有乜野樂器易上手呢?

0203Ma

個女之前學過幾年琴, 但鍾意學唔鍾意練停了. 學校要學一樣樂器, 邊樣好呢? 易D上手?

motherotk

Cello? at the begining is a bit boring, but better to handle than violin. One of my children learn violin, need more concentration, he's good at that. The other one's concentration is not that good as the first one, able to handle cello.

[ 本帖最後由 motherotk 於 11-10-15 22:51 編輯 ]

cement

既然中意學鋼琴，應該繼續，寧願每日練少D時間，keep住興趣。因為學樂器經常會有樽頸，克服之後便是飛躍。

motherotk

agree, persistent and consistent is the rule of success..

原帖由 cement 於 11-11-16 16:20 發表
既然中意學鋼琴，應該繼續，寧願每日練少D時間，keep住興趣。因為學樂器經常會有樽頸，克服之後便是飛躍。

palmchristy

學好violin可以第時學埋cello. 八級violin後可即考5級cello. 但調轉就唔得.

Cello易過violin. 但一般都是Cello與鋼琴一起學數年. 有鋼琴底睇譜快.

babyislove

佢自己有無咩o野想試學?
不如你帶佢去聽吓音樂會，睇吓佢對咩樂器有興趣。
我過來人，就覺得口風琴好易學，尤其是已經識彈琴。
另外，長笛D聲好清脆、好好聽。

原帖由 0203Ma 於 11-10-12 09:03 發表
個女之前學過幾年琴, 但鍾意學唔鍾意練停了. 學校要學一樣樂器, 邊樣好呢? 易D上手?

appleice

同意有興趣學琴就繼續,因為就算學其他樂器都要練習~我囡囡都係咁,所以我成日都教佢做野唔好輕易放棄.

motherotk

For small kids, it's ok for the parents to choose for the kid based on parents' understanding on the child's strengths and limitations, unless kids voiced out their priority very strongly, sometimes they do..

From my personal experience, kids will lose their patience or withdraw from the learning becuase of the boringness of learning at certain stage of, choosing a good instructor, and format of learning is important. Group learning for musical instrument is not preferrable in my children's situation. Instructors from kid's school are usually not ok as well. Instructors from "big chainstores" are not ok as well. Instructors from youth centers are not ok in my chilren's case.

With a good teacher, the children's motivation be maintained and persisted.

Don't give up. I use learning music as a way to nurture their problem sovling ability besides appreciation of music..., like climbing up a mountain without seeing destination, full of uncertainities...

Cello093

You must be kidding!!!

Just the bow holding for right hand and vibrato for left hand are totally different for violin and cello.

原帖由 palmchristy 於 11-11-16 22:27 發表
學好violin可以第時學埋cello. 八級violin後可即考5級cello. 但調轉就唔得.

Cello易過violin. 但一般都是Cello與鋼琴一起學數年. 有鋼琴底睇譜快.

palmchristy

原帖由 Cello093 於 11-11-18 12:00 發表
You must be kidding!!!

Just the bow holding for right hand and vibrato for left hand are totally different for violin and cello.

是我囡囡的大提琴老師教學生的經驗來的.  該老師當年也是小提琴出身. 她的小提琴學生也是走這條路. 可惜我囡囡一開始是學大提琴.