蔡繼有，幾時公布第二輪面試結果? 幾時第三輪面試?

mosesmom

回覆 花花之家 的帖子

same here too.. also group C la... the english teacher not even paying attention to my kid's answer.. and said something else...

tiffany168168

woyj 發表於 16-12-15 11:54
又是group c !?
primary senior teacher 講英文的只有少數，學校網頁有資料及相, 不知是否同一人 ...

I'm also in Group C
Both teachers are hea,  not just the senior teacher.

cwansze

we are also group C... will update if the situation is the same... good luck to all~

fixedstar99

花花之家 發表於 16-12-15 11:38
我in group c , 同樣情況！hea 而且感覺呢位English senior teacher 無心機in !
有一條問阿女' do you like ...

我地都有呢條問題。
唔通全部問題一樣？

mathpets

We were also group C, the Chinese teacher looked bored and didn't want to be there. The English teacher seemed young to be a "senior" teacher.

Wahzube

回覆 mathpets 的帖子

We had the same feeling of that even though we were not assigned in Group C.  The whole interview lasted for only few minutes without any warm-up activities arranged before getting in the room.  We were asked only 2 questions followed by answering few simple questions by the kid.  I believe no matter how smart the kids are, they cannot provide the answers that can differentiate with one another due to the time limitation.  Both parents and kids can only provide the short answers to the questions straight away without any elaboration.  In this round interview, I think only parent's sincerity can be demonstrated instead of candidate screening......

gwenmother

回覆 Wahzube 的帖子

We were also asked two questions --- one answered by father and the other one mother. We were given enough time for our elaboration. The teachers were attentive and patient. The Chinese teacher especially showed her interest in our sharing. As for our child, both teachers took their turns to ask in Chinese and English. The questions were about daily life and her kindergarten. My child felt relaxed while answering these questions though there was no warmth up and the setting was the typical interview one. The whole process lasted for around 10 minutes.

IICHENG

retriever 發表於 16-12-15 11:56
入左3RD IN 機會幾大... 唔好咁失望.

3 rd int 成5百幾人呀！

retriever

IICHENG 發表於 16-12-15 14:52
3 rd int 成5百幾人呀！

really? if i recall correctly, it was around 300 last yr.

hongk

so you can see, interview at such young age is just a joke.

retriever

hongk 發表於 16-12-15 15:18
so you can see, interview at such young age is just a joke.

not at all.

just the type of interview the posters shared here....

kids at this age group would show their attitudes towards diff things and situations.  

hongk

retriever 發表於 16-12-15 15:41
not at all.

just the type of interview the posters shared here....

Soon you will see, sometimes the children who were on waiting list are performing better than those who got admitted in the first round. Lots of children fall behind around age 10 just because they were burned out. So I dont see any point to interview children at this age.

Some of my friends were so shy at young age, but turned out very confident now. Some are just the opposite. Life is a long journey and it is just the beginning of their life.

Most of people are just about the average level.

meowloo

woyj 發表於 16-12-15 11:25
好明白你的心情, 問小朋友問題, 但又吾俾時間答。 問D 平常既大路問題, 又顯得不耐煩, 咁不如一早問D 其他 ...

我們上年都是兩位老師接見，也有類似感覺：其中一位很HEA和面試很快完成；見到隔離GROUP和副校傾得好開心和傾好耐，當刻的感覺實在很差。但我記得學校是按考生號碼順序編組的，應該不存在見校長才有較大機會得獲取錄的情況。

認同揀學校要以家庭需要和細路利益為依歸，不值得被一兩個無關重要的人影响自己的決定。

想問下你是說該老師平日上課都是這樣？無家長向學校反映嗎？

siuap

以過來人的睇法：短短5-10分鐘的family interview 的確問唔到好多嘢。但學校係咪真想係3rd in 度搵出好smart 嘅小朋友，而決定收或備取呢? 我覺得唔係, 因為小朋友入到3rd in， 大家嘅水平理應好接近。CKY好著重家校合作，可能老師們會從3rd in 發問簡單的問題，來觀察或考慮呢個小朋友，甚至家庭適唔適合CKY.

（只屬個人睇法，不喜勿插）

woyj

原帖由 meowloo 於 16-12-15 發表
我們上年都是兩位老師接見，也有類似感覺：其中一位很HEA和面試很快完成；見到隔離GROUP和 ...

認同你所說的，揀學校應該整體來看, 不好為個別人士的不良行為影響最終決定。 我也希望這種hea 的態度只是那位老師吧了！

慶幸我的小朋友從不是她做班主任/老師, 只在一個場合遇上。

我想其他家長也寧選擇不投訴, 因為她已是senior teacher, 投訴後就算有結果, 其他老師一定知, 對自己的小朋友就算沒有標籤, 也有顧忌。 作為家長, 極可能忍一年就算, 好過以後幾年小朋友都有個tag 。 如果這情況發生在其他學校, 我認為也是同樣的選擇吧！

cwansze

  A

meowloo

woyj 發表於 16-12-15 16:49
認同你所說的，揀學校應該整體來看, 不好為個別人士的不良行為影響最終決定。 我也希望這種hea 的態度只是 ...

都係嘅。又或者老師對住自己班學生時，態度又會唔一樣。

woyj

原帖由 meowloo 於 16-12-15 發表
都係嘅。又或者老師對住自己班學生時，態度又會唔一樣。

希望係。
其實從未試過遇到咁冇耐性的老師, 我聽到都覺得好愕然。 入學到現在, 所遇到的大部分都很有耐性, 只有小部分耐性比較少( 重申是比較其他老師), 但也不至於打斷小朋友回答, 露出極不耐煩的樣子。 所以看到這帖，腦海裏就即時想起

woyj

另外, 樓上有家長話有4th 5th interview, 通常是沒有的。 上年有此經驗的家長以前在EK 有答, 是校方對在讀生的弟妹給予多一次機會才有4th in 。

harriet121

abby0624 發表於 16-12-13 10:11
By post around mid Jan 17

請問是老師說一月中嗎？聽說要二月中至尾才出結果(emoji)