【視頻】上品無寒門？（鏗鏘集）

mirage

Junko 發表於 13-6-5 13:46
回復 mirage 的帖子

Just wish to clarify that only 1 parent joining the tour. The DBxPD robotics tea ...

What I known was only 1 parent joined the whole tour but half  of the parents did go to Germany also by themsleves coz they have a better ticket/stay perference. (e.g. business class/go nearby city first then to the venue)
What we need for education is not this kind of splendid oversea competition for limited number of students. And this is a waste of resources in some meant. I dont think any aided/goverment school can support this kind of tour. Or if they have this kind of extra resources, I think they will have hundred kind of different spending options.

ohnono

talent2000  You are not up to this level. This is why you still are turning around yourself so far. Sorry if this is not "your tea", just forget it.

--------------------

Yes，you are right，may be i am not up to your level，as i would certainly not put 「骨氣」，an very abstract thing， in my priority to choose school。As I knew even I chose no matter a government school or a government aid school ，I am still getting the welfare from the society.

I am not 「聖人」，just like other parents，I only think which school will best fit my children and which school will have the most chance，that's all。

mirage

ohnono 發表於 13-6-5 17:56
talent2000  You are not up to this level. This is why you still are turning around yourself so far.  ...

Getting fee remission scheme from a DSS is partially getting benefits from other parents who do not get fee remession, I think no one will object this.Getting grant/loan from University is getting welfare from the society, I think everyone will agree this.
This is what talent2000 meant 「骨氣」 in my opinion.

cathyming1

唔好勞氣，我之前講過某人言論BK家長見怪不怪，詞不達意，引用之前家長話，心胸狹窄，鬼叫學校收我唔收你，金句我唔會比小兒讀，收你咩，s學校最錯唔係直資，係唔收伛，哈哈，大家心水清家長有留意BK都知一講SPCC就會飛撲出來講什麽富二代，校長有鄉音，等等，唔祗其它學校都一樣，什麽屋X學校，連張祝X都問人出過D什麼領袖，埃好心你拉，學下尊重大家，有D修養，尊重下其他學校。

HKTHK

回復 cathyming1 的帖子

Thank you for the reminder.  Remember him now.  Same comment as I have for ohnono, "有骨氣，冇EQ，一樣無用!"  I guess the emphasis should be on the middle part  

Mukchilee

www 發表於 13-6-5 11:09
請問校方怎樣歧視窮學生呢？
校方為什麼要這樣做？

真係無時間又打一次咁多字....前面我有講, 有時間可以睇一睇, 謝謝

HKTHK

回復 mirage 的帖子

Actually I don't see the difference.  DSS schools charges tuition and gets funding from government.  Universities also charges tuition and gets funding from government.  Money is fungible and they cannot really be distinguished. How is one getting welfare from society and the other not?  What am I missing here?

ANChan59

Choose a best fit school is the priority.

cathyming1

下!學費減免=支援=計缩数，好優質學校变成偷東西回家，再变借錢不還，犀利，想像力豐富，引證我果句詞不達意，有小小驚，會唔會仙人有???

www

talent2000 發表於 13-6-5 18:02
見到好多人伸手支援係應該的，咁年輕自己有能力去找工作養家活儿又只識計縮數連個小孩也知道點計支助來的多出來的怎樣用，可惜呀！
所以人的質素就是這樣嗎？
再舉个例給大家參考一下，有一間有好优質學校，有人見到其他同學的東西，喜歡的就偷回家，借錢不還等行為，這就是家庭教育及質素的問題，明白嗎？

Mukchilee

HKTHK 發表於 13-6-5 18:37
回復 mirage 的帖子

Actually I don't see the difference.  DSS schools charges tuition and gets fundi ...

其實佢會唔會係咁嘅意思: 你讀官津及讀大學, 政府庫房資助你一份錢. 不過如果你讀直資又唔交足學費, 咁就即係政府資助完你一份錢之後, 再由其他比足全數嘅家長資助你讀書呢? (我都係試下估下佢嘅意思, 估錯勿插)

tttw1

假設性問題。如果全港中小學都是官校。所有課程，教育語言都劃一，有身份證就有得讀。而且學生再沒有banding。咁係咪就可以解決所有問題？咁係咪就係公平？

tttw1

如果你反對以上的假設。咁再討直資是否公平係咪有點多餘？

ANChan59

原帖由 tttw1 於 13-06-05 發表
假設性問題。如果全港中小學都是官校。所有課程，教育語言都劃一，有身份證就有得讀。而且學生再沒有bandin ...

睇下北區小學的學生參差程度，點教呀！:;pppp:

HKTHK

回復 tttw1 的帖子

Not sure if it is good, but everyone is going to be average

Bluegene

ANChan59 發表於 13-6-5 20:04
睇下北區小學的學生參差程度，點教呀！

官津小學係一定係程度參差，唔係北區獨有。一般學校都預咗要補底啦。私小直資就可揀人，不過未必冇揀錯。

www

Bluegene 發表於 13-6-5 20:25
官津小學係一定係程度參差，唔係北區獨有。一般學校都預咗要補底啦。私小直資就可揀人，不過未必冇揀錯。
...

程度參差，區區都有；兩非學童，北區特別多。

Bluegene

www 發表於 13-6-5 13:58
同意！
很多人話學校歧視家庭收入低的家庭，但學校怎知道你的家庭收入呢？
而且，很多直資都講明，家長只 ...

學校冇歧視低收入的家庭，係家長被學費嚇怕遮。若果見門口架架名車，個個司機管家接送，門高狗大，基層家長真係要有勇氣。

ANChan59

回復 Bluegene 的帖子

你誤會啦。
我講的差是英文字母不識，自理能力都缺乏的部份跨境學童！