ESF睇唔睇地址收生？

calvinlinda

如題。
拎畢架山為例，一個住何文田，一個住九龍塘，係咪九龍塘嗰個勝數高啲？

FattyDaddy

calvinlinda 發表於 16-8-6 22:51
係咪九龍塘嗰個勝數高啲？ ...

Officially no, the residential address is only used for determining which school the application should be forwarded to and plays no part in the assessment.
Unofficially nobody knows. I doubt it.

bforbtec

不看地址, 睇市值

你何文田, 愛民村 同 京士柏山 都是何文田

有個同學間屋地址是獨立屋市值8千萬,只考英文, 入year 9, 很快有通知

其他人仍在waiting list

但地址只佔收生少部份(你報公屋地址, 學校不敢收你, 怕你交不起學費), 主導

收生仍以成績

964000

原帖由 bforbtec 於 16-08-07 發表
不看地址, 睇市值

你何文田, 愛民村 同 京士柏山 都是何文田

我以為CIS 同GSIS先係

滑蛋河

我覺得無關係，感覺上大部份都係普通私人屋苑。

calvinlinda

原帖由 bforbtec 於 16-08-07 發表
不看地址, 睇市值

你何文田, 愛民村 同 京士柏山 都是何文田

如果一個租超豪宅，另一個自置好多層普通私樓，好難評喎！

type409

跨國公司CEO既屋多數係公司用10多萬月租的

Radiomama

原帖由 calvinlinda 於 16-08-06 發表
如題。
拎畢架山為例，一個住何文田，一個住九龍塘，係咪九龍塘嗰個勝數高啲？



  ...

建議先上網check清楚地址屬於那個catchment zone, 這與報哪一間ESF學校有関。

另外小孩的英語水平和能力最重要。

如果想爭取面試機會，不如買nomination right。

nintendo

calvinlinda 發表於 16-8-6 22:51
如題。
拎畢架山為例，一個住何文田，一個住九龍塘，係咪九龍塘嗰個勝數高啲？



  ...

As an ESF parent, I would say the answer is "no". They would not judge your address.
To be honest, ESF fees are not that expensive. So I do not think ESF would worried about people not able to pay.
Even if someone somehow no longer can afford, ESF can always ask whoever is on the waiting list to fill the place.

But of course, there are always people that want to convince you otherwise.
Especially those that are bitter about ESF for whatever reasons, and would say ESF reject students for reasons other than aptitude.

So, it is up to you what you want to believe.

calvinlinda

原帖由 nintendo 於 16-08-09 發表
As an ESF parent, I would say the answer is "no". They would not judge your address.
To be honest, ...

Thanks for your sharing!
To be an ESF parent, do u know the proportion among ESF kindy student and non-ESF kindy student? Are all ESF kindy students can eventually 'obtain' an ESF place in junior school?

MrsGM

原帖由 calvinlinda 於 16-08-11 發表
Thanks for your sharing!
To be an ESF parent, do u know the proportion among ESF kindy student and n ...

Over 90% I would say, got a spot in ESF junior.

Moonlight819

ESF Tsung Yi campus has about 99% last year.

Babybaby2011

原帖由 Moonlight819 於 16-08-11 發表
ESF Tsung Yi campus has about 99% last year.

All went to Kowloon junior school?

964000

原帖由 Moonlight819 於 16-08-11 發表
ESF Tsung Yi campus has about 99% last year.

May become less next year coz there is a new Tung Chung ESF kinder

nintendo

calvinlinda 發表於 16-8-11 07:57
Thanks for your sharing!
To be an ESF parent, do u know the proportion among ESF kindy student and n ...

All ESF kindy students get chance to interview.
Then you need to pass the interview to enter primary.
Heard that there are some that fail the interview.
Technically speaking, there are more primary places than number of kindergarten students.

If you are from other kindy, you need to wait until they finish interviewing ESF kinda kids.
Then you may have a chance for interview.
Again you need to pass interview.

nintendo

Babybaby2011 發表於 16-8-11 12:13
All went to Kowloon junior school?

According to where you live.
If you live in shatin, then Shatin Junior.

calvinlinda

So, how's the proportion between ESF kindly and non-ESF kindly in the junior school?

Osiana

ESF 小學有分區, 中學沒有.  即係如果你住九龍, 唔可以報香港區的ESF.

Activehealth

Osiana 發表於 16-8-24 17:19
ESF 小學有分區, 中學沒有.  即係如果你住九龍, 唔可以報香港區的ESF.

Deleted

jZmom

原帖由 nintendo 於 16-08-11 發表
All ESF kindy students get chance to interview.
Then you need to pass the interview to enter primar ...

Thanks Calvinlinda.

I note the policy changed a little couple years ago, and now it is back to allowing kids from kindergarten to have interview priority, correct?

And do the kinder parents still need to pay the 500k nomination fee in order to get a spot?