輯

請問為何入S1学校会提拱奖学金比学生?

有特異功能就會有

ppmmbb

ICbaby 發表於 17-7-28 14:27
本帖最後由 ICbaby 於 17-7-28 14:28 編輯

請問為何入S1学校会提拱奖学金比学生?

https://www.yingwa.edu.hk/about.aspx?clid=171&atid=1732&lan=1

於學術、藝術、音樂、體育或其他方面具傑出表現之直資同學可獲提名申請直資獎學金。

2jkidsfather

little_yolky 發表於 17-7-28 13:20
好彩你反應快, 差D講咗我都識添！ 呢兩間學校邊度架? 唔識既?

新移民？