請問以下哪一所幼稚園比較值得申請

nlj1216

請問以下哪一所幼稚園比較值得申請 and why?
1)    聖保録 (CWB)

2)    寶血

3） 聖公會

4） St. Clare

5） St Catherine

6)    Kentville

7)    蘇浙

8)    真光

9）  聖心

10）維多利亞

11）劍鳴

12)  救恩
13)  香港銅鑼灣靈糧堂


Can you rank your preference from most favourable to least?

gwlam

First of all, you have to consider:
1. Location - you live in Hong Kong Island or Kowloon side?  It might be very difficult to arrange cross-habour nanny bus.
2. Curriculum - you prefer traditional school or trilingual curriculum?
3. Your child is a boy or girl?  Some of them are purely girl schools.
4. Will you target on through-train schools?
5. Is that school voucher a matter to you? Some of these schools don't accpet school vouchers.
6. Religion - see whether you have any religion background or preferences.

creamsicle

No need to rank la.  Cross off the ones that don't have school bus or are farther away from where you live and apply all the rest.  

nlj1216

回復 gwlam 的帖子

First of all, you have to consider:
1. Location - you live in Hong Kong Island or Kowloon side?  It might be very difficult to arrange cross-habour nanny bus.  
2. Curriculum - you prefer traditional school or trilingual curriculum?
3. Your child is a boy or girl?  Some of them are purely girl schools.
4. Will you target on through-train schools?
5. Is that school voucher a matter to you? Some of these schools don't accpet school vouchers.
6. Religion - see whether you have any religion background or preferences.

1)  Hong Kong Island
2)  Target Marymount, St Paul Convent primary, St Stephen College.  As for curriculum, would hope to find a kindergarten which provided good language environment as don't really want to pay extra or spend weekends going to tuitions for English/Mandarin/Phonics...etc,.
3)  Girl
4)  You mean one dragon schools?  It is preferable.
5)  No a big issue
6)  Don't have a religion so we don't have special preference.

LL222

不如, 報咗名，in咗，收咗，再問。

dmma

原帖由 LL222 於 12-08-31 發表
不如, 報咗名，in咗，收咗，再問。

蕃薯仔媽媽

原帖由 LL222 於 12-08-31 發表
不如, 報咗名，in咗，收咗，再問。

呢個Answer 100分

bbchung2009

回復 LL222 的帖子

agreed

CatEgg

如果報哂又全部都去in，家長壓力好大，難免影響小朋友。
不如問下自己，想小朋友係一個點樣的教育環境中成長。

lingan

係唔係報哂，係唔係全部去in, 壓力都係來自自己，唔target 咁多咪無咁大壓力囉。。既然樓主已經知自己要求，樓主所提的學校何不自己了解背景教學等等，了解後自然就有答案啦。

小兔咕

nlj1216 發表於 12-8-31 17:51
回復 gwlam 的帖子

First of all, you have to consider:

really want to pay extra or spend weekends going to tuitions for English/Mandarin/Phonics...etc,<---
但係要入st paul 就要讀spk，spk 係中文幼稚園.
到小學呢又要英文好...
所以你想讀st paul 要諗一諗.....
而且年年3千幾人考.. 都唔係咁易咁.
唔係值唔值得報, 而係人地收收唔收, 你list 果d 根本就好多人考..
你唔報多幾間有d 危...
但係13間又好似太多......
我諗你報少3-4間, 再加番一d 近你屋企又少人考既安全d .
同埋你考學校前都要諗下你自己小朋友既性格... 啱讀邊類學校.....
同埋果間學校又要d咩學生。。　
同埋佢地interview既橂式o係? eg 有d 係唔可以家長陪, 你小朋友ready 未. 未ready 你又要點樣可以幫到佢等.

marcuscyrus

km 係面試當日才交報名費(以往是這樣)，抵報!!如面試前已有offer大可以唔去慳返幾十蚊^_^
如果是我，住港島就不報九龍區的，反之亦言(龍校除外)

seelokyu

樓主小朋友有沒有讀PN?如有亦不是太差，不如只考龍校，要不然小朋友又要再適應。

gwlam

nlj1216 發表於 12-8-31 17:51
回復 gwlam 的帖子

First of all, you have to consider:

If I were you, I'll first cross out those at Kowloon side. As your kid is a girl and there are several good dragon schools in Hong Kong Island, you can mainly focus on:
1)    聖保録 (CWB)
4） St. Clare
7)    蘇浙
8)    真光
9）  聖心
10）維多利亞
12)  救恩

SKH is a very popular kindergarten with good track record although without primary school backup.

Precious Blood is a good kindergarten.  Its primary school is a government subsized primary thus it's not a through-train school.

LLC is a happy school too, but the curriculum might be a bit easy (heard from the others) and neither with school vouchers nor primary school backup.

For your target primary, Marymount, as this is a government subsidized primary school, the admission would mainly base on the marking system (e.g. catholic, old girls, with silblings currently studies at Marymount) at the first round and central allocation at the second round (the lucky draw).  

For St. Paul's Convent Primary, of course the highest chance to get in are those from its kindergartens, including SPN, SPK and SPN Taipo.  However, the admission to its primary is not 100% guaranteed.

For St. Stephen's College, I suppose you are referring to St. Stephen's College Preparatory School located at Stanley, I can't remember it's a private or DSS primary, but the admission is definitely based on interview performance.

chrissteph

全部報名。好多人同你爭。

polarbearlee

Last year, each KG you listed have over 1000 people to apply. So better apply  some non popular KG or you may end up nothing. I applied 13 last year and end up 1a, 8w, and 4r.

carmensamso

apply for all la
all the school in your list are good school…but their 教育理念are quite different, you can spend some time and see which one match with your expectations !
answering your question...
first, you might not be able to attend all the  interview due to time crashes/sickness!
second, you/your kid might not like the school anymore after your actual visit
then, just pick from the school which grant you an offer!

sissysze

你唸唔使出去補英文就唔好報kv 同cwb st paul 了，一定要出去補

nlj1216

回復 CatEgg 的帖子

Agree....i think it is too much for my daughter and ourselves to handle.  Too pressurised for a 3 year old to attend so many interviews.

nlj1216

回復 polarbearlee 的帖子

So crazy?  My daughter just started K1 at LLC as a super small B, that's why I wanted to apply a better kindergarten and repeat K1 that will enable to have a better foundation for interviews to primary.