ESF TY今年考小一如何

VVhuilee

想了解下今年多咗TC一齊爭，有冇K2 家長可以講下暫時第一輪有幾多人有offer?  感激

Moonlight819

好像有些班好些，有些班不太好，不少waiting或reject!

hong0706

VVhuilee 發表於 17-2-18 09:52
想了解下今年多咗TC一齊爭，有冇K2 家長可以講下暫時第一輪有幾多人有offer?  感激
...

我個班我知的20人中，13人已有offer, 4人wait foundation school, 機會應該好大， 1人直接reject, 2人要second interview.
有D班仲差D，整體我估有成15％人reject or second interview , 好似比去年嚴， 2nd interview 最後入唔入到未知。

個玩法好似改變中，reject 或2nd interview 的理由五花八門， 尢其不利怕陌生或靜的孩子，ESF在不同briefing一次又一次強調他們會令shy的孩子說話, 唔好信, 有這問題的一定要train up, 否則貴客自理。 今年fail 的有D係native speaker, 仲大部都冇被學校揀中上enhancement course 的！

貝珠

hong0706 發表於 17-2-20 09:36
我個班我知的20人中，13人已有offer, 4人wait foundation school, 機會應該好大， 1人直接reject, 2人要sec ...

What is enhancement course ?

lckfwylyk

our class with 18 students, only 6 got offer in the first round, for the rest, half are rejected and half are waiting...

964000

ESF似乎愈多人報，愈來愈揀學生了，這是可以理解，ESF失去政府資助，以後要吸學生，點都要交下成績

babyonboard

回覆 lckfwylyk 的帖子

wah.... half are rejected...

貝珠

lckfwylyk 發表於 17-2-20 10:20
our class with 18 students, only 6 got offer in the first round, for the rest, half are rejected and ...

For those rejected cases , do u think that it is because of eng standard ? Or just timid personality ? Or other non-cooperative behaviour ?

cusoon

It's a good sign

cole_chan

lckfwylyk 發表於 17-2-20 10:20
our class with 18 students, only 6 got offer in the first round, for the rest, half are rejected and ...

Half are rejected ! That's quite a lot
Do you know the reason of being rejected ?

ssmm1012

回覆 lckfwylyk 的帖子

more than 1/2 of them didn't get the offer is very awful.i think the successful rate at WKS is much better than TY.

lckfwylyk

cole_chan 發表於 17-2-20 10:42
Half are rejected ! That's quite a lot
Do you know the reason of being rejected ?

I know the rejected kids, regarding eng standard, except one is too shy , others are active and can speak good English, however, I observe some of them are not well behaved and lack of social skills.

kwokkellybb

一半咁多? 咁esf tc咪仲好過esf ty?

cole_chan

Is the school start selecting children with good background like other elite school ?

VVhuilee

kwokkellybb 發表於 17-2-20 10:58
一半咁多? 咁esf tc咪仲好過esf ty?

TC應該更差。。。。

VVhuilee

cole_chan 發表於 17-2-20 11:00
Is the school start selecting children with good background like other elite school ?

整合我自同老師同媽咪傾計嘅個人觀感：
英文同自理能力及social skills要求高。怕羞，攪攪震嘅學生一定輸蝕。
老師多次強調重要性，感覺上家長唔好諗著讀kinder有 priority就hea著算。
foundation school 話non-selective係唔太睇academic, 但 RC一定睇academic.

babyonboard

回覆 VVhuilee 的帖子

有冇人知道 TC既實際情況?

VVhuilee

cole_chan 發表於 17-2-20 11:00
Is the school start selecting children with good background like other elite school ?

唔覺，但唔好諗著入咗kinder就一定掂囉。

964000

VVhuilee 發表於 17-2-20 11:00
TC應該更差。。。。

WKS 暫時識得的都有offer/waiting, 未聽見有reject, 不過我識得的k2人數不多

858

cole_chan 發表於 17-2-20 11:00
Is the school start selecting children with good background like other elite school ?

What kind of family background are they looking for? Parents are doctors, barristers, engineers, accountants and pilot?
My son's classmates whose dad is a pilot got rejected. Another case is the candidate's dad works in legal field and he's been placed on waiting list - namely my son.