選讀拔萃女小學,還是讀瑪利諾修院小學

mamafans

考到拔萃女小學,你會因為有一個細妹而要女兒讀瑪利諾修院小學嗎?

如果選讀瑪利諾修院小學, 如何向大女兒交代??

[ 本帖最後由 mamafans 於 11-2-9 15:44 編輯 ]

icbb1230

要向大女交代什麼？

if it happens on me, I will go for Maryknoll.  Even though I think DGJS is more famous and might be higher in term of academic and student performance, but competition is too keen nowadays,Maryknoll is very good la.

原帖由 mamafans 於 11-2-9 14:49 發表
考到拔萃女小學,你會因為有一個細妹而要女兒讀瑪利諾修院小學嗎?

如果選讀瑪利諾修院小學, 如何向大女兒交代??

nicolemummy

if it happens on me, even without a younger sister, I will also go for Maryknoll.  DGJS and Maryknoll are both famous but different in style. You can feel the styles by observing those who are studying in them. My girl is more suitable to Maryknoll. Moreover, MCS is within walking distance with our home.

BTW, if your kid is selected by DGJS, she normally is very outspoken and confident. She may be more suitable to DGJS. If in case she is not this style and be chosen by DGJS in other reasons, e.g. you are great person in society etc, she may need to reconsider it. Most of the kids there are confident and thus like to compete - strike for excellence. If your kid is not that kind of style, she may experience hard time.

Let her visit the schools and let her choose.

原帖由 icbb1230 於 11-2-10 00:03 發表
要向大女交代什麼？

if it happens on me, I will go for Maryknoll.  Even though I think DGJS is more famous and might be higher in term of academic and student performance, but competition is too keen no ...

Martina

有朋友入讀的告訴--去年只有４個不能直升,  我相信壓力不比沒有直屬中學的高 !  

原帖由 angrybirds 於 11-2-10 09:40 發表
From Maryknoll primary to secondary, you will get a lot of pressure. I don't prefer.

lamtsuiyee

我們的家庭醫生的女兒, 小一至六都是Maryknoll, 中學就考入了女拔. 現在中六, 成績中上, 佢話小學唔讀女拔, 自己的英文唔夠小女拔上來的強, 佢話D同學的英文真的好勁.  但真的好大競爭. 同學出去補習班都唔會講你知. 佢話有得番轉小六, 佢會留係Maryknoll.

Sherryko9

我覺得小朋友模仿和語言能力是比大人想像的高,學語言是越細越容易適應,我老細兩個女都係女拔小上女拔中,聽過細女講英文,真係好鬼(好好聽),老細雖然在英國生活十幾廿年,但都帶著港音;我有果朋友個女係協恩F1轉過去女拔F2(當然成績係好過去),活躍份子,但過左去女拔,都覺得自己英語唔及女拔果D同學正,人地聽得出,F6了,讀得好好,好鍾意.
唔識人瑪利諾讀,但兩間比外人感覺都係轉統名女校;我覺得你只需考慮兩間活動配唔配你囡囡強項,及地點便可,每間實有佢地捧場客.

TMMA

我覺得如果學校有收生(自選)學生的能力，學生的素質或其他各方面都會比較平均d。

小天使kiki

乜原來讀瑪利諾全英小d英文出到來都同DGJS差咁遠，咁德望有無得比？因為好多人都話德望d女仔講英文好好聽

lauerica

原帖由 小天使kiki 於 11-2-10 22:05 發表
乜原來讀瑪利諾全英小d英文出到來都同DGJS差咁遠，咁德望有無得比？因為好多人都話德望d女仔講英文好好聽

其實好主要係從小開始搵外國人教英文，聽得多自然學會外國人既口音，所以發音出來既英文係會好聽好多，如果從小導師都係中國人就好難講到好似外國人既口音，除非個中國人導師從小都係受外國人教英文，咁口音就冇問題，所以如果想自已仔女講英文口音好聽，而家自已應該識得點簡啦。

kenmay

我會選DGJS, 我絕對不會因為妹妹而浪費姐姐的機會. 妹妹他日自然有自己的路要行.

原帖由 mamafans 於 11-2-9 14:49 發表
考到拔萃女小學,你會因為有一個細妹而要女兒讀瑪利諾修院小學嗎?

如果選讀瑪利諾修院小學, 如何向大女兒交代??

lauerica

當然名校請D老師,校長都會揀D口音好的。
咁點解會口音好？咪就係從小跟外國人學英文，港式英語點都講唔到外國人口音。

Sherryko9

我見老細平時同個囡(電話)傾計都係廣東話,無聽過佢用英語交談,點解我又可以聽過佢細囡用英語?因為老細有同事用英語問佢細囡野,所以聽到;我都唔明點解D細路用英語用得甘好聽?我睇DGS又唔係全部外語西人,就算係西人,但D細路文法又甘好,好多西人D文法真係唔係太好,好文法只是少部份,通常中國人著重文法多些(當然不能以偏全概);我舊同學果女當年在協恩時(F1)成績是最top,但聽說去到DGS時英語仍比佢地本土生有不足,而家唔知,上年攞了6A入場卷,所以話啦!如果成績叻的不需担心轉去強學校會下沉,遇強越強,不能低估小朋友適應力,佢地比大人強!亦不怕死!

shalaladream

對於樓主嚟講佢心目中只有DGS, 要"委屈"大女讀MCS係對佢唔住,所以先要向大女交代.

將D大家公認係好既學校比較嚟比較去, 食魚翅好定熊掌呢?
其實係咪應該唸吓自己係咪啱食呢?

wh0709

agree, we should respect kids and treat them fairly.

However, 12 study plan is not an individual plan, it's really a family plan:
location, $$$, parental involvement, social-relationship, etc.

Personally I prefer DGJS, new campus and may be more powerful social network.

原帖由 kenmay 於 11-2-11 09:36 發表
我會選DGJS, 我絕對不會因為妹妹而浪費姐姐的機會. 妹妹他日自然有自己的路要行.

cherrieshum

我選Maryknoll，因為女拔不是我這些中產讀的，入得女拔大多是非富則貴，又或者是名人，除非自問家境很好，否則讀女拔可能會讓小孩自卑。另外，Maryknoll已經非常棒了，何必一定要選女拔。