維記或根德畢業生嘅家長，如果時光倒流你地會點考慮呢

sonmeow

total agree same situation here.  depends on the character  
of your kids.

Heima10

Have u finally chosen Victoria?

Mayandrew

In fact, this is a topic discussed a number of years ago among my peers. Some of them were alumni of both kindergartens. Conclusion is both schools are good but, it happened, all of us did not go for KV.  Some eventually went to Victoria. Some parents are pretty traditional and we can classified them as "tiger mom". The rationale is they believe Vic can offer an environment for happiness and to develop critical thinking and problem solving skills. For those so-called academic stuff (English, Chinese, Math), don't worry...parents will probably teach them at home + doing tutorials after school :). As a parent who is a teacher himself claimed, what Vic can offer is not what he can offer but easy the other way around.

mirage

唔知點解，critical thinking在我的讀書年代，就算唔係大學也起碼是高中才需知道係乜，近年去到小學甚至幼稚園也話critical thinking.但一個六歲以下小孩根本連為什麼哭、為甚麼不高興也不懂完全向其他人説明白，又怎去學甚麼是critical thinking 呢？

Mayandrew

家陣小孩真的比我們一代叻。早前在課堂內有同學討論如果有壞人破壞地球，大家應不應該打他們？ 也有提梁振英說謊的問題。時代不同，我們當年四、五歲點會在台上演說、面試十幾次（好多大人一生也沒這麼多的經歷）？

mirage

上面所說的只是基本價值觀。大部份幼園也會有。真正critical thinking 要求學生有的並不只是what,where,when,why and who.也不是compare ,interpret or organize .它要有apply, analyze,create and evaluate .幼稚園生基本野都冇，做唔到critical thinking.外國也只會在高中才開始正式教，在幼稚園冇可能教到。

Freeb

原帖由 mirage 於 12-12-16 發表
上面所說的只是基本價值觀。大部份幼園也會有。真正critical thinking 要求學生有的並不只是what,where,whe ...

Support ur wording....without establish a good foundation....how come to the problem solving.

Mayandrew

大部份幼稚園可能真的分別不大，各取所需啦。正如不少學者也曾得出結論，大家報小學名校其實是self-fulfilling prophecy。大部份名校的師資和課程設計差別也不多（除了少數音樂和運動科強校）

Jane1983

Vic Kee有吾少tiger moms係事實，佢地自己好努力栽培小朋友，我認識有部分真係中英數常都好叻，吾係學校學的！

chansiub

我係KV舊生。這所學校不是不好。但用的方法並不適合應該仍在愉快學習的三至五歲人仔。基礎可以用很多方法去建立。Learn through Play! 並不一定要由抄寫去建立。正如上面有人寫，要做到KV的認字一點都不難。並不神奇只是填鴨。我用了改良了的方法也可令兒子在K1時差不多完成基礎漢字五百。現在配合了維記的閱讀。效果不錯。但我真係做唔到維記令小孩開曉及speak up 的威力。數學應比KV差但Hk700 一個月的Enopi已可彌補了。普通話及英文不用補。

chansiub

若你說KV可以自己做功課,坐定定。這跟人有關係。我就從來都沒習慣坐定定。而在屋邨快樂幼稚園長大的老公沒有不適應坐定定。他從沒在幼稚園有功課但上了小學都是自動自覺的做功課。我的KV生涯只有test及抄寫。我想兒子在愉快中學習。三年幼稚園是玩的。要做到牛咁的日子，大把有得去做。唔駛心急。太早開始並不等於win at the starting point. 以我為例就輸了三年可以無憂無慮的日子。

MrBeast

chansiub 發表於 12-12-18 11:16
我係KV舊生。這所學校不是不好。但用的方法並不適合應該仍在愉快學習的三至五歲人仔。基礎可以用很多方法去 ...

我反而更enjoy和小孩談天，說笑，講故事。
Anyway, 這麼長的討論也沒有變罵戰，反映Vic 和kv家長都是高質數。

chansiub

其實真係沒有那間是好些。只有那間適合些。跟小孩談天說地也是一種學習方法。

happyforever168

Actually what is the difference on the teaching method for Vic and SC? Which one do you think is better?

manlee22

我個依家學緊，但小朋友要串太多字有D困難，請教如何教小朋友串到咁多字？謝謝

DwarfMaMa

學phonics會有幫助