培正vsCCKG點㨂

CasperChan75

naughtybj 發表於 14-4-28 11:20
As I know, CCKG has changed the principal, are you sure the relationship with DBS remains the same?  ...

Yes, true, CCKG has no principal now, only a supervisor called Rev. Ross Royden who is one of the current school committee member of DBS.

http://www.dbs.edu.hk/index.php?section=administration&sub=schoolcommittee

The 7th one under Committee Members in the above link.

CasperChan75

ccy1009hk 發表於 14-4-28 09:33
回覆 DCMaMe 的帖子

Dear,

To be honest, the Chinese standard of CCKG is really low, but the English standard is excellent.

On the contrary, PC has a more balanced development and no need to apply for P1 again.

Think if you are wasting your kid's time if he study K1 again?  If you want a stable path for him/her, then PC should be your choice.

CCKG cannot guarentee your kid to go to DBS or DGS, but i think other than these 2 schools, CCKG graduates would go to the top schools in HK.

If your kid is already bored with the K1 class now, why do you need him/her to stay for another boring year?  However, if he still cannot catch up the K1 curriculum, PC is suitable for him/her as he can have 1 more year for the K1 class again.

Its really difficult to make the decision, let us know when you have the final decision, cheers.

CasperChan75

回覆 ccy1009hk 的帖子

Please read read another post:


下學期離開一條龍，返回LH
http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2741985&fromuid=952703



Choose the one which is suitable for your kid, rather than it's just a 一條龍 school.

angie_mama

其實，睇樓主回應，大膽問一句，「唔試CCKG會否唔心息？日後去了培正都哽住哽住？」如果係，不必船頭驚鬼船尾驚賊，去CCKG啦，計乜風險＆assessment也irrelevant. 這裏沒有人能guarantee 説你孩子有乜characteristic 會細B都入DBS....即使今天DBS校長也不能答你，誰能預知未來？CCKG**不是**DBS附屬幼稚園是鐵一般的事實，培幼**是**培正小學附屬幼稚園人所共知。如不去CCKG你覺得是不能踏半隻腳入DBS門的話，何須hesitate ? DBS via CCKG > DBS via PC 不用置疑，如target DBS，可早早放PC位，功德無量。當養孩子是investment 的話，計ROl，一定是少交一年repeat K1加早一年出社會搵錢好，payback period 都快d啦(assume 幼稚園小學中學大學都不留班)，但，為孩子係咪咁嘅formula計？there's no quantitative analysis for child development, as it involves soooooooo many uncertainties and parameters (淨係考DBS嗰日病咗都收檔啦，邊有得計讀邊間幼稚園？! )中國人有句話「吃得鹹魚抵得渴」，不過建議問下老公係咪一齊願意承擔後果，這不是你一個人的決定，咁你壓力一定少50%。知道自己要乜走咩路嘅家長，至會**有機會**引領到孩子去「目的地」，當然，還要天時、地利、人和。中學時讀過一句「坐這山、望那山，一事無成。」我自覺，語言在於思想與溝通，英文重要，但中文更難學，但details不在這裏詳述，off topic。

Lulu0820

搭訕，其實好簡單一句：介唔介意中文中學？

幼稚園已經講中學，好似好遙遠，但入咗培正好多小朋友都唔捨得走，所以家長誠實回答以上題目，就知應該點簡。

ccy1009hk

I am really glad and appreciate that there are so many intelligent and thoughtful parents in this platform. Really thankful for taking the time finding and sharing the information with me.

macmate

敢問樓主目前係點樣培育小朋友操流利英語?最後決定怎樣?點都好，有一點我想提一提，品德培育對樓主有多重要?坦白講，dxs英語一定勝培正，但品德方面培正反勝係好明顯，當然一切仍以家庭環境影響最大

macmate

講多少少，dxs全港的而且確係神級，小朋友普遍性格愛拼愛贏，鍾意爭第一同認叻;相反培正人比較純樸謙卑，樓主想自己小朋友係邊種?dxs需要小朋友除了學術有成績，亦要體藝有非凡成就;培正有培育同學們有國際視野，但相比要求起來應該比較簡單。樓主又有沒有心理準備及強大資金作後盾?以上均值得參考。

chichiho

點解啲家長成日認為讀培正英文會唔好？
難道讀英文學校嘅英文一定好？

Lulu0820

英文或中文好唔好唔關讀邊間學校事，主要睇自己點讀

但培正係中文中學，用中文教學係事實，咁如果家長介意係真係應該諗清楚

利申：我兩個小朋友都讀培正，大既已經升中，so far 我滿意學校

DCMaMe

回覆 ccy1009hk 的帖子

樓主，唔好意思咁遲才回覆你。其實細B可能在一些發展上未及大B，但是否所有細B如是？好似你小朋友的Case，我相信好多大B都有去考CCKG，但學校最終係選擇左你小朋友。其實每間學校都有細B，咁考小一時CCKG的細B，比其他幼稚園的細B，你又覺得如何？而又是否所有細B都沒有好的Offer？
如你只target DBS，其實CCKG 細B或培正都未必係最好選擇，當然CCKG成數始終都係高D。 不過如果你可接受其他Top 的小學如CKY，YW，LS ，SPCC（可能都比較難）或次小小的 SFA，TSL，宣道等，其實CCKG的training，會相當唔錯。但是要得到那些學校的Offer，家長們也不能袖手旁觀，好好培養小孩的品德和一些學術要求。要是知道，CCKG本身收的學生就是有Potential而不是那些靠谷出來的，所以要相信你自己小朋友，給他所需要的，慢慢培養，一個有禮，有自信，有內涵的小孩，去到那裡也是受歡迎的。

當然你還需要去考慮你們是否真正喜歡培正，坦白講入左培正，你未必會出來再考其他小學，原因好多，不在此詳談，你要明白這可能會是你小孩未來15年就讀的學校，所以你們一定要清楚自己是否喜歡培正和它的教學理念。
在EK我想信培正的Fans比較多，相對CCKG的家長較少，或許是因為家長郡有所不同的原因，這點也可作參考。因為同學的家長郡，會大概知道同學們的家庭教育背景，你要知道CCKG的家長可以係Eason Chan's couple, 林海𡶶同彭玲，任達華，一些官員的仔女，或一些有錢人的兒女，當然亦有中產家庭的家長，不過大家都係有禮謙虛的。有些人會擔心，有些人會自在，這只是一個其中因素，但亦是不可輕視的因素。

CasperChan75

ccy1009hk 發表於 14-4-28 21:36
I am really glad and appreciate that there are so many intelligent and thoughtful parents in this pl ...

Do you mind to tell if your kid is currently studying in the Kowloon Tong Kinder like SC, KV or just study in kinder with study voucher?

Why do i ask such a question?

If its the former, it means you are an aggressive parent.

Think about why did you apply for CCKG and PC for your kid last year?  Is your kid happy in his current K1 kinder?
If it's really difficult to make a choice between CCKG and PC, would you consider to stay in his/her current kinder simply because he is happy with the classmates and teachers?

ccy1009hk

Thanks for the comprehensive analysis. Could not think of a word to express how grateful I am in receiving all your candid comment. Really useful to me.

I have a strong believe that it is better for both parent and the child be a big B rather than a small one, building up ones' confidence in the upbringing is important. And practically, it's serve some advantage when come to the P1 interview. Thus, I had decided to repeat K1 in the beginning.

To answer Casper your question, my child only received a few K1 offer last year (as the small B) and lucky enough he received more K1 offer this year, including the above 2 you mentioned. It's ascertain my belief that bigger b is more competitive.

I would say I am very much like other parent, will provide them different extra-curricula activity and ready to gear them up in sport, musical and communication skill for getting into a good P1 school. (The fundamental is having a good moral standard together with personal core value). Not meant to be stereotype, you can consider me as an aggressive one so to speak.  
  

qualcomm

原帖由 naughtybj 於 14-04-21 發表
【明報專訊】傳統名校拔萃男書院新任校長鄭基恩昨會見傳媒表示，該校首屆新高中學生成功升讀本地及海外的大 ...

佢連中文字都係返DPS教音樂先學

不過DB以前得三份一入中六，也不是100%讀到大學

連lB平均都係band one尾quality

會考0分每年都有10個8個，DSE7成人入到大學已有進步

CasperChan75

qualcomm 發表於 14-4-30 21:03
佢連中文字都係返DPS教音樂先學

不過DB以前得三份一入中六，也不是100%讀到大學

the last 2 rows of info seems not correct.
ib of dbs has an average score near 40 out of 44 last year.

in the past day with hkcee, though there were some weak students in dbs, their english are still good, there should not be 8 to 10 students score 0 in hkcee.

macmate

原帖由 CasperChan75 於 14-05-03 發表
the last 2 rows of info seems not correct.
ib of dbs has an average score near 40 out of 44 last yea ...

yes, i knew a db boy scored 5 all from english in hkcee.  others were 0

CasperChan75

macmate 發表於 14-5-3 17:52
yes,  scored 5 all from english in hkcee.  others were 0

oh then, how is that boy now?

macmate

原帖由 CasperChan75 於 14-05-04 發表
oh then, how is that boy now?

he repeated then went overseas for futher study.  now working in a bank.  i can't say he is very good now but much better than most people.