SFA VS St. Paul boys 你地會揀邊個？

KikiDaddy

thru train schools are attractive but we still need to consider the academic standard. hence, the schools my son applied for are in following priority order: -

1. DBS
2. APS
3. SFA
4. YWS
5. KTS
6. KRS

we only focus on schools in KLN as we live in Kwun Tong.

KikiDaddy

2009-2011 means the two academic years for P5&P6. Hence, the year before is 2008-2010.

原帖由 flyda 於 11-11-22 14:47 發表
係，但APS個result係2009-2011;唔知點解佢啲report都係兩年嘅；其實九龍好似SFA派位咁好嘅小學真係得APS 同KTS;但SFA就係以往一直都咁好。

flyda

謝謝，如果SPB向九龍，你會點排？

KikiDaddy

I'll rank it the same as YWS.

flyda

何以見得呢？St. Paul boys 中學都係 Band 1C 喎。

bb@wonderland

原帖由 flyda 於 11-11-22 15:44 發表
何以見得呢？St. Paul boys 中學都係 Band 1C 喎。

I think they are refer to the % of 6科14分, St. Paul boys in 2010 - around 49%. So it is band 1c.

You may click this link and download the ranking of the HK secondary school.



2010中學排位
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2300037&extra=page%3D1&page=1

6科14分%

聖保羅書院

中西區

1C

直資

男女

基督教

6

49.07

imdaddy

DBPS is so attractive because it has a famous and long history secondary school. If DBPS is on its own without secondary school, it is just a regular primary school. In the end of the day, everyone is looking for a secondary school, primary is only a stepping stone. So in my opinion, a school without good secondary school to continue rank lower.

The secondary allocation for school like SFA is not same every year, lots of factors will affect this result, no of seats provide from secondary school, your school rating at that time, your son need to compete with students in other schools, but if the school has secondary, the allocation ratio is fixed and you will sure what you will get if you get to standard.
This is only my opinion. I will play safe and look for better option. Unless you sure you son will be super smart in 6years time.

KikiDaddy

Academic result is just one of the factors to consider. SPB has its own strengths like a strong historical background and a well established alumni network.

原帖由 ha! 於 11-11-22 16:27 發表
Yw 成績ranking 勝過sp boy woo

JoshuaN

請問在那裡可以看到英華中學的成績呢?你怎樣知道他是band 1b 呢?

KikiDaddy

Some of the good teachers left DBPS and joined DBSPD when it was set up. This is one of the reason for the deterioration of its standard. In fact, DBPS' secondary school allocation in the past few years is not impressive except for the 10 seats from DBS.

I totally agree with you there is a definite advantage of a thru train school. However, even DBS and LS have around 20% students can't get 14 marks in HKCEE each year. Not to mention those second tier schools. Hence, it's
very important to have solid academic training at primary school stage. This is just my own opinion and all parents have their own right (and responsibility) to choose the appropriate schools for their kids.

原帖由 imdaddy 於 11-11-22 16:32 發表
DBPS is so attractive because it has a famous and long history secondary school. If DBPS is on its own without secondary school, it is just a regular primary school. In the end of the day, everyone is ...

KikiDaddy

Please refer to the following thread:

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... &extra=page%3D1

sytw

我有朋友一心target最top小學(e.g. SPCC, DGJS)，但無奈小朋友入唔到，佢而家決定會讀SFA，因為學術水平高，佢想之後幾年試插班入返呢d dream school，當然佢預左會辛苦及唔一定得。另有個朋友仔仔入左st paul boys開心到彈起，因為係佢心目中呢間係筍野，傳統名校又有中學，面且佢自知仔仔唔係最叻果d，無機會入DB呢d層次。我仔仔都好彩被St Paul boys收左，我自已覺得呢間係一間唔錯既學校，但近年中學成績差左的確令人有d擔心，但有人話係因為佢好大部份叻學生未到F5已去了外國讀書，我自己都想對呢間學校了解多d。

所以其實好睇樓主你心態係點，想6年後唔洗再煩但讀一間"幾好"既小學，定辛苦d但寧願搏小朋友能插班或中學入到"更好"既學校。

imdaddy

Sytw: seems you have offer from St Paul Boys and RC. So which is your final decision ?

sytw

原帖由 imdaddy 於 11-11-22 17:42 發表
Sytw: seems you have offer from St Paul Boys and RC. So which is your final decision ?

我地都未決定到，我先生鍾意st Paul Boys多d，而我就因為見好多人話佢中學差左而想揀RC，因為RC學術水平好似高d又男女校... 真係唔知點選好，所以都不停上網睇及問人意見