以一間無直屬中學的小學來計, 幾多%入到Band 1英中才算理想

ANChan59

原帖由 ha8mo 於 13-06-15 發表
某校貼上網的剪報

好嘢！咁都俾你搵到。

我以前冇咁大想頭，50%英中已經十分滿意，100%冇諗過！

cmir

回復 feiji 的帖子

but when i checked the school website...it's only around 60% for Band 1 英中. Please correct me if i am wrong

Bluegene

原帖由 ha8mo 於 13-06-15 發表
李鄭屋官立係南亞之星，大部分學生都要搵英中

擊中核心

Bluegene

我覺得有50%以上入Band1都好叻

feiji

回復 cmir 的帖子

cmir, I didn't verify his data.  I guess maybe it is not up-to-date then.  I guess 50% - 60% is already very good.

cmir

回復 feiji 的帖子

that's true, especially it's a govt aided school.

iantsang

回復 cmir 的帖子

I think there are few things to clarify:

(1) There are no banding on schools, neither secondary not primary schools, banding are only applied on P.6 students for their S1 allocation;

(2) A secondary school with all classes using English as medium of instructions may not be band 1, if they are under Direct Subsidized Scheme;

(3) A secondary school even if all classes using English as medium of instructions, can accept some band 2 students;

So basically if a school claims they have certain percentages entering EMI schools, usually I will discount about 10-20%, depends on what type of schools these students go to (aided or DSS), then this will be closer to the percentage of the school's band 1 student%.

For an aided school, above 40-45% is already good (considering turning 10% of band 2 to band 1 or swapping band 3 out with band 1 students in over the years :p), and above 50% for private schools is consider satisfactory.

ANChan59

回復 iantsang 的帖子

Agree.
Some schools list out all placements in their websites, we can see the standard of those schools.

pooh仔

原帖由 ha8mo 於 13-06-15 發表

你個表嘅小學升英中比率9x% ~ 100%

taktakchichi

最有透明度係APS, SFA 同TSL, 升中派位都可以係網站睇到. 佢
地升上 Band 1 英中比率都好高, 尤其APS同TSL