港島區>>民生/蘇淅/明慧/明我，會揀邊間?? 謝~~

sobmama

點解呢? 謝~~

twllc

我會咁揀: 蘇浙>明慧>民生>明我

因為我希望語文能力好d,從遊戲中學習，多過催谷功課，而蘇浙英普合我心意,而且蘇小評價都ok。明慧較民生出名，所以我排佢先，但其實有d家長對佢感覺唔好。民生我小朋友讀過，老師都幾take care 小朋友。明我唔係我杯茶，加上以前interview 時不愉快，係唯一一間in 完覺得佢肯收我都一定唔俾小朋友入讀既學校

sobmama

twllc 發表於 12-7-26 19:31
我會咁揀: 蘇浙>明慧>民生>明我

因為我希望語文能力好d,從遊戲中學習，多過催谷功課，而蘇浙英普合我心意, ...

謝謝分享, 可唔可以講講點解不愉快呀? 因為明白至近我家...... 謝~~

cathygum

回復 twllc 的帖子

聽講明我有分「有功課班」同「冇功課班」，係咪真的呢？
Tks~

twllc

回復 sobmama 的帖子

其實係發生响兩年前in n 班時，當天安排很混亂，咁樣都算。但當in時，in我地既老師一邊in我地，一邊同隔離枱in緊另一位家長既老師傾計(兩張枱相隔好近)，唔知係咪因為我地係超細仔問乜都唔識，佢地預左唔收定點，我覺得叫得黎in，係咪都應該尊重下家長/小朋友呢?

不過我朋友in第二位老師冇呢個情況，可能係個別事件，但令我對呢間學校印象大打折扣。

twllc

回復 cathygum 的帖子

我朋友講係分有功課同冇功課，不過話入得去都係buy佢催谷果套，所以基本上都會揀有功課

lovewanc

我仔今年讀民生n班, 有無小朋友今年都開學?

sobmama

twllc 發表於 12-7-30 08:55
回復 sobmama 的帖子

其實係發生响兩年前in n 班時，當天安排很混亂，咁樣都算。但當in時，in我地既老師一 ...

ICIC thanks for sharing...

ladypanpan

我會揀最近自己果間先

meloeskie2

我會咁揀: 蘇浙>明我>民生>明慧
蘇浙-- perfect language environment, less school fee
明我-- no worries in primary school due to heavy training in kg
民生-- caring & happy school with good language environment
明慧-- quite commercial school

gwlam

PN: 我舊年PN就揀咗民生。 蘇浙PN我無考，因為personally唔buyPTH教學。明我太遠無報。 明慧收但太commercial無讀。
K1: 有考蘇浙K1，雖然personally唔buyPTH教學，但抱住人考我又考下嘅心態考下，蘇浙收但最終無揀，因為都係唔鍾意太大班同唔buyPTH教學。 如果想PTH好，KCS is definitely the right choice.

GCG

回復 gwlam 的帖子

Yes..蘇浙PTH environment 雖則好, 但不是絕對! 聽朋友有嗰有小朋友家庭只用廣東話溝通, 嗰小朋友可能語文能力差係學校聽得唔係好明, 佢父母!為怕因此而阻礙費學習東西機會, 佢父母最終幫轉左校, 所以都係趙Sir嗰句...睇邊間幼稚園適合自己小朋友。我見好人提及可能此終PTH接近廣東話, 即使小一先至起點, 不出一年已經追返晒其他同學, 妳buy 唔 buy 咁早學PTH隨妳。

Torontolim

I will choose 蘇浙. My daughter is studying there ( K2 in Sept ) and she really enjoys her school life.

meimei223

Definately KCS, most of the children can pick up PTH very well,  I don't speak PTH at home but they understand totally, it takes around 1/2 yr to pick up.

ncream

meimei223 發表於 12-8-8 02:29
Definately KCS, most of the children can pick up PTH very well,  I don't speak PTH at home but they  ...

Agree x2!
My boy used to speak english and no pth at home... after joining kcs for the first semester, he can understand what the teacher is talking about ..... and just before this summer vacation, he is able to pick up the new language and chat in pth sometimes.....and now he always sing in both eng and pth.......

Makminnie

咩係pth?新手媽媽，我個女得三個月，不過睇定先

gwlam

Makminnie 發表於 12-8-9 15:22
咩係pth?新手媽媽，我個女得三個月，不過睇定先

Putonghua

ncream

Makminnie 發表於 12-8-9 15:22
咩係pth?新手媽媽，我個女得三個月，不過睇定先

mandarin.........

MBK

蘇浙>民生>明我＞明慧

lalamike

講環境，一定是KCS最好，不過，如不是由KCS的N上，而是直入KCS讀K，本人親戚有實際經騐，就是除非家庭本身有PTH background，又或小朋友語言能力強，否則，選KCS未必合適!
至於民生、明我及明慧，其實論課程，民生及明慧相類似，明我英文或會弱一點，但又催谷一點!