York PN 2013 - [Exception Case] letter for Small B? - 幼校討論

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1139

21^#

發表於 13-1-21 12:21 |只看該作者

認為YORK是有心教好小朋友的~

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1587

22^#

發表於 13-1-21 12:38 |只看該作者

回覆：York PN 2013 - [Exception Case] letter for Small B

I dont really agree ....why some small ball straight to K1...while some others need to have special arrangement.....

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1587

23^#

發表於 13-1-21 12:39 |只看該作者

引用：I+dont+really+agree+....why+some+small+b

原帖由 kissobaby 於 13-01-21 發表
I dont really agree ....why some small ball straight to K1...while some others need to have special ...

Sorry...is small B not small ball

TeriAnla

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1764

24^#

發表於 13-1-21 12:56 |只看該作者

回覆：York PN 2013 - [Exception Case] letter for Small B?

其實我覺得如果你唔認同呢間學校，禁咪唔好apply咯。我囝囝係大B, 由申請到收到offer都係on schedule, 亦係第一志願PN PM offer. 我覺得學校很好，安排很好。唔需要限時限刻交form, 唔使排隊，interview由一大group開始玩到individual, 囝囝warm up晒。校園大資源充足，我很滿意。

aokiwong

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1863

25^#

發表於 13-1-21 13:49 |只看該作者

引用：我識既朋友裡頭有2個收到k1+offer.....1個o

原帖由 kissobaby 於 13-01-21 發表
我識既朋友裡頭有2個收到k1 offer.....1個oct bb另一個nov bb.....咁佢地又唔需要training?

...

Hi both of your friends received letter today?

OSMrLai

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	136

26^#

發表於 13-1-21 14:14 |只看該作者

TeriAnla 發表於 13-1-21 09:53
其實如果你唔係太心儀呢間學校，又覺得麻煩，何必勉強。不去就是了。試問如果個個家長打去，啲staff又講啲 ...

I do not think anybody would have any offense to York here but so far when I read your post and I knew yougot a pn offer from York,I think you need to concern those who still have not received any letter yet.It is understandable that they are so nervous and would have some questionsabout the arrangement of the offers. I just felt you would make them a bituncomfortable if you wrote such words.

It is certainly not easy to get an offer from York. However it is much easier to get a “PM”nursery offer for local district private kindergarten. Add Oil to the parentswho are still waiting and I believe more seats will be released in a laterperiod

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1587

27^#

發表於 13-1-21 14:35 |只看該作者

引用：Quote:原帖由+kissobaby+於+13-01-21+發表

原帖由 aokiwong 於 13-01-21 發表
Hi both of your friends received letter today?

Received last week

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1587

28^#

發表於 13-1-21 14:48 |只看該作者

回覆：York PN 2013 - [Exception Case] letter for Small B

我不想鬧交....但遇到有奇怪既情況，大家評論下，分享下，係好正常不過。

如果一有意見就話唔好申請，好似誇張左。

我申請既時候未預計到有d咁既情況，我上EK討論係因為我仲有思想。唔會盲目接受所有學校任何安排，所以我會留意。

我可以唔分享我知道既情況，但係我都想其他mama知道多d...呢個唔係就係EK既功用咩？！

點評

bbqueendom

發表於 13-1-21 15:00

TeriAnla

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1764

29^#

發表於 13-1-21 15:19 |只看該作者

回覆：York PN 2013 - [Exception Case] letter for Small B?

如果太家誤會了，不好意思。我的comment唔係講樓主的，我就係明白未有信的等得好心急，收到信又唔明學校想點，好想有mama分享。所以見到有人reply學校係人都有，學校騎呢，麻煩，其實我好不滿。我想講呢啲說話應該都係人考佢考，很lucky有offer就話學校係人都收。

我囝囝有offer, 我認為得來不易，我絕不同意係有錢就收。對有PN offer想讀同好想讀又未收到信的媽媽好唔公平。我由囝囝有offer開始，就不停有人叫我唔好讀，不停聽負面評語。

我覺得學校收生好認真亦係好學校。如果你地認同，要加油啊。學校肯同你解釋安排，就係想同家長溝通好，先叫你地決定。總好過出完信俾你，你又唔知即係咩就要決定。十卜十卜你地。

點評

miracleinlife

發表於 13-1-23 18:17

karinepig

發表於 13-1-21 19:12

OSMrLai

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	136

30^#

發表於 13-1-21 15:54 |只看該作者

Actually, EVERYBODY is giving out the hardship but unfortunately, the rule is there. In is not avoidable that “Small b” is treated at a lower priority of given an offer.
I do not think it is necessary to be angry with the gossip of “everybody will have an offer once submitted the application”. Parents who applied York must know it is needed to go through a selection process before their kid is accepted by York. It is not wise to have any anger with such tiny gossip as the truth is out there.
Honestly speaking, whether accepted or not somehow depends on BOTH luck and the performance, half and half. Some kids could answer all the questions but only get a K1 offer because they are “Small b”. Two kids had the same performance but assessed by different teachers may have different results. This kind of unfairness will always happen when the kids grow up. So take it easy and you would be happier.

tiffany168168

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1893

31^#

發表於 13-1-21 16:27 |只看該作者

回覆：TeriAnla 的帖子

你咁認同學校咁你係咪會放棄你另外八個offers而揀York? I saw somewhere u said your son has received 9 offers out of 11 applications.

tiffany168168

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1893

32^#

發表於 13-1-21 16:28 |只看該作者

回覆：tiffany168168 的帖子

This is for TeriAnla.

TeriAnla

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1764

33^#

發表於 13-1-21 16:57 |只看該作者

回覆：tiffany168168 的帖子

我只係認為如果apply了呢間學校，就要follow佢地嘅安排而已。正如好多名幼都唔接受細B申請一樣。係而家嘅offer中，呢間係比較迎合我家的需要，所以暫時都會選擇呢間。我亦有留過言我會繼續考餘下的學校，因為我一直嘅approach都係自己同囝囝去學校睇下。希望唔會令大家唔開心。我亦冇意討論有幾多offer, 我認為呢個時代，間間比較有名就算地區出名幼稚園都競爭激烈，大家亦好明白有offer唔代表叻啲。有邊個覺得呢個遊戲唔辛苦，呢個遊戲規則公平呢？只係活在香港又係冇分人事，所以先無何奈何而已。