同一時間學鋼琴＆小提琴

bebebe12345

開始是沒有甚麼必然的沖突，主要在於孩子練琴的時間和家長陪伴與負擔的能力。最重要是跟着甚麼老師!我所有孩子開始時都是學二樣，到了某個時候就會各自各精彩!主次自然會分。

BB_Girl

原帖由 henryho4h 於 13-10-13 發表
想請教一下你的孩子是在什麼年紀及情況分到主次的？

我女兒7 yrs 分到了，現在只keep cello.  停了piano.

bebebe12345

henryho4h 發表於 13-10-13 18:11
想請教一下你的孩子是在什麼年紀及情況分到主次的？

大囡囡二年級才開始學、三年級已分主次、但鋼琴仍彈至六年級考了八級!
第二、三基本是五歲幾鋼琴己成定局,但小提琴拉學校Orchastra至中學畢業。
細囝未學已定鋼琴、中學停小提琴,大學主修鋼琴,今年棄鋼琴選Vocal。

最主要原因............老師!

marble2004

回復 fwan1213 的帖子

My daughter is learning both violin and piano and the same time.  No conflict at all.  I don't really ask her to take exam.  I just want her to enjoy learning musical instrument.  However, this year, her teacher suggests her to take violin exam.  I struggle a bit as I just want her to learn, really no need to take exam.  But it's up to my daugther to decide herself.  If she wants, I won't say no as long as she could cope with her study.  

jellomama

bebebe12345 發表於 13-10-13 21:48
大囡囡二年級才開始學、三年級已分主次、但鋼琴仍彈至六年級考了八級!
第二、三基本是五歲幾鋼琴己成定局, ...

四個孩子學樂器，勁！

bigyanb

我學生兩樣學，過了五級，今年13歳

marcuscyrus

my son learns both, turning 8 next feb, still progressing for both instruments yet i think he wont major in either at the moment.  havent take exam for both after g3.  will keep learning in the near future.  

小藍莓

我的小朋友剛今年開始加入小學的小提琴班, 另外他上年開始學琴, 還未有參加過任何比賽及考試, 可能比較其他遲一點, 不過先培養興趣是好緊要的。

beetle

對於返本地全日制的高小學生真的很難，都不知如何找時間練。

marcuscyrus

beetle 發表於 13-10-15 14:06
對於返本地全日制的高小學生真的很難，都不知如何找時間練。

對個阿媽都好難，不知如何找時間接接送送+練

rogerlam123

八級前應沒問題，八級後真係要用多好多時間，去到AT的話，我個人認為都算幾盡。

beetle

原帖由 marcuscyrus 於 13-10-15 發表
對個阿媽都好難，不知如何找時間接接送送+練

titibaby

我就minor 那樣唯有進度慢些，長假才多些練，不過找這樣能包容的老師，就不能有要求啦

bebebe12345

titibaby 發表於 13-10-16 09:26
我就minor 那樣唯有進度慢些，長假才多些練，不過找這樣能包容的老師，就不能有要求啦 ...

你和beetle的囡囡早己是分了主次,主的要求多自然也花時間多、次的也並不是要放棄,keep住就好.....

titibaby

原帖由 bebebe12345 於 13-10-16 發表
你和beetle的囡囡早己是分了主次,主的要求多自然也花時間多、次的也並不是要放棄,keep住就好.....

...

本來都常想放棄但去年mf 又好彩有獎，又有些動力

Junko

回復 fwan1213 的帖子

My boy, now 12 years old, has been learning both violin and piano since age 4. He just completed G8 violin exam and is planning to take the G8 piano exam next year. He joined the school orchestra since P2 and he just joined the school orchestra in his secondary school.

Parents need to put extra efforts in the early stage, e.g. to accompany the kids in practising, to create a happy atmosphere during practising time, make practising like playing game, then your kids will enjoy music. A good beginning is very important. Practising will become a habit.

Parents' support is the main successful key, both in terms of efforts and money. Also need to find a good teacher, otherwise, you will waste your kid's time.

I don't know if my boy get any plannings in music in future, he just said he will still keep both at the moment and his next target for violin is ATCL or DipABRSM.

四隻貓

我女六歲, 都係同時學小提琴同鋼琴. 小提琴應該係主, 曾經想放棄鋼琴, 因為實在唔夠時間練習, 不過最後都堅持住.
最緊要唔介意個進度, 慢慢學, 每次學少少, 始終係會學到野.
鋼琴老師有要求但會盡量體諒我地. .

titibaby

羨慕有d 有天分小朋友真的兩樣都能出色。一定是本身領悟力強，能事半功倍那種