DELETED

gerki

請大家對題俾意見，我只不過想了解呢間學校多dd，再決定應唔應該申請，我有呢個既憂慮，先出post問一d相關既爸爸媽媽。你地唔係相關既爸爸媽媽又何必要黎俾意見。
你覺得唱國歌無問題，你米自己出個post出黎囉。我都寫左係真心問意見，唔係同大家爭論何謂愛國。

Jane1983

回覆 Kittybama 的帖子

這版只限用家，入錯版，無謂多講。

Antonyliang

只是很奇怪國際學校的家長也會提這樣的問題，看後有點擔心

gerki

Antonyliang 發表於 16-12-5 11:45
只是很奇怪國際學校的家長也會提這樣的問題，看後有點擔心

甘你慢慢擔心，多謝你既意見。

Lucent

gerki 發表於 16-12-5 09:22
請大家對題俾意見，我只不過想了解呢間學校多dd，再決定應唔應該申請，我有呢個既憂慮，先出post問一d相關 ...

我答你：只有唱英文和國語兒歌，中文程度比我想像中好，個人覺得係一間唔錯的學校。

gerki

Lucent 發表於 16-12-6 13:30
我答你：只有唱英文和國語兒歌，中文程度比我想像中好，個人覺得係一間唔錯的學校。
...

Thanks!
終於，有人肯答我問既問題

cathyaki

Jane1983 發表於 16-12-5 09:06
教小朋友愛國、唱國歌，為自己作為中國人而自豪，對我來說，係正面的事情。

如果家長好抗拒，可能選一些IS ...

贊同。

type409

CDNIS 要唱加國 and 祖國國歌。

LittleHoot

Do not want to get into any wars, but really disgusted by your post! If your son/daughter goes to SIS or CNDIS you will be far more happy to let your kid sing Singapore / Canada national anthem. And then we won't be even looking at this disgusting post here!

You need to find a way to immigrate to another country rather than keep your kid here to worry sing country's national anthem or dress traditional clothes or eat Chinese food !

BUT why didn't you think ahead to marry a western man???who can give your kid a foreign passport! Or get one for yourself even! to avoid all the hassles you are having right now???

You do not deserve HK!

FattyDaddy

I can think of many innocent reasons why someone may not want his/her child to be taught China's national anthem and national education.

The poster asked a simple question, whether a particular school teach that, and a simple "Yes" or "No" answer would suffice, but instead we have so many irrelevant people giving irrelevant "advises".

type409

I know my reply on this thread is also "irrelevant". But I just want to point out the fact that IS students also sing Chinese national anthem at school, because we are all stepping on this piece of land called China.

LittleHoot

If her kid is a Canadian and goes to SIS where all kids need to sing Singapore national anthem, I can fully understand her concern. However, after she mentioned brainwashing for singing own country anthem... she needs to think big! To leave here for better

FattyDaddy

type409 發表於 16-12-30 16:13
because we are all stepping on this piece of land called China ...

So? There are many foreigners stepping on this same piece of land, your domestic helper for instance.
To avoid any further irrelevance creeping into this thread, this should be my last post.

LittleHoot

Same here. Will drop this.
Everyone has an answer on certain thing. Just hope everyone can stick to it, as there is no way to turn back! Kids only gown once!

type409

So? I think my point is clear. We are talking about schools! what domestic helpers? I just want to say both IS and LS students may have to sing national anthem because we are inside China. What is wrong with it!

Your comments in EK are those I highly regard. And I never argue with anyone here. I really have no idea why you responded to my reply in such way.

FattyDaddy

type409 發表於 16-12-30 17:35
So? I think my point is clear. We are talking about schools! what domestic helpers? ...

This is to clear up the misunderstanding.
The example of the domestic helper is to illustrate there are many foreigners living in HK. Besides them there are those who are assigned to work in HK for a few years and so brought their family along with them and thus need to put their children in schools here.

You might think if you're stepping on a certain country's soil for whatever reason then you're obliged to learn that country's anthem and national education, but there are many exceptions so we shouldn't pass judgement on why some people don't want it.

KarieWu

其實出這類post, 就有好大機會引起激烈討論或爭辯，如果真的是簡單如yes or no的答案，與其出post等回覆，不如直接向學校查詢，會得到更直接及準確的答案。
簡單答一句：國際班小學及幼稚園部均沒有要求唱國歌，老師教導孩子比較著重國際視野，而非偏向單一地區。
孩子仍在小學部，中學部情況不能代答。

robocorn

我兩個女都無唱過, 只唱英文，同普通話歌，中文比我想像中深，K1一個學期已經教了
菜    牛奶  
魚     肉  
毛衣  棉襖
手套  圍巾
草     花
木     石                 雨    爸爸  
媽媽  哥哥  
弟弟  姐姐  
妹妹   大   
小     水
火    水果
蘋果    梨
葡萄  檸檬
草莓  香蕉
西瓜  菠蘿
橙     口
山     天
日     月  
紅色  藍色  
黃色  橙色  綠色

Abelmama

回覆 robocorn 的帖子

咁都不淺喎。想問下英文reading多嘛?writing方面又點樣教?謝謝。