用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 小一選校 25分的部署
查看: 4658|回覆: 44
go

25分的部署

Rank: 2


77
發表於 11-8-3 16:41 |顯示全部帖子
小女有25分, 太太為傳統名校舊生, 加埋宗教分

該校在區外, 故會先在自行收生階段申請, 但有一個很矛盾問題, 雖然有25分, 但為保險計都會考幾間直資學校, 但又想到當自行收生失敗後, 要面對選擇直資的offer (假設有), 還是等大抽獎 (同樣放該校在第一位), 由於所住的區域較差, 亦不會有搬屋, 借地址等做法, 故如果再放棄直資的offer, 就真的很搏, 現在15/16, 都不知道如何部署好!

Rank: 8Rank: 8


17194
發表於 11-8-3 17:02 |顯示全部帖子
過去無聽過25分入唔到,就算瑪利諾、喇沙都有人20分入到,唔好人憂天喇!疊埋心水等買校服啦!
原帖由 carloslau 於 11-8-3 16:41 發表
小女有25分, 太太為傳統名校舊生, 加埋宗教分

該校在區外, 故會先在自行收生階段申請, 但有一個很矛盾問題, 雖然有25分, 但為保險計都會考幾間直資學校, 但又想到當自行收生失敗後, 要面對選擇直資的offer (假設有) ...

Rank: 5Rank: 5


4345
發表於 11-8-3 17:18 |顯示全部帖子
25 分唔駛 15 16 喇, 一條心直入你太太間小學喇。

如果返學路途遙遠, 甘要 plan 下是否可以搬到學校附近,等阿女唔駛甘辛苦。

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1891
發表於 11-8-3 17:20 |顯示全部帖子

回覆 3# carloslau 的文章

pls check PM

Rank: 2


77
發表於 11-8-3 17:45 |顯示全部帖子
矛盾在於我是否還要去報直資學校? 不報不心安, 報了又可能是reject offer

Rank: 5Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


4330
發表於 11-8-3 17:45 |顯示全部帖子
自行只計分,不論住係邊都沒有影響
反而有一些直資是在10月底前公布收生,你take offer就會沒有機會自行
而25分基本上sure win
根本唔需要煩惱


原帖由 carloslau 於 11-8-3 16:41 發表
小女有25分, 太太為傳統名校舊生, 加埋宗教分

該校在區外, 故會先在自行收生階段申請, 但有一個很矛盾問題, 雖然有25分, 但為保險計都會考幾間直資學校, 但又想到當自行收生失敗後, 要面對選擇直資的offer (假設有) ...

Rank: 10Rank: 10Rank: 10

醒目開學勳章 貢獻勳章


25161
發表於 11-8-3 19:19 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 carloslau 於 11-8-3 17:45 發表
矛盾在於我是否還要去報直資學校? 不報不心安, 報了又可能是reject offer


如果真係咁擔心嘅,就去報幾間私校
恐龍家

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1953
發表於 11-8-3 21:48 |顯示全部帖子
25分sure win

Rank: 3Rank: 3


444
發表於 11-8-3 22:26 |顯示全部帖子
25分在手都仲要擔心? 幾多人恨都恨唔到呀, 如果真係擔心既, 咪報下心水既直資同私校先, 真係收你先再考慮囉..

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


11352
發表於 11-8-4 01:35 |顯示全部帖子
原帖由 carloslau 於 11-8-3 16:41 發表
小女有25分, 太太為傳統名校舊生, 加埋宗教分

該校在區外, 故會先在自行收生階段申請, 但有一個很矛盾問題, 雖然有25分, 但為保險計都會考幾間直資學校, 但又想到當自行收生失敗後, 要面對選擇直資的offer (假設有) ...


25分仲要部署?難為我呢d得15分,個校網又唔靚的哦..放心好了,25分冇問題啦!!

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2029
發表於 11-8-4 08:40 |顯示全部帖子
樓主,

25分sure win,冇得輸.

不過....如果你真是要保險啲,有以下建議:-
1.大部分私校都容許小朋友參加大抽獎(如KTS,APS,SFA,...),可以報這類學校為主.
2.只報自行結果公佈後才要註冊的直資(如培僑,TSL,...).

其實如果真的自行收生失敗,跨區大抽獎的機會就太微了,倒不如先要了心水直資的Offer,到出年六月再叩門.

但是我依然認為你囡囡入梗你太太的母校.

原帖由 carloslau 於 11-8-3 16:41 發表
小女有25分, 太太為傳統名校舊生, 加埋宗教分

該校在區外, 故會先在自行收生階段申請, 但有一個很矛盾問題, 雖然有25分, 但為保險計都會考幾間直資學校, 但又想到當自行收生失敗後, 要面對選擇直資的offer (假設有) ...

Rank: 19Rank: 19Rank: 19Rank: 19Rank: 19Rank: 19

版主 醒目開學勳章


48717
發表於 11-8-4 09:29 |顯示全部帖子
近年未聽過25分唔入既例子(EVEN係超級名津小), 你唔需要太擔心喇(ASSUME你肯定無計錯分, 例如宗教分, 上下午校果D咁既野)

學樓上話齋, 如果真係好擔心, 就考D可以大抽獎既私校做BACKUP啦, 直資就唔好喇, 收左就要放棄政府派位, 到時你仲15/16呀

Rank: 3Rank: 3


155
發表於 11-8-4 10:16 |顯示全部帖子
其實想知邊間學校?為何令樓主25分還擔心?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1991
發表於 11-8-4 10:47 |顯示全部帖子
除非唔想讀太太間舊校,25分根本冇可能唔收,樓主太杞人憂天
幾多人恨都恨唔到,你竟然仲擔心呢樣,擔心果樣

Rank: 8Rank: 8


17194
發表於 11-8-4 11:53 |顯示全部帖子
我聽到有一個唔多熟嘅家長話佢個女有25分今年會抽跑馬地聖保祿,都仲係好擔心,都唔知佢係唔係樓主?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3050
發表於 11-8-4 13:51 |顯示全部帖子
hehe..., i acutally understand his concern.  With many more babies in these years, sooner or later 25 pts can't guarantee to get in.
My boy also has 25 pts but I don't think is 100% either, especially 2008 has many baby boys!

Rank: 4


921
發表於 11-8-4 13:55 |顯示全部帖子
之前有一個家長在Baby Kindgom話佢個女有25分今年會抽Maryknoll,但就不停問有冇人20分入到Maryknoll,因為驚25分都要抽,都唔知佢係唔係樓主?

Rank: 5Rank: 5


3973
發表於 11-8-4 14:12 |顯示全部帖子
我都明白,始終都要手拿入學證果刻感覺先至實在。一年比一年艱難,名校學位只減不增,出生人數又係咁升,25分下年我估都 sure win, 但再過多兩年, 就真係唔包. 我都識名校舊生家長, 20分怕唔得, 走左去幫BB 領埋洗, 正係唔怕一萬至怕萬一. 某幾間超熱門, 今年收20分都係小貓幾隻, 兩三年後25分相信一樣都要抽, 有風險架.

Rank: 5Rank: 5


1953
發表於 11-8-4 14:25 |顯示全部帖子

回復 18# w_y 的帖子

25分大部分都是舊生分數+洗禮。目前25分跟出生率的關係不大,除非所有出生的小孩都是來自本地人。 所以除非學校有減班,不然統計學上來講,入不到的機會太微。

Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


46099
發表於 11-8-4 14:45 |顯示全部帖子
I think there are two questions from the member:

(1) Whether 25 points is secured to reach his wife's old school;
(2) Struggle to apply other "better" DSS/ private schools in parallel.  If being accepted, then how to choose.

First, we have just experienced the first year of P1 allocation with upward trend.  So, we are in a process that we must re-assess all the previous data we collected.  For example, I have seen schools which usually have high chances with 15 points, turns out the DP seats are almost (over 95%) filled with 20 points.  2005 is the first year for birth rate to increase in average of 10-15%.  So there will only be more applications.

Another reason which causes the higher demand of points in DP is due to the seats available in P1.  In the past, some of the popular gov't aided schools can have class size up to almost 40.  However, with the policy implemented two years ago, the biggest size is now 30 (plus 10% door-knocking seats which doesn't affect DP seats).  So, that means there are less seats in DP.

What does it tell us?  There are less DP seats for more babies.  A very simple math.  So it would push the marks required to reach a school.

I would guess the two popular choices for girls in Kowloon side would soon need 25 points to be accepted again.  So the worry is a valid one.  Although with limited information, we can only guess this year by year for when would this happen.  I believe it should happen within the coming 2-3 years.

So whether it is needed to apply to other schools as "backup", I believe it depends on how soon the daughter will be applying for P1.  If just the coming year, I think it is still rather safe (I would not guarantee this), but applying other schools are never a bad idea if the member feel insecure.

Hope the information is useful for other parents as well.

Ian

[ 本帖最後由 iantsang 於 11-8-4 14:47 編輯 ]