馬灣基慧? 德雅小學?

HYsquare

兩間小學， 那間較好呢？大家可否給予一些意見參考？

daishidoi

基慧你放第幾志願? 基慧都係band 1 學校wor!

HYsquare

first choice but tak nga belongs to shum shui po district which is a better network for secondary schools.

ac917

原帖由 HYsquare 於 12-06-02 發表
first choice but tak nga belongs to shum shui po district which is a better network for secondary sc ...

荃灣區嘅中學都好強

Nicolelong

原帖由 ac917 於 12-06-02 發表
荃灣區嘅中學都好強

荃灣唔係得四間英中咩？請多多指教！反而荃灣小學就幾平均！

SFA04008

of course,Tak Ngai

Happy2049

- one is private --> need to pay money 6 years  Vs one is free govt school
totally different.
- as i know 德雅 very traditional (修女學校) Vs 馬灣基慧 relatively is free
- better English 德雅  Vs 馬灣基慧 better chinese
- but 德雅 secondary school already down grade to Band 2 Vs 馬灣基慧 although regional Band 1 primary school. but as per allocation result...each year have around 70-80 kids  success allocate to Band 1 secondary school (not only focus on Tsuen Wan & Kwai Tsing), in my mind only....聖士提反書院 have 5  students, 女拔萃 , 皇仁  and 聖保羅男女...

compare with Net 41, still hve distance but if you as regional school...my opinion is quite good.

i think it depends on which school style you like?
which one match your family style?
religious?
location?
financial?

Kittymummy

基慧吾知，但TN 中學真係down左grade, 變band 2。 4班中有兩班開中文班。ssp 近年多左好多新屋村，千禧小學校。但全英中由7間變5間，小學生多左但英中位少左，本區英中位都吾夠，要問他區借。呢個都係要考慮之一。

SFA04008

德中雖然down-graded 但係德小畢業生好受中學歡迎 唔洗怕 因為程度高 易考到好中學

仔仔錫錫你

入德小，應寄望入band 1英中或中途轉更好小學
入馬基，應寄望最差都要入到德中granded 中學，亦唔好期望可轉更好小學

kmmum

回復 HYsquare 的帖子

德小程度好深, 最TOP 的學生入上智, 中間入聖母玫瑰.  最差果D先入德中.
我會咁睇.  用同一個'谷法', (如果在德小考到中上). 馬基應該可以考到好TOP.  (即係可以選BAND 1 中學)
同一個谷法意思係. 德小= 小三做小四數, 做小四英文. (小朋友要有能力應付及家長要配合)

莎莎莉莉

住邊?
如果係住荃灣, 讀番基慧啦
其實兩間唔係差好遠....
我都覺得德雅小學似係大家水泡咁...

jomel

我個仔同你一樣,不過我住荃灣,同老公衡量過後都係馬基,因為唔想仔仔搭車辛苦,加上學費,車費,膳食等,仲有時間問題,最後決定馬基,雖然德小程度高D,谷D,但係仔仔程度一般,如果強硬要谷,倒不如有時間同精神幫佢,話曬都住近D.希望你考慮自己情況吧!

Jackieson

jomel 發表於 12-6-3 19:21
我個仔同你一樣,不過我住荃灣,同老公衡量過後都係馬基,因為唔想仔仔搭車辛苦,加上學費,車費,膳食等,仲有時 ...

你的決定很明智

HYsquare

Thanks for all your opinions. As my daughter needs to be pushed (not much self-discipline, haha), I think traditional and strict school is better for letting her back to the track of self-discipline and building good character. I have finally taken the offer of Tak Nga.

God will prepare everything we need. :loveliness:

angeemama

回復 HYsquare 的帖子

Welcome to our family! We have formed a group in TN page and we are planning to see if we could have our children to meet with each other during summer time.  Please check it out.

HYsquare

回復 angeemama 的帖子

Hello, angeemama. What a good idea! Where is the page, at BK?

angeemama

回復 HYsquare 的帖子

Yup.  Please check the in Tak Nga Primary School in BK under the thread:
[size=1.2em]TO : 各位德雅小一家長朋友 [size=1.2em]