71間於自行收生階段出現世襲超額情况小學名單(2013)

carchu12

感激！很有用!這2屆都有留意你的數据

chengkiwi

對，八百幾為自行加統一

daisy17772

Thank you so much.  So useful!

littlelamma

好多都是受歡迎的熱門小學.

bbtammy

iantsang 發表於 13-1-9 18:23
哈哈，統稱唧！唔好意思！

因數據分唔開是否世襲兩種情況。

O~ IC, 請問我可以咁理解嗎？表中71間學校就算有25分在手都唔洗去抽, 因為所有自行分配學位嘅QUOTA都已經比晒「必收生」, 所以得25或20分嘅去抽根本就冇位，而學校餘下嘅學位會用作統一派位。

CoffeeCake

好似係”必收生”如在自行階段多過SET左既限額，學校就會動用原本預比統一派位既學位填上喎。
所以，必收生係唔會侵蝕留比計分人用既位。
唔知啱唔啱？
當然，如果25分既人比DAY 1留比計分位既人更多，就25分都入唔晒了。

CoffeeCake

我諗緊未來會唔會癲到連動用埋所有統一派位既學位都唔夠比”必收生”，尤其本身學位少既學校。

魚王

柴米得番46位，凍過水

adakitty

元朗超咁多既...
咁北區去左邊??

dlee_ca

兄弟姊妹同校制度沒有問題，父母畢業生加分就不公平。

sbux

原帖由 CoffeeCake 於 13-01-10 發表
好似係”必收生”如在自行階段多過SET左既限額，學校就會動用原本預比統一派位既學位填上喎。
所以，必收生 ...

呢個就係我想Ian 解答嘅地方，因為原來教局寫自行計分位係不得少於自行全數嘅20%，咁即係無論必收生有幾多，都一定會保留部分俾計分位(最少20%)，如果超多必收，就會食入中央位囉。咁學校又可以決定收計分位去到幾多，多過20%都得，之後再以必收生蠶食中央位

carchu12

屯門及沙田今年都開始要借位

iantsang

sbux 發表於 13-1-9 23:04
咁係咪即係如果自行超額嗰D學校，一定係必收生都用晒自行位而無得派俾計分嗰D? 因為必收用唔晒嘅位學校只 ...

Basically the bottom line is there are always 20% of TOTAL seats (not first round seats) saved for the points system.  So, there can be two situation, (1) when number of siblings of current students (必收) exceed 30% of total seats, additional seats are allocated from the Central Allocation pool;  (2) when the above number of siblings doesn't exceed the 30% quota, the remaining seats will be transferred to the points system pool.


Hope this is okay to share here but this is a chart I prepared last year's for non-EK parents' reference.  I think this should give you a clearer picture.

sbux

原帖由 iantsang 於 13-01-10 發表
Basically the bottom line is there are always 20% of TOTAL seats (not first round seats) saved for t ...

thanks Ian, fully understand now

iantsang

bbtammy 發表於 13-1-10 11:37
O~ IC, 請問我可以咁理解嗎？表中71間學校就算有25分在手都唔洗去抽, 因為所有自行分配學位嘅QUOTA都已經比 ...

Coffee Cake's answer is correct.

For better illustration purpose, you can refer to the examples below:

iantsang

CoffeeCake 發表於 13-1-10 11:42
我諗緊未來會唔會癲到連動用埋所有統一派位既學位都唔夠比”必收生”，尤其本身學位少既學校。 ...

This is quite possible especially for the situation you described.

開心小花

不過, 我之前聽到的版本係咁 :

50%  (A類)必收生(有兄姐在校) + (B類)計分生
50% (C類) 大抽獎 (統一派位)

如果一間學校是P.1收100人(100%). 其中50個位係要俾A & B類學生. 而其中最少20個位係要俾B類學生. 當A類學生係超30人, 佢額外的位就係食C類學生的位. 即係統一派位額.
如果, A類+B類不足50人, 多出來的位就會俾統一派位.

另外, 我聽講如果, 第一輪時, A類有位剩, 就會俾埋B類. 但我又聽過A類多出來的位要拿去大抽獎. 有無人可以CONFIRM呢點?

iantsang

開心小花 發表於 13-1-10 15:03
不過, 我之前聽到的版本係咁 :

50%  (A類)必收生(有兄姐在校) + (B類)計分生

The information you stated is valid as of the current system.

另外, 我聽講如果, 第一輪時, A類有位剩, 就會俾埋B類. 但我又聽過A類多出來的位要拿去大抽獎. 有無人可以CONFIRM呢點?

When there are seats remained for Part A, it will be transferred to Part B for points system.  However, if total number of applicants in discretionary places stage is below 50%, then those remaining seats will be transferred to central allocation.

You can refer to the above two charts for reference.

CoffeeCake

iantsang 發表於 13-1-10 15:03
This is quite possible especially for the situation you described.

咁第日EDB可能要開多個”抽獎箱”比必收生了！

cautionchan

其實ianstang 已經好好解釋了！計分是不會超額，只有甲一在校兄姊先係世襲必收，超了會佔用大抽獎的位，會多收，計分即宗教，父母兄弟舊生個D永遠都不會超收！