陳守仁 vs 港大同學會的決擇

bermama

有冇家長已經被以上2間學校同一時間取錄? 如有, 大家如何選擇和取捨?

hoihoima

These two schools are very far apart, where do you live??

headmama

我兩個都有offer. 不過我揀左港大同學會,因為TSL太多外藉人士.

I1.rlkn

我都會選港大

gooday

請問點解揀港同呢? 以申請人數計算,好似陳守仁受歡迎D？ 請指教!

im_csb

港大同學會的只有九龍east , HK east 的家長會choose, but 全九龍, 和新界都可以choose  TSL

bbiloveu

申請人數可以某程度上反映到受歡迎程度, 當可以方便地上網報名時,一定會更多人申請的.

tinyuichan

港同不需中學派位
但假若你充滿自信派band 1著名官津中學, 就tsl
不考慮以上, 兩間都是好學校便近邊間讀邊間!

bermama

我地住緊將軍澳, 其實陳守仁對我地黎講的確遠左小小, 前日再多收多一間offer 九龍塘學校, 3間o係我地心目中都係叮噹馬頭, 唔知點揀

HaYi

如果小朋友是受傳統型較單向的 : KLT > TSL  (因TSL 的成績都不是很好, 大部份去顏保玲, KLT 好似多些去傳統的band 1)

如果小朋友是需要雙向活動型: HKUGA > TSL  , HKUGA 中英都應該良好, TSL就英強中弱, 但現在要中英都強才是好.

Charlotte_mom

講開中文, 又要讚下學校(港同)教得好
我D普通話係"爛"級別, 頂硬上果種
上星期公司ANNUAL DINNER, 有一PART係玩剪報紙, 第一檯去滙報果個係內地同事, 用普通話, 第2檯又好順便用普通話, 到我果檯, 我女出去, 都係好順便用普通話讀晒成篇野, 當場全場拍掌(包括內地同事仲有我北京藉老闆娘)話佢發音準確又唔怯場

雖然之後個個同事COMMENT都係:好心你跟你個女學好普通話啦! 但心裡都忍唔住開心架

silvia_ng

原帖由 HaYi 於 11-12-15 23:30 發表
如果小朋友是受傳統型較單向的 : KLT > TSL  (因TSL 的成績都不是很好, 大部份去顏保玲, KLT 好似多些去傳統的band 1)

如果小朋友是需要雙向活動型: HKUGA > TSL  , HKUGA 中英都應該良好, TSL就英強中弱, 但現在要 ...

點解話去顏bowling就差? 有冇考慮過tsl有一個特別之處, 就係有一批小朋友唔係中國人, 佢地係tsl 6年都係只學法文英文同少量中文? 佢地有幾多間主流中學可以選擇, 比佢地繼續以讀法文為主?

每級大約有5份一呢d小朋友, 即係大約一級35人, 咁可唔可以解釋到點解咁多人去顏bowling? (同埋大家都係保記學校呢!)

人地既阿媽

顏保玲係Band 1 中學，好野黎架！看TSL website，除左顏保玲，佢地有好多學生去左傳統Band 1 中學，如DBS, DGS, Good Hope, King's, La Salle, Marymount, Queen's Queen Elizabeth, St.Paul Boys, St.Paul Covent, St. Paul Co-Ed, St. Stephen Girls, True Light, Wah Yan, Ying Wah 等等。我覺得佢地派位成績好好喎！

Ving

But for TSL, you need to count the percentage that can go into so called "elite school" and assess if your children can be within that percentage.

KikiDaddy

Secondary school allocation is never the selling point of TSL. If you compare its allocation result to that of APS, you can see the difference.

Having said that, TSL is a good school that offer excellent English learning environment and modern campus with good facilities. Its school fees is the most reasonable among the DSS / private schools.

原帖由 人地既阿媽 於 11-12-16 11:49 發表
顏保玲係Band 1 中學，好野黎架！看TSL website，除左顏保玲，佢地有好多學生去左傳統Band 1 中學，如DBS, DGS, Good Hope, King's, La Salle, Marymount, Queen's Queen Elizabeth, St.Paul Boys, St.Paul Covent, St. Paul C ...

[ 本帖最後由 KikiDaddy 於 11-12-16 12:28 編輯 ]

人地既阿媽

報私校同直資無住址限制，我有朋友住東涌都報港大同，我諗如果你好鍾意某間學校，幾遠都會報既。

人地既阿媽

Agree!  Since 樓主 is comparing 港大同 and TSL (but not TSL vs other Elite schools like APS), so I just want to raise the point that TSL's secondary school allocation results is actually quite good for 樓主's consideration.

Ving

But fortunately or unfortunately, in HK most people evaluate whether a primary school is good or not mainly on its allocation rate to good secondary schools.

If one told a parent your children can have good language but he/she will go to band 3 schools, then I think over 90% parents won't accept.

人地既阿媽

我係TSL同KTS 中揀左TSL，原因係TSL學費平d，又有外語學，同埋我prefer 英小多過中小。如果我期望小朋友入到band 1 中學，入讀呢兩間是但一間對我分別不大，因為兩間都係好學校，但我相信家庭既配合才是最重要。