黄大仙區某中學入大學率之疑問?

wkkelvin

黄大仙區某中學剛轉英中幾年,公佈其DSE入大學(學位)率為75%, 但同時公佈其 "5科平均4級或以上(包括4科核心科目)"為57%。在不同途徑得知本年大學入學要求起碼要 5科平均4級, 不明白此中學如何入大學人數比最低達標人數還多? 有沒有這方面專家解釋得到?

Marco-ma

wkkelvin 發表於 12-12-17 12:24
黄大仙區某中學剛轉英中幾年,公佈其DSE入大學(學位)率為75%, 但同時公佈其 "5科平均4級或以上(包括4科核心 ...

"大學入學要求起碼要 5科平均4級" >> 是政府支助八大學位....

"公佈其DSE入大學(學位)率為75%" >>  會唔會有好多是私立自資學位 ?? 如樹仁/珠海/恆生果d....

wkkelvin

回復 Marco-ma 的帖子

它的網頁是這樣寫的:
成功入讀本地資助大學學士課程百分率 : 75%

Shootastar

If my memory is correct, the minimum points (for 5 subjects) to be admitted to HKU is 20. For other universities, the minimum is lower. So it is possible that that school has 75% admission rate yet the percentage of its students of score 20 or more is 57%.

Shootastar

For example:

The average score for Lingnan's BBA program is 4.05 (5 subjects). That means a number of students who scored below 20 were admitted.

All median figures for all programme of Open U are 19 or below (for 5 subjects). The median figures for some program were 17. So, a number of students whose scores were below 20 were admitted to Open U.

The median figures for most programme of BU were around 20. The median figure for B Pharmacy was 20. So a number of students whose scores were below 20 were also admitted to BU.

For PolyU and CitiU, they used weighed formula. A rough estimation on the figures would review that a number of students whose scores were below 20 were also admitted to PolyU and CitiU.

In case of HKU, CU and HKUST, I think it is very marginal to be admitted if the score is 20.

elbar

原帖由 wkkelvin 於 12-12-17 發表
回復 Marco-ma 的帖子

它的網頁是這樣寫的:

會否大部份都入嶺南和教院

jessimm

至少詨校升學輔導做得好,計算到今年double cohort下四年制大學學位(三大以外)有極多位(因non jupas集中係三年制)

Shootastar

回復 elbar 的帖子

The mean score of HKIE is between 18 to 19. For one or two hot programs, the mean score is 20. For Diploma course, the mean score is 17.

It appears that there is no inconsistency of the figures by the WTS school.

Shootastar

Because there is no more double cohort effect, the competition for admission to local universities would be more fierce for JUPAS or Non-JUPAS applicants.

jessimm

所以今年睇入U率會被誤導,反而level 5 or above會可靠些

Shootastar

I cannot say the school is misleading the parents as far as the admission rate and the percentage of students obtaining score of 20 or above are concerned. They are facts (which I believe).

However, it is true that from now onward, we should focus on the results of HKDSE instead of the admission rate if we want to find out the students' performance in HKDSE.

elbar

原帖由 elbar 於 12-12-19 發表
會否大部份都入嶺南和教院

還有演藝

jessimm

如果睇埋該校網上公佈資料,英文是這樣表達
Percentage promoted to institutions funded
by University Grants Committee                                  75%



並不是 percentage promoted to degree program funded by University Grants Committee

wkkelvin

回復 Shootastar 的帖子

Admission rate is definitely the important indicator indicating the quality of the school. Since this school doesn't announce the details of the DSE result, I can only consider the admission rate as the consideration factors. But the admission rate is quite contradict with the real situation.

Shootastar

回復 wkkelvin 的帖子

It is true that admission rate is an important indicator of the school's performance. However, the admission rate would depend on a number of factors which are outside the control of the students or the schools. For example, if one whose result is fine for science (if he put it as his first choice) but he chooses medicine, If he is not admitted to medicine and is not admitted to science (due to the fact that it is his second choice). This may affect the admission rate.

On the other hand, if one does not want to take the risk and applies for less popular program, it would boost up the admission rate of the school.

The average scores of the students, in my view, is a good indicator of the school's performance. It would be more accurate with the assistance of the admission rate.

TKO2040

wkkelvin 發表於 12-12-17 12:24
黄大仙區某中學剛轉英中幾年,公佈其DSE入大學(學位)率為75%, 但同時公佈其 "5科平均4級或以上(包括4科核心 ...

樓主是指何X堂, 如果真的7X%入8大, 甘佢真係好努力, 事關6年前佢收既係黃大仙BAND2學生, 就算現在入去讀的中1生, 都係BAND1中游學生.
但佢網講過有幾十個學生入中大喎? (好似40人左右, 希望無記錯.) 如果是真的, 甘何X堂好勁囉!

cow

--- deleted ---

ChiChiPaPa

wkkelvin,

www.edu-kingdom.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=35057&do=blog&id=1881

平均仍是低過保良一中。

khmama

相信4x人入中大係包括高考嘅考生，對於75%嘅考生分佈似乎仍是一個謎.