名校-尾; not名校-top

meejh

Confused: if aim at top band 1 secondary school, eg. QC, KC
And kid is only ordinary, should he have more chance if study at easy primary that is not名校? as much less competition?

i always hear "every school has band 1 student". And band 1 students pick secondary schools first, so aren't I better off being top at an easy primary school that nobody picks?  Then I can still have a chance at QC whereas if I'm band 3 at famous school, no chance to choose QC.  (Yet band 3 at famous school may be very outstanding already.)

Yet nobody picks the easy schools?  or am I wrong/confused??

weisscarton

你講得好啱，所以通常到小四就會由名校轉到其他學校，等小五，六呈分 keep 住 band one。

lauerica

第一次聽，奇聞。

weisscarton

我意思是如果你在名校到小三，四發覺成績是  Band 3,通常家長都會轉去其他學校，因為有機會在其他學校考前排位置,呈分試是 Band 1 學生。

yyy8182

原帖由 weisscarton 於 11-12-1 08:10 發表
你講得好啱，所以通常到小四就會由名校轉到其他學校，等小五，六呈分 keep 住 band one。

sigh

[ 本帖最後由 yyy8182 於 11-12-1 08:26 編輯 ]

weisscarton

其實無扭典，通常一，二年級是蜜月期，到三，四年級你發覺小朋友在 top 的學校跟唔上，成績又差，通常都會安排轉校。到新學校如果之前底打得好，都會考得前名次，始終都要努力先會在學校做到 band one 學生。但轉校後比你派到 top band one 中學，跟唔跟到就要睇個小朋友。

[ 本帖最後由 weisscarton 於 11-12-1 16:36 編輯 ]

MC1128

band one 是計全港首三分之一最好成績的學生,不是每間學校最好成績的首三分一喎?

marcuscyrus

原帖由 meejh 於 11-12-1 16:06 發表
Confused: if aim at top band 1 secondary school, eg. QC, KC
And kid is only ordinary, should he have more chance if study at easy primary that is not名校? as much less competition?

i always hear "eve ...

第一輪自行有面試，學校亦有該學生的全港排名在手，非名校的top未必會比名校非top排名高哦
到第二輪大抽獎，自要你是band 1生就有機會抽先，成功與否就在於random number先後

marcuscyrus

duplicated

[ 本帖最後由 marcuscyrus 於 11-12-1 18:08 編輯 ]

marcuscyrus

duplicated

[ 本帖最後由 marcuscyrus 於 11-12-1 18:33 編輯 ]

TiTiTiTi

原帖由 MC1128 於 11-12-1 17:06 發表
band one 是計全港首三分之一最好成績的學生,不是每間學校最好成績的首三分一喎?

正解，所以轉唔轉校都系同一個塘(全港或同區)，
當然，轉校令孩子提升自信心或與新老師新環境而產生化學作用，使成績有改善就另當別論！

meejh

Thank you all for comments.  So let me try to summarise:

努力is needed for sure no matter which school. Anyway, lets assume he's at Easy primary, amongst the top of the class.  

At第一輪自行, unlikely get QC interview as Easy primary is ranked too low. Even if he gets interview, unlikely to get a spot. But at 名校, no interview either b/c he's band 3.  Am I right?

到第二輪大抽獎, b/c he's band 1 student at Easy primary, he'll CHOOSE EARLIER than 名校 band 3 students.  So Easy primary gives the boy more chances?

So it seems weisscarton's strategy works at maximizing chance, trick is to know child's banding at P4.  Please I do not have any prejudice for or against 名校 or Easy primary.  Just that I believe 努力is not enough.  I need to know the game and play by the rules.

kennyklt

留意，喺名校考得尾唔代表能夠喺普遍學校考第一，喺普遍學校考頭幾名嘅學生都讀得好叻，由名校轉過去並無任何保證。

meejh

yes yes, understand. the big worry is, in Easy Primay, there is actually NO BAND 1 student in 第二輪大抽獎.

無任何保證is true, but is a chance. if stay in 名校尾=no chance.

So for a mediocre child, may have a chance if change to Easy Primary at same district at dream Secondary at P5, assuming they let the child in. I wonder if this is true and whether there has been any success stories?

kyliejet

唔係好明...

如果:
名校band 2
普通學校 band 1
成續: 名校band 2 叻過 普通學校band 1 (有可能嗎?)

問題:
邊個可以進入band1中學?

[ 本帖最後由 kyliejet 於 11-12-2 12:31 編輯 ]

yiptszman10

I want to know......

marcuscyrus

原帖由 kyliejet 於 11-12-2 12:26 發表
唔係好明...

如果:
名校band 2
普通學校 band 1
成續: 名校band 2 叻過 普通學校band 1 (有可能嗎?)

問題:
邊個可以進入band1中學?

呈分次第並非單統計名次，有空可參考升中那邊有關呈分次第的計算法，看了才知原來是這樣
另，banding 是給個別學生的，不論他讀何學校，只要他是band 1生，在大抽獎階段就會比band 2生較先處理，而各band 1 生的抽獎次序，跟其成績先後冇關，而是靠他的隨機編號

[ 本帖最後由 marcuscyrus 於 11-12-2 18:04 編輯 ]

虎媽媽

原帖由 meejh 於 11-12-2 11:44 發表
yes yes, understand. the big worry is, in Easy Primay, there is actually NO BAND 1 student in 第二輪大抽獎.

放心，一定有！

就係因為學生參差，好多學校會放資源去幫d叻嘅小朋友 (唔係差嗰d！)，所以，如果叻嘅小朋友，佢响d普通d嘅學校讀，有機會得到更多！

meejh

yes yes, this is exactly my confusion. Who will choose first at random draw? 名校band3 or Easy Primary Band1?

I heard about a boy rank 尾3 at very 名校in wanchai. Almost went crazy studying, could not handle. Transferred to "Easy Primary" and rank 1st every year.  Don't know if he's in secondary yet.

Thank you 虎媽媽. If this is the case, Easy Primary becomes very attractive.

虎媽媽

原帖由 meejh 於 11-12-2 16:41 發表
Thank you 虎媽媽. If this is the case, Easy Primary becomes very attractive.

其實我一路留意緊直資私小，最近有朋友安排咗佢個資優兒入讀津小 (地區上都算熱門但唔係大熱嗰d)，學校會安排能力上較高嘅小朋友參興特別嘅課程 (其他同學嘅功課堂)
detail我唔太清楚，只知佢地係無話俾學校知小朋友係資優

當我再睇多少少津校，同埋同津小老師朋友傾開，都發現好多學校有類似安排，特別係所謂band 2學校！有能力嘅小朋友得到嘅資源就會更多！
唔只一位小朋友聰明嘅家長，都叫我3思！
到底，要做叻人裡面嘅一個小人物，定係普通人裡面嘅叻人... 好難諗！但我相信後者應該會開心d嘅！

但係，如果真係有名校收，又真係好吸引架喎，好難唔接受...
(發吓夢先..)