讀兩間幼稚園？

janice007

回復 gwlam 的帖子

咁既arrangement我又覺得麻麻﹐我寧願直剷兩間。我個中醫個孫囡都係讀兩間﹐一間small world christian school, 一間禮賢﹐佢話現今好多人都係咁。

seeker.email

謝謝各位的囘覆。你們剛才說的都是我的憂慮，尤其是小孩的休息時間，否則我不會在猶豫。

兩家幼稚園離我家都很近，即使我之前從來也沒有計劃要上兩家幼稚園，交通時間一直都是我其中一個首要考慮，你可以想像我本身都很重視小孩的休息和遊戲時間。

我是有點偏向SKH，是因爲覺得跟本地小學接軌比較容易，以及較重視德育。

可是我也不捨得Victoria的雙語環境，我的小孩在那裏上PN，一直都維持雙語，從沒有在學校内跟同學和老師說廣東話（兩文三語班的確實是會集中說廣東話）。我亦有特別留意K3英普班的小孩，他們的語言程度絕對可以。

眼見小孩的午睡時間越來越短（半年後，可能還會午睡，也可能沒有），所以才有這“奇想”，看看要不要上兩間。正如ningningb所講，可能到時上興趣班也一樣忙！

所以希望有更多的家長可以告訴我實際的經驗。謝謝！

gwlam

其實時間上真係可以配合嗎？ say上午個間放12:00, 下午個間返13:00, 一個鐘時間又要travel, 又要食飯，又要換校服，又要去下厠所，我自己lunch一個鐘先啱啱好，要同個小朋友做咁多嘢自問做唔到，下午班一定遲到 .....

Freshment

老實講，如果第日小朋友大左真係唔需要午睡，我會寧願下午安排興趣班俾佢學都唔會俾佢返2 間幼稚園。起碼讀興趣班佢可以學到不同既野，而唔係早上同下午都學差唔多既野。

Ackl1002

It's good to develop bilingual ability, but is it the only area that you want your child to develop? She can only attend interest classes like piano or painting during weekend, then you sacrifice the family day etc etc. I personally don't think it is good to attend 2 kinders. Maybe you can find interest classes which is taught in Eng/PTH, so she can learn the language, at the same time develop her interest in other aspects.

CoffeeCake

gwlam 發表於 12-3-21 11:55
全日班嘅下午session比全日$定半日$? 其實食飯+午睡到三點起身排洗同食茶點，實際下午上堂時間應該得一個 ...

其實我估半日錢都OK,
全日班既下午,好多都唔係正規課程(只有全日班既學校除外). 瞓醒食下野,跟住學校有D課餘既活動(EG,體能,美勞)

may0928

唔好霸住個學位啦,

seeker.email

True. I know language ability is one thing. It's always important to have an all-round development. If I were to put her into two kindergartens at the same time, I am aiming at doing it for one year only. After K1, I would probably drop one and leave more time for her extra curricula activities.  This sounds very ideal but there are indeed many things to consider.

My child is able to speak pth in full sentences. Really want to reinforce that. Therefore it's tempting to stay for a bit longer.

caca316

回復 seeker.email 的帖子

睇來你都已心中有答案,......如果你覺得唔試唔心息, 你可以試下一段時候, 唔OK咪即quit law.....

gwlam

This would be unfair to those who don't even have any offer on hand.

linseymom

小兒讀普通學卷幼稚園，有個同學番上午班，但留校食埋午飯，仲可以換埋去街衫(因為下午間國際學校不用著校服)，由工人接走搭車番第二間學校。由於兩間學校地點只相隔幾分鐘路程，睇落佢又唔係好趕，真係要視乎學校同屋企點同佢配合。人各有志啦!

caca316

回復 linseymom 的帖子

無錯, 人各有志, 都無咩話fair 唔 fair, 樓主或其他人有咁既決定, 我地都唔好對別人作太多批評..... 而且,SKH都不易入的....如果未有offer的人,可以考慮下考無咁熱門的學校,相信一定有着落.....

kaychung

seeker.email 發表於 12-3-21 14:15
True. I know language ability is one thing. It's always important to have an all-round development.  ...

純粹路過, 每對父母都有不同既考慮, 每位小朋友都有不同既需要, 不過, 呢度既聲音大多並非出自真正用家, 反而酸味愈吹愈濃, btw, 問心無愧, 一試無妨。

sunnygirl

我見過有d返兩間幼稚園嘅小朋友要係公園匆匆咁食飯同換衫，唉~何苦呢！

AEteam

我覺得你要預咗你小朋友係下午間學校表現可能會差啲，因為攰月同悶（因為課程可能會重覆，只是用不同語言）。如果下午是SKH要考慮吓，因為學校嚴，會影響成績表評分。不過如果只讀SKH，英文普通話都要出面學。

bluigugub

AEteam 發表於 12-3-21 16:50
不過如果只讀SKH，英文普通話都要出面學。 ...

Indeed this is the point.  even if the kid just attends one kinder, does it make a huge difference if he/she is to attend tuition classes for both english and PTH after school?  One will appreciate that unlike other extra-curricular activities, if a kid is to have good language skills, it would not help by letting him attend outside classes for, say, 1 or 2 hours a week ... but if the kid is to have more frequent / longer Eng and PTH classes (and highly likely, additional phonics class as well), isn't it equally exhausting and tiring ?

seeker.email

我的目的不是要霸著學位，如果我想這樣做，反而最容易，立即註冊，然後等到9月看看小孩的情況再算。讀兩間來互補不足看似很理想，但不一定切實可行，所以想搜集多些例子，慎重地考慮，要放棄其一也可以儘早讓給他人。
謝謝你們給我不同角度的意見！

lymchau

I understand your view and studying VIC for afternoon is also good for them learning English and PTH.  My girl enjoy much in there and learnt a lot of both language within a year.

janettsui

為人父母當然千方百計為子女提供最好既學習環境
我地機關算盡時又有冇係小朋友角度出發諗諗呢?

讀2間唔同既學校, 會否令佢好混淆?
點解人地讀1間, 我讀2間?
如果佢真係咁問你, 你預備點答?

假設發現唔work, 你會揀邊間?
小朋友返左一段時間, 對2間老師同學都有感情, 而且必定有比較及喜好.
你心中所揀同小朋友既意願唔同時, 最終又應該點決擇?

假設小朋友handle到, 但無晒自由玩樂既時間, 會否令佢討厭返學呢?

學d野好相似, 小朋友會否覺得厭倦?

當然可以試下先, 但我個人會考慮到...
如果搞到小朋友唔鐘意返學, or覺得返學好悶時, 就手尾長, 到時唔係三言兩語就可以改變到佢抗拒既心態...