重讀K1問題

cherry913

我個女2007年12月30日出世~~~最近搬左去坑口住~~~星期六同佢去左IN一間坑口幼稚園打算比佢讀K2~~~點知老師話佢好細~之後我個女IN個時又唔出聲又好驚~~~老師叫我等通知~我知個機會唔GA大啦~~~我D親戚朋友都叫我比個人重讀K1~~比佢重新識認會好D~~因為佢係細B~~我想左一陣~打去學校比意見~~老師比左意見我~不過最終要自己決定~我最後話如果K1有位都好考慮~老師話K1有位~如果係就收~~~佢叫我比留位費~~~唉~~~不過我自己又15 16咁~~~比佢讀多一年好定係升上去好~~~仲有學劵只可以用3年~如果重讀多一年會點~~可以比意見我MA???

snowygary

repeat for sure

恩林

我自己都有個中學同學同佢阿哥同一級(阿哥留班), 常常俾人問佢地係孖生的....
佢地都有d唔開心...
我唔知你有冇兩個小朋友, 但如果有, 我覺得就唔好repeat喇~~
其實小朋友去到某年歲會level up, 唔洗急~
睇落好似比同班同學進度慢, 但相反睇, 其實係比同年, 但又repeat左一年的小朋友快.....

姐係例如, 你冇repeat, 直上k2, 而有同年同月的小朋友repeat k1, 當你小朋友學緊寫字串字時, 另一個小朋友仲係唱緊兒歌, 學緊排隊...
就算repeat k1可令小朋友係班中做一哥, 亦唔代表k2/k3會叻過人....

另外, 你宜加對新的學校也不是100%了解 同 sure合唔合適你小朋友, 如果repeat k1至發覺唔合適/有所不滿, 咁咪晒唔一年??

所以我唔讚成呵~~~!

[ 本帖最後由 恩林 於 11-5-23 01:34 編輯 ]

EvaKim

Dec is really a small b. There may be disadvantage in competing with other kids in the same year for good primary DSS and private schools.

EvaKim

I have a friend whose daughter is a end of Dec girl. She is smart enough to get into St Stephen's girl kinder as a small girl. However, she hasn't been able to get admission into St Stephen's girl primary or other great girls' primary. My friend said that if he can choose again, he will let her daughter to repeat K1 or K2 so that she can have more confidence.

Chewy

Personally, I don't agree of repeating in K1. You may consider repeat in K2 or K3. K2 or K3 will be more acadamic focus.  My girl is born in late Nov.  But she seems fine. Don't be sterotype of Small B. Its all about the school and parents guide them to learn.

School wise, of cos they want you to repeat la.. more $$$$

anteater

你可以俾佢REPEAT,不過REPEAT坑口幼稚園就唔值得,係都REPEAT D 出名D的學校,做大女一定入到,如果只係REPEAT坑口幼稚園,真係浪費左

ChingMan06

我都曾遇過E個問題,當時我有問過老師意見,佢話一般11月12月出生的都提議repeat!
大B自信心真係會強D!自小就可以做領導者,細B好多時都只會係跟隨者,就算細B真係好SMART,都未必有同學肯聽佢講,因為佢年齡比人細!
你諗下08年1月1日出生就根本冇得選一定係報2012年讀K1,你個B係07年12月尾,同08年1月果D只係差幾日???!!

如果做大B去出名幼稚園多數都收,如果K2先repeat都可以,但出名幼稚園插班一般都只能收PM,有好多家長都唔鍾意讀PM.

學劵冇錯只能用3年,你REPEAT就要自己俾多一年全費,如果唔係相當手緊,E一年都係值的!

galic

10月尾REPEAT COMMON 嗎? 本人PREFER REPEAT

原帖由 ChingMan06 於 11-5-23 10:29 發表
我都曾遇過E個問題,當時我有問過老師意見,佢話一般11月12月出生的都提議repeat!
大B自信心真係會強D!自小就可以做領導者,細B好多時都只會係跟隨者,就算細B真係好SMART,都未必有同學肯聽佢講,因為佢年齡比人細!
你諗 ...

恩林

我覺得不如用一年學費的錢去學其他活動好D......
我大仔雖然係2月出世, 唔大唔細, 但情格內向, 結果我報左一個 DJ班, 增強佢自信心, 短短半年由唔多出聲的3-4歲小朋友, 變成又可以上台做talk show, 又可以駁我咀嘅小朋友喇~~

rdong

樓主要想下K2要開始寫字,你個小朋友得唔得?睇長遠D,上到小學好多學科需要理解,你個小朋友又係唔係真係冇問題呢?
有好多野都係要到左那個年齡先能夠做到那樣野,好似BB仔學行咁,要到左那個年齡才會行到一樣!未到那個年齡就要做那樣野,辛苦的會係小朋友和那個幫他惡補的你!
我的想法是小朋友從小建立自信心是很重要的!你多給的學費能夠獲得的遠遠多於你想像!

bolun

我女兒係中女呀！都好難有學校收她repeat！她性格太內向了；所有新鮮事物要其他同學、朋友仔玩完先敢去；週不時，到我女夠膽玩已要收拾了！

讀了全日N班到而家都八、九個月，都仲怕同老師談話。連去洗手間都唔敢同老師、嬸嬸講！你話…. 我更想她repeat

GAT

I think repeat or not really depend on case by case, on the child's capability.

However this could be trained by the parents by giving the child more exposure to different people and to strangers, and go to more new places.

I also see some small B (Oct/Nov) got admitted to top kindergartens.

bolun

我個女對新事物真係好慢熱；在家才夠放膽咋！好似在校內連Warm-up運動都唔太敢做；我要在家同她練習，她才有信心回校做！

annie126

my daughter also born at 12/30 and is super small girl in class but she leant everything the same and can catch up the same with her classmates.  so it really depends on how's attitude of your child.  she will be P.1 at Sept and also get into SHCS wow.  so don't worry...  if she/he really can't follow the progress, change to another school law or let her repeat during Primary school.

when i was young, i was a big girl but still need to repeat at P4 la so small or big girl is not a big concern but it should be how you train her or her attitude law.  anyway, it just my personal opion.....