舊油vs St.Paul Boys

Jane1983

回覆 Nath 的帖子

我覺得有吸引力，但一頭家、兩個仔會多野考慮，十幾年學費，細佬係咪一間學校好d等等……

rai_fc

I would pick spb.  
Little brother if lucky enough to get in spb, then you only play p1 game 1 time but no more f1 game.
If elder son pick Yau Tin, then you need to play f1 game twice!  A big headache!
Of course, if 2 boys goes to spb will put big financial burden to family, then is a different story.

karen55407

回覆 gilgil39 的帖子

SPB

Nath

回覆 Jane1983 的帖子

SPB 合條件係可以申請學費減免，另外亦有唔同類型既奬學金。不過若預計要外補幾科，就要計下條數可唔可以負擔。同埋細佬考時有得加分，入到機會又相對較易。其實，升中時2兄弟都唔一定會考到同一中學，到時行既路都唔會一樣。如果經濟許可，點解唔先安排好哥哥先呢？

IVISTSE

請問 SPB 有幾多％可以升中?

Nath

唔知多唔多人收到waiting call呢？

gilgil39

IVISTSE 發表於 15-6-29 22:58
請問 SPB 有幾多％可以升中?

聽校長話係合乎要求就上倒

小曳人

—般SEN支緩，津校比較好。但資優，你最好直接問用家！因為有D学校会—視同人，有D就有特别安排，不过如果有其他問題，学校点都要俾支缓

小曳人

另，資優兒如果做到績優，完全唔需要擔心中学！家長如果咁早已發現其特質，又对学習表現有信心，油天啦！

pharaoh

原帖由 gilgil39 於 15-06-29 發表
剛剛收到Spc call waiting, 開心但亦頭痛，因有細佬跟尾（資質一般），真心求意見怎選擇；吾比哥哥讀spc 好 ...

一定spc.  spc 課程比油天深，你看看spc 用家 "甘恩" 之前的分享吧！

spc 有中學backup, 你大仔績優的話六年後要去比st Paul college 更好的中学有難度嗎？當touchwood 都仲有st Paul college 做back up. 仲使諗？

弟弟考小一，spc 1st round 有10分加已有優勢。入到後兩兄弟不用煩升中，還是你想往後搏升中 x 2 ??

hkpapa852

gilgil39 發表於 15-6-29 14:38
剛剛收到Spc call waiting, 開心但亦頭痛，因有細佬跟尾（資質一般），真心求意見怎選擇；吾比哥哥讀spc 好 ...

自己諗下呢幾個問題:

1. 小朋友升學, 係小朋友一個人既事, 定係一家人既事?

2. 如果話唔俾阿哥讀SPB對佢唔公平, 咁掉番轉諗, 阿哥入咗SPB, 但細佬日後一間都考唔到仲抽中寶校, 咁係邊個攞走佢可以讀油天既機會?

3. 兩個小朋友係唔同學校讀書, 家庭能配合到嗎?

4. 經濟有壓力嗎?

5. 如兩個小朋友係同一學校讀書, 有機會"被比較", 有呢方面既考慮嗎?

我會搵一個對"家庭"最合適既方案, 而唔係盲目追求公平, 況且, 呢個世界沒有絶對既公平, 對阿哥公平時可能對細佬唔公平

Jane1983

回覆 hkpapa852 的帖子

講得好好。
這令我想到之前有家長問，應該將家裏所有資源比晒家姐交學費讀德望，亞妹抽到邊間讀邊間……後來睇回應，真係人人想法吾同，無對錯。

有能力、有運氣的哥哥，應吾應該幫無甘叻，亦吾知有無運的細路開路？真係 a million dollar question.

lepetitprincehk

I have similar situation and I finally have given up SPC-PS offer and chosen a regional famous public school.
As I have 2 daughters after my elder son. Entering a public school will allow us trouble free in coming years. I don't need to push hard on my daughters and troublesome in choosing Kindergarten and also P1 interviews.
I would rather save the time and efforts to can enjoy family time and let them have a more relax early childhood.
I don't think it is a big loss to my elder son because he also now can enter a tier 1 primary school whose majority of graduates can go to Band 1 Secondary Schools. If we trust our kid's ability, I think he will be able to find a Secondary School not worse than SPC in the future.
I also think allowing my son to study in a public school with more variety of kids from different background can help him to build up a more all around personality and ability.
Of course, SPC has some advantages over other general public schools. e.g. A big and new campus, more resources in extra-curricular activities, higher % of post graduated teachers etc. However, at the end, SPC is still a very traditional school with traditional way of teaching and learning actually.

奥脫福

要舊油，可能會嬴少左（哥哥），但一定唔會輸（兩兄弟）。

要ＳＰＢ，哥哥可能會嬴得好靚，但卻有可能會輸左細佬。呢個係高風險遊戲：
嬴左個大，但輸左頭家，值唔值呢？！

ppmmbb

奥脫福 發表於 15-6-30 10:53
要舊油，可能會嬴少左（哥哥），但一定唔會輸（兩兄弟）。

要ＳＰＢ，哥哥可能會嬴得好靚，但卻有可能會輸 ...

但如果哥哥知道SPB收佢，佢又想讀，但屋企唔比佢讀，哥哥會點諗？要小心處理！

gilgil39

好多謝大家比左咁多意見！呢個問題真係好頭痛，我真係諗到喊不過都會盡快同爸爸決定。歡迎大家繼續発表！

keep-calm

我會揀舊油：1,舊油世世代代也可世襲，兩兄弟將來的子女也受惠。2,慳番的學費可上其他資優増潤課程，如2兄弟都私小學費負擔不輕。3, 小朋友去到考中學的歲數，有冇書緣已經大致可以睇到，如天資好的舊油/SPB一樣可以裝備小朋友更上一層樓；如天資一般，讀Paul boys 小即使可升上Paul boys 中，夾硬上又是否好事？

Babyarsene

原帖由 gilgil39 於 15-06-30 發表
好多謝大家比左咁多意見！呢個問題真係好頭痛，我真係諗到喊不過都會盡快同爸爸決定。歡迎大家繼續 ...

好現實的問題，唔理對邊個公平先，你afford得到嗎？

Babyarsene

原帖由 Babyarsene 於 15-06-30 發表
好現實的問題，唔理對邊個公平先，你afford得到嗎？

我講錢