St.Paul Boys vs Ying Wa

momama

原帖由 Peter2880 於 11-11-29 23:40 發表


你d推斷唔多合理, 間間學校d校長都會退休, 唔通校長退休間學校就"林"?, 放且林校長係協恩過來的, 她走後的協恩唔見得差左

Do you know that since she left HY, HY has changed to a totally different direction?

newmommy

DaisyWu, do u mean Snoopy is too pushy / sum gup and other staff cannot follow?

momama, could you kindly share what direction Heep Yun is now going? How different since Snoopy left?

Ths!

tokwawan

咁我又覺得好難去比較的, 因為HY始終咁耐, 好多野上晒軌道, 就算校長離開, 相信不太受影響...但YW唔同, 佢轉直資只係4年, 難免會有家長担心一旦校長離任, 對學校會有咩影響...

Ving

我覺得林校長似精神領袖，就好似任志剛在金管局，他的離開對整個運冇大影響，但就覺得遜色左，尤其同陳德林相比。

babybear

我覺得佢似一個TOP SALES，把口好得。

同埋佢以前好似係全女校教開， 依家改教全男校， 一定有某程度既挑戰。

[ 本帖最後由 babybear 於 11-12-1 10:40 編輯 ]

ASamSam

唔知有冇現在英華家長的睇法呢？

Ving

祈實把口得好殺食，尤其坐校長lee d 位

mamay

My son is studying YW P2.  In fact, I live in HK island but I still think it is worth to travel to kowloon side.
The YW life is really very very happy.  The kids do not feel any pressure at all.  I will say, even the teacher will not give pressure to the parents.  However, we all notice that most of the YW parents do have expectation to the kids.   Also the acadamic level of some kids are really really high

Mrs Lam when she is free, she will go to the classroom to talk to the kid during recess.....and will greet the kids in the morning when they go to school

There are  a lot of activities and school teams for the kid to participate....from Mon to Fri after school and even from 8 to 5 on Sat.

As Mrs Lam always said the boys are different than girl and they need to move all the time, starting from this acadamic year, the PE lessons have been increased from 2 to 3 per weeks.  The boys are so so happy.  

Overall, the boys at YW are active.  Few years ago, I did attend interview at St Paul where I notice most of the boys are relatively "quiet".  Not sure if my observation is still valid or not.  

Let me know if there are any other things you want to know.

newmother

我都係一位住港島報咗英華既家長!想請教 Mammy 妳個仔仔每天放學幾点返到屋企呢？

Ving

So, does your son travel to school by nanny bus and by how long?

Is it 100% for P6 student to YW secondary?

Is it YW primary a chinese or english school?

Do you know if the vice-principal take up Snoopy principal job if she retire. And do you think any impact if she retire from YW?

Thanks

mamay

So, does your son travel to school by nanny bus and by how long?
- we, the YW parents living in HK island arrange the nanny bus by ourself......now we got more and more boys living in HK island....that demand > supply : )
- depends on your location.......20 mins to 1 hour

Is it 100% for P6 student to YW secondary?
- if you got pass in Chi, Eng and Math....yes, 100% go to secondary.....that's why it called "one-dragon school)

Is it YW primary a chinese or english school?
- Chinese.......but the english level is high.......around 10% eng math at P1 and will gradually increase.......test and exam has "eng math" as well.....P2 start teaching Eng poem.......I can see that some P3 boys can write Eng poem very well


Do you know if the vice-principal take up  ...
- Honestly we as YW parents, do worry that Mrs Lam will retire...however, she is still so passionate....I don't think she will retire soon.....at least not the coming few years.........

taboding

我贊成揀屋企附近嗰間 since their levels seem almost the same!

sytw

兩間我自己比較喜歡英華，但老公就覺得遠左d(我地住港島東)，不過英華咁多人爭，真係收左先再諗讀邊間。之前對st Paul boys有好多疑問，不過上星期去完簡介會後認識多左，我地都好喜歡。

ASamSam

好同意，不過唔知到時夠唔夠時間去諗。

DaisyWu

自已可能主觀咗D,尤其是看到很多YW嘅家長意見後。兩位校長各有不同的風格，一個和藹可親、一個友善But"嚴＂及講efficiency,各有各好。
本人與樓主情況差唔多，之前並無小朋友在呢兩間小學就讀，與及Paul Boys收咗和YW正等消息。不過，唔知點解自已綜合各方意見後，就好鍾意Paul Boys,至於YW,唔會諗Lu..

Ving

聽聞st Paul boy新校舍系山道校舍的四倍，即四千八百平方米，想問lee個面積較其他小學算大定細？

moubb

我唔知同DBS、CO ED等大大間的學校比SPB個新校舍有幾大，不過我一路睇住佢起，個地盤大到我初初以為佢係起國際學校TIM。

Glau

如果兩間差不多又鍾意, 就應該揀近屋企, 話晒小學+中學 12年, 宜家d 學生好忙分分鐘星期一至五或六都有留校課外活動. 細個有家長接送, 中學真係會朝7晚7先番到屋企.

Ving

Spb個新校舍對現有的學生另一好處是有多二十五巴仙教學，活動空間，因教署未落實幾時加多一班。

Era

都幾得意,講講下似乎就只係比較校長,其實仲有好多,例如教學方針,活動...好多野可以比較既喎.
我自己來講,就覺得SPB係傳統既,YW就冇咁傳統,會有好多活動既.所以靜既小朋友,可能會鐘意SPB多D,活既就會鐘意YW啦.

我係YW家長,校長個人係點,我就唔多理既.但聽佢既演講,的確學到好多野.而囝囝又的確讀得好開心.

不過如果真係住得太遠既,除非搬啫,咪真係揀間近既好D啦.好多活動有機會要留校既,返到屋企真係有可能好夜.