大學提高門檻 篩走4,000學生

cmamum

elbar 發表於 16-11-14 08:55
■浸會大學傳理及商學課程將提高入學門檻，由3322+2變成3322+33。

想請問 港大, 中大, 科大, 城大, 理大, 係咪必要 332233，即2科選修科取得 3級成績？

若果考六科，其中五科 5* ，但餘下一個選修科得 2，咁係咪唔夠資格報上面5間大學？

cmamum

Mattison 發表於 16-11-16 10:47
如果我們要求我們的下一輩做好閱讀理解 請由自身開始 依上文而言 這個一定不是一個好問題了
...

What's the problem of my question?

cmamum

ANChan59 發表於 16-11-16 13:14
Those 4000 students may not have a space in past years.

I think this may not be correct.  

Those 4000 students mentioned in the article have obtained "3322+2 or above", but just not "3322+33", which means they could have obtained 5** in all 5 subjects.

Correct me if I am wrong :)

cmamum

ANChan59 發表於 16-11-16 14:39
The intakes are from high to low in scores, so no matter 33222 or 332233, that's mathematically poss ...

Of course I understand it’s not possible for those students who only meet the minimum requirements of obtaining 33222 or 332233, to enter universities through Jupas in HK.  I will never mix this up.

However in this article, the 4000 students are calculated as the difference between students who obtained “3322+2 or above” and “3322+33 or above”.  The main difference is the two elective subjects.

For example, Student A who got 5545+42 and Student B who got 5545+33. They both got a place to enter PolyU last year.

But in this coming year, only Student B could possibly get a place from PolyU, and not Student A, as the minimum requirements changed to 332233, which means the two elective subjects got to be both 3 or above.

Student A is ranked among the “33222 or above” group and Student B is ranked among the “332233 or above” group.

Student A could be one of the 4000 students who got a place last year, but not this year.

A "sift" from the change of minimum requirements.

cmamum

ANChan59 發表於 16-11-21 10:00
No matter what hypothetically possible from your argument, all spaces are from high to low.  Even 3 ...

Yes, you are correct that there is no chance to get a space for those meeting only the minimum requirements, no matter 33222 or 332233.  

My concern is someone like Student A who obtained 5545+42, who could get an offer from PolyU in the past years before the change, but not now.  

Some students may "suffer" from this change, even if they are good at the 4 core subjects but failed to get "33" in both of the electives, then they don't have a chance to get into or even apply to either HKU, CU, HKUST, City U or PolyU.

So the change does matter some of the students.

Thanks :)

cmamum

Mattison 發表於 16-11-22 14:17
The reason behind the change is, I believe, the sufferings and sometimes, the failures from the inta ...

Understood.  Thanks :)