本年度St. CAT入讀PN (2016-2017) 統計分析

blackpuma

12尾超大B囡,
last day last min 交 form,
number 2XXX,
有first in 有 second in, 最終收了讀 AM 班，
所以我覺得交 form 時間同 number 無關係。

GetReal

本人看了所有表達及回覆, 甚至PO 文者, 私只可以說太好笑及誤導
1) St Cat一向都係全香港最有名及最好及最有競爭力的幼稚園之一, 多人考係正常不過
2) 點解需要提供這樣的數據誤導那些菜鳥家長. 過份
3) St Cat

GetReal

本人看了所有表達及回覆, 甚至PO 文者, 私只可以說太好笑及誤導
1) St Cat一向都係全香港最有名及最好及最有競爭力的幼稚園之一, 多人考係正常不過
2) 點解需要提供這樣的數據誤導那些菜鳥家長. 過份
3) St Cat一向都比較喜歡大B, 6,7月打後出生的比率是低的.

總之英文好, 有反應, 比較活, 會自動答回題是比較有優勢

GetReal

回覆 hilaryashley 的帖子

大錯特錯不要再誤導
那有一暑學校不存在關係這事
但絕對不是可否考進St Cat的主要成敗原因

Cutekillq

原帖由 hilaryashley 於 16-03-19 發表
我覺得應該係皇親國戚.... 入st cat 最緊要識人...同夠運~

有些不用2nd in 直入應該係識人，我唔信有咁多孖b. 邊個有save底2nd in 清單應該一目了然

Ann201403

事實係真係有人原本冇second in，之後因為返樓下playgroup, 而有得second in, 仲入埋！

vpo0615

其實無乜嘢可以拗, 大家當係一個參考啫, 始終我哋唔係學校中人, 學校用咩準則嚟收人, 大家都係估估吓, 無確實答案.

Cutekillq

原帖由 Ann201403 於 16-03-21 發表
事實係真係有人原本冇second in，之後因為返樓下playgroup, 而有得second in, 仲入埋！



  ...

之後返playgroup便有2nd in? Playgroup在什麼時候參加？

Ann201403

認同，冇人知點解

hilaryashley

原帖由 GetReal 於 16-03-21 發表
回覆 hilaryashley 的帖子

大錯特錯不要再誤導

我唔係好明你意思? 我身邊有幾個讀緊K2同K3同事個囡都係識人先入到st cat, 佢地親口承認, 佢地話但都要循例interview~ 呢個係不爭既事實, 點解係誤導?

入到名幼要有實力但都要講運氣, 都係事實~

Cutekillq

原帖由 hilaryashley 於 16-03-21 發表
我唔係好明你意思? 我身邊有幾個讀緊K2同K3同事個囡都係識人先入到st cat, 佢地親口承認, 佢地話但都要循例 ...

咁我都相信好多間學校都有咁情況，唔係話刻意扁低間學校。樓主既分析大家都係參考下......

GetReal

回覆 hilaryashley 的帖子

I said clearly it happens at MOST Top and Famous schoolsthe situation is even worse when you look at Primary Schools
Relationship is always a major element in Chinese society, especially at work.
However, look at how many students at each grade in St Cat
we are talking about more or less 800 students, but how many could get in just purely because of relationship
the percentage is less than 0.05%  

Cutekillq

原帖由 GetReal 於 16-03-22 發表
回覆 hilaryashley 的帖子

I said clearly it happens at MOST Top and Famous schoolsthe situation is e ...

那裡有數據少於0.05% 人靠關係入呢？

GetReal

回覆 Cutekillq 的帖子

Believe or not, it doesn't matter indeedNo harm
Then you may provide some numbers

People just dont like to listen facts, like the teens in nowadays
keep thinking people are telling lies
People always love to hear something no good and make challenge
funny people, funny society

HAYHIPPO

That's so true .

Lululuk

回覆 GetReal 的帖子

Just to share:

阿仔11月B, 今年 K1 PN 都有報, 無relationship ~~~~~~

K1 interview - very quiet, didn't speak at all though the teacher was so nice kept asking him and encouraging him. (well he is a talkative boy!!) waiting list

PN interview - very active, he was the number 3 child of the group but he shouted loudly the answers for number 1 to 5 students' questions.  he ran and danced with teacher, completed the task assigned by teacher (feeding the cat).  got accepted.

I personally dont think the K1 interview is any harder than the PN interview,   the difference is one-on-one vs group interview.   I dont know why my son didnt speak at all during K1 interview,   I personally think it is about luck - how your child is reacting during the interview, and most of the time we cannot control haha.

英文好, 有反應, 比較活, 會自動答回題是比較有優勢 - this is true on SC.  So the personality really matters.

GetReal

回覆 Lululuk 的帖子

做大B好過小仔特別考小一時你就會睇到分別

sailormercury

其實大家真係唔駛咁執著呢啲嘢...間間學校都有 discretion on admitting some students la, 就算好多神校小學的這類情況更嚴重，將來職場上不公平的待遇只有更多。我好懊悔自己細個時被灌輸“只有努力就會成功”，結果出到來做嘢先領教到一大班關係人士可以勁廢勁懶但又可以威過你惡過你。早啲認識到現實唔公平都係好事......

Guaichu

肯努力，父母又有心栽培的話，讀官立學校都可以入CAMBRIDGE。

ANNA5

用頭一百個號碼來仔細分析，
每隔一兩個號碼，什至連續幾個號碼的小朋友都會有second in.
根本學校已將學生分類而排號碼