細仔變大仔後，有冇後悔？

tszyaumama

心大心細，好驚行錯呢一步！有冇jm比意見。

myfamily1807

我都好想知呀~

dora88

讀緊K1, 若有好的幼稚園, 會repeat K1。

彈弓狗

Good topic, what to know too

giyim

雖然我個仔唔係細仔, 但係如果佢係細仔我一定會俾佢REPEAT一年轉大仔LOR~ 因為好少少既幼稚園而家都擺到明淨係收大仔, 如果唔轉大仔真係冇咩選擇~ 同埋而家好多人都係咁, 加上變大仔後識野多D, 細仔驚跟唔上對佢心理唔知有冇影響~~

AdrianChowB

我兩個小朋友都吾係細仔，但如果係我，而又有學校收做細仔，我吾會repeat !

我地細個讀書，同班都有十一、十二月出世的同學！點解有書讀又repeat 呢？

如果小朋友將來讀吾上，真的要repeat,咁咪前後大人兩年？

cycream

我識3個小朋友都係repeat, 不過而加仲係k1. 其中2個女仔, 1個我諗佢係ok叻, 不過n1考唔到心儀kg, 於是再考一年n1, 入到心儀, repeat n1呢一年超叻, 成績表係full excellent,老師校長超鍾意佢, 而加k1, 佢媽一心target佢考dgjs.  另一個女仔,係本身好叻,無讀n1, k1考唔到心儀, k1再考, interview時, 表現好到老師問佢阿媽你個女考k1定k2? 佢媽話想佢repeat k1輕鬆d. 而加k1剛上學, 老師都讚佢好叻.  最後係一個男仔, n1一開學時老師已同佢媽講佢個仔有d跟唔上, 咁佢媽都覺, 就俾佢repeat n1, so far而加好好多.

我3個friends小朋友, 三個都係唔同能力, 都係repeat. 我覺得如果明知小朋友跟唔到就repeat會好好多. 又或者考唔到心儀, 又好想入, repeat都唔係一件壞事. 我仔都係細b, 佢好彩入到心儀又跟到, 我就無俾佢repeat. 阿仔同班都有細b, 佢媽都怕佢跟唔到, 問老師可唔可以repeat, 老師話佢阿仔跟到唔駛repeat. 每個人case都唔同, 真係唔可以一概而論. 其實樓主你係咩case呢?

giyim

AdrianChowB 發表於 12-9-12 11:00
我兩個小朋友都吾係細仔，但如果係我，而又有學校收做細仔，我吾會repeat !

我地細個讀書，同班都有十一、 ...

但係而家又唔可以同我地以前比較~ 以前我地教育制度同而家好唔同~ 有時我地都要因應情況而作出轉變.......

tszyaumama

如果第時小一想入津校，搏大抽奬，有冇需要repeat?

hobby

如果搏大抽獎，唔會repeat，除非跟唔上

happy.rita

原帖由 AdrianChowB 於 12-09-12 發表
我兩個小朋友都吾係細仔，但如果係我，而又有學校收做細仔，我吾會repeat !

我地細個讀書，同班都有十一、 ...

非常同意！

babyaabb

唔係細 B 的 MUMMY 係唔會明白.
Of course it also depends on the kid himself and what type of school parents are looking for.
In my personal opinion, if parents are not looking for 1st tier KG / Primary sch, defer one year be BIG B.
If parents go for lucky draw or have already got a secured primary allocation, then be Small B la

oscar1101

hobby 發表於 12-9-12 12:17
如果搏大抽獎，唔會repeat，除非跟唔上

請問點解搏大抽獎，就唔會repeat呢??? 唔太明白, 請指教~

klm402

我女係細B, 老師話女女好MAture, 強烈強議唔洗repeat, 不過礙於有另一個較出名同較受小學歡迎既kindi收左我女, 所以好爭扎既情況下比佢做大b.

cmycat

我咪係一個例子，我11月出世，以前媽咪比我揀，讀K3定P1，我咁細個實擇K3啦，到左F5都諗左好耐再唔再repeat，係果時媽咪真係好後悔呀!

Ackl1002

oscar1101 發表於 12-9-12 13:12
請問點解搏大抽獎，就唔會repeat呢??? 唔太明白, 請指教~

Because you don't care which kinder your kid will study in. Big lucky draw only takes into account the residential area, but not where nor which kinder your kid graduated from.

Those who wish to repeat, are targetting at entering famous kinders, which may help them in securing a good P1 place at private or DSS schools.

hobby

回復 oscar1101 的帖子

其實抽獎, 跟大細b冇關, 不過如果跟得到, 咁早一年會好少少 ... 因為出年率年年高 ... 而龍b應該係高峰, 咁要中第一志願, 會越來越難

hobby

我嗰囡都係11月細b, 之前都問過pn老師, 老師答佢樣樣都跟到, 不用repeat, 依家升k1, 佢樣樣表現都好好, 講嘢表達能力, 自理能力都得到老師認同, 仲讚佢乖添; 不過, 佢大小肌肉就仲未追到班大仔, 所以 ... 除非之後老師叫repeat, 否則都唔會, 因為囡囡一定會唔開心

siutinging

回復 hobby 的帖子

Agreed.

feiji

My kid repeats K2 now.  He is a small boy, but his communication skill is good.  That's why I also hesitated letting him be a big boy.  However, i can see that his finer motor skill is weak, which means his writing is quite ugly.  Also, he is weak at sports (maybe because he is very small in size).  Now he is repeating K2.  I am so happy that he finds all those writing easy to handle.  His writing is much tidier and he can write much faster.  He is also happy that he is not one of the youngest kids in the class.  I can feel that he is gaining confidence, which is the most important thing in my heart.  Also, I myself feels less stressful and I don't need to give him so much pressure like last year.  I don't regret at all and I am so happy that I have made such decision.