沙田嘉德麗 Vs 馬鞍山Greenfield Vs HKPS

bettyysf

大家對呢三間學校有何評價？會點排？

poonmc

我都想知。因已收greenfield am and 嘉德麗 pm

bettyysf

same here, Catiline am and Greenfield am

calvinlinda

Of course catiline! 沙田top校，gf only well known in mos..
Per my personal exp, catiline is much better than gf, in terms of teacher, school exp and syllbus.
Gf only better than catiline in terms of 語境。

bettyysf

回覆 calvinlinda 的帖子

That's what I think, but I don't understand why many MOS mama said that GF is better

calvinlinda

Because it is near their home, no need school bus or transportation.
I am mos mama too, i will choose catiline if i got yhese 2 options..
For me, i am thinking about international school or local school, instead of gf or catiline...
If u will study the kindergarten until k3, the next u will think about primary school issue... Catiline student is more famous than gf in primary school principals, in case u need to 叩門，it helps u.

yeemw

三間学費差不多，如果係我，我会揀hkps同gf. 英文环境最好，第時考直資和扣門都易d. 而且，hkps名氣最大，直資学校有着數。hkps同 gf 校舍一定好过嘉德丽，新d. 嘉德丽好殘舊，又細，又近街市。

同埋嘉德丽話沙田d校長好鐘意佢地学生，都係个校長自己講，而且小学收生是計分或攪珠，与幼稚園無关，只有扣門是有用的。但如果間小学扣門時考英語会話，hkps同 gf学生一定会有優勢。嘉德丽只是中文好，自己係屋企教都得，唔值貢貴去学中文。

manfaiho

我会揀am 班，因為時間好用好多，訓完晏覺下午仲可以去学興趣班或去公園玩。而且訓晏覺对小朋友好重要，可幫助腦部發展，大過会聰明d。曾经有个朋友為了学校名氣俾个小朋友返下午班，个细路上堂時訓覺同無精神，乜都学唔到，勁後悔。

beanie430

請問有沒有媽媽可以分享一下（mos greenfield vs mos Boxhill vs 嘉德麗，all am offer)？我希望囡囡讀完n班後，k1考九龍一些名幼，target直資小學，感激萬分！

yeemw

考直資和名校k1, 英文和小朋友的表達能力很重要，mos boxhill最好，全英及普通話授課，小朋友两文三語较强，又活动教学，小朋友会敢於表達，其次gf, 課程同boxhill差不多，但gf 名氣稍不夠boxhill。嘉德丽太傳統，重視古文和中文，小朋友雖然会坐定定，但interview時英文底子不夠或過於被动，会較蝕底。

beanie430

多謝你的分享，應該Boxhill 了

貝珠

We share the same thought. Our children will be classmates.

Theone111

貝珠 發表於 14-11-26 13:13
We share the same thought. Our children will be classmates.

Me 3