今年DSE考題：必要的沈默

chumiguan

今年DSE考題, 應該令更多家長出走逃難到IS.
真想哎救命！香港下一代將淪陷為咩嘅一代！好驚！

jolalee

中方在香港回歸十五年突然提出國民教育，你話阿爺冇一個五十年漸變的時間表？我唔信! 所以選IS時，我聆願放棄一間有質素的IS小學，都要堅持要一間小學冇咁好的IS龍校，因為，我怕數年後香港入IS中學會是風腥血雨的景況！

amethyst123

今日嘅LS已經唔係我哋當年嘅LS

小冬姑

speechless!  Really shame on the education system in HK.

jolalee

If one looks into the exam question long enough, it really is a wise question which requires the students' use of imagination, judgement and wisdom. It is true that there are tunes when keeping silent is a better choice (I always rember the story of a family on the metro where the kids where yelling and acting out so people on the train were scolding the dad, only to find out their mother just died). Anyhow it is one of the three options presented so the students may choose to answer two other questions. However, with the current sensitive political climate in HK, the exam board really didn't consider well enough the publics' reaction to this question. The question is itself is full of wisdom, but the board of examiners who picked this question at this time, on the other hand, is a bit foolish.

MM2H

chumiguan 發表於 14-4-8 23:21
今年DSE考題, 應該令更多家長出走逃難到IS.
真想哎救命！香港下一代將淪陷為咩嘅一代！好驚！



  ...

其實呢條題目都唔係太大問題，唔一定要演繹至同政治扯上闗係，可以用不同角度解答，但當然要下一步評核番改卷員定分標準為何才能再下判斷。
但今日條通識題就真係直指政治環境，仲要求學生例出現今香港社會2大核心價值矛盾，廣泛之餘亦必會於作答上扯上政治偏向，有點心寒。

964000

會不會稔多左呀？保持沈默，可以把日常小事寫成小品，例如見到有老人家偷野，出於憐憫我保持沈默，吾一定同政治扯上關係

jolalee

回覆 964000 的帖子

以現時香港的政治氣候，怎能叫人不會唸多咗？
我相信考試局本身係冇心嘅 ，但真的缺乏智慧。
（事先察覺到的話仲咁蠢print條試題出黎俾人插咩？）
問題係學生同家長睇完點唸。
People will always see what they want to see.