放棄 GH 選 SC?? - 幼校討論

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2146

21^#

發表於 11-1-18 11:40 |只看該作者

我會選sc, 雖然3年後搵小學都幾煩，不過要搵好過gh的私小\直資有五六間，差佢少少都有六七間，計埋津貼官立真係好多選擇。不過最緊要適合小朋友性格，如果唔係好易變拔苗。

DGJS

Rank: 4


	777

22^#

發表於 11-1-18 11:43 |只看該作者

又一個願意對子女承擔責任的母親. 你會是Norfold or Essex?

國家

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2057

23^#

發表於 11-1-18 12:05 |只看該作者

thank you DGJS, really happy that you use "又一個願意對子女承擔責任的母親" to describe.
My girl will be at Norfold.

How about you?

DGJS

Rank: 4


	777

24^#

發表於 11-1-18 12:48 |只看該作者

She is in Essex.

原帖由國家於 11-1-18 12:05 發表
thank you DGJS, really happy that you use "又一個願意對子女承擔責任的母親" to describe.
My girl will be at Norfold.

How about you?

chunlaifat

Rank: 4


	632

25^#

發表於 11-1-18 13:11 |只看該作者

一鳥在手總勝過百鳥在林, 不過你不喜歡那隻雀就另計.

MyAshley

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1262

26^#

發表於 11-1-18 13:19 |只看該作者

回復 25# chunlaifat 的帖子

Exactly!

kellyjason

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	111

27^#

發表於 11-1-18 14:12 |只看該作者

Agreed !!! If I have not yet joined the P1 admission game, may be I would also prefer SC over GH. But after experiencing this game this year, If I can select again, I would definitely choose GH.

You would never share the feeling or pressure that come from this game unless you have joined it even though my kid got accepted by dgjs at last.

I suggest you asking more parents that joined P1 admission before and see what are their comments.

The last thing is that, you never know the elite schools want to take what kind of students whatever how smart your kid is. I have a friend that her kid is very smart in academinc, attended a lot of extra curriculum activities, got many awards from open competitions on both academic and sport sides. However, her kid still got nothing offer now and need to attend the lucky draw later. So, the P1 admission results may not as what you expected.

Anyway, wish you good luck if you finally choose SC.

原帖由 chunlaifat 於 11-1-18 13:11 發表
一鳥在手總勝過百鳥在林, 不過你不喜歡那隻雀就另計.

國家

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2057

28^#

發表於 11-1-18 14:28 |只看該作者

Thanks Kellyjanson, your kid is so smart, may I know which KG was your girl in? Do you have any relationship with dgjs or professional background? Can you share the sthengths and characters of your girl?

cleverbb

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	351

29^#

發表於 11-1-18 17:51 |只看該作者

4 years ago, my friend’s son got Pui Ching AM offer. But finally they gave up PC & took KV (they love St Cat more but was just on waiting list). We all were surprise for their giving up PC as the daughter’s father was also an old PC boy. They admitted PC is a good school but their daughter’s character may not fit-in. They said they can’t sleep for several nights thinking if their decision for their daughter was right or wrong.
Time passed by, they keep on equipping their daughter for P1 application as they know the P1 competition is keen. Their daughter got offer from one of their target DSS primary school P1 last year. They thank God for guiding their decision & paving the way for their daughter.
From this case, it reminded us as parents we would choose the school is suitable to our child’s character and the school teaching philosophy & curriculum meet our expectation, rather than for the sake of convenience of parents.

icbb1230

Rank: 4


	648

30^#

發表於 11-1-18 18:33 |只看該作者

話咗唔comment, 但又忍唔住....

"又一個願意對子女承擔責任的母親"

難道揀GH嘅家長就唔原願意對子女承擔嗎？揀GH嘅家長就可以喺嚟緊幾年"kiu"埋雙手什麼都不用做嗎？

此comment好似有d唔係咁好囉.....

EggEgg08

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1884

31^#

發表於 11-1-18 18:43 |只看該作者

我諗佢嘅意思唔係選GH就一定等於不負責任，只係覺得呢位媽咪願意跟小朋友的特性選校，以小朋友能力出發,rather than 只考慮一唔一條龍。

原帖由 icbb1230 於 11-1-18 18:33 發表
話咗唔comment, 但又忍唔住....

"又一個願意對子女承擔責任的母親"

難道揀GH嘅家長就唔原願意對子女承擔嗎？揀GH嘅家長就可以喺嚟緊幾年"kiu"埋雙手什麼都不用做嗎？

此comment好似有d唔係咁好囉..... ...

TKma2010

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	237

32^#

發表於 11-1-18 19:52 |只看該作者

呢位媽咪係寧願未來幾年自己辛苦啲，都按個囡性格同能力去選校，認為咁對佢係最好。字裏行間可見佢對個囡嘅了解、愛同承担，值得表揚！
不過，每人心目中都自己有把尺，不同學校亦適合不同性格小朋友，所以並不代表揀GH嘅家長係貪舒服。其實GH都係一間好好嘅學校，如果小朋友性格適合嘅話，直情係正添啦，小朋友呢幾年又可以按真正嘅興趣參與ECA,而唔係為考小學而去考證書，一定可以過一個好happy嘅kinder生活呢！

國家

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2057

33^#

發表於 11-1-18 22:37 |只看該作者

多謝TKma2010。
相信每個媽媽都是好愛自己既小朋友的，如果唔係都唔會上來BK forum啦。希望及祝福每個小朋友都有一個開開心心既童年呀!!!

kellyjason

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	111

34^#

發表於 11-1-19 08:41 |只看該作者

回復 28# 國家的帖子

Pls read my PM

easybring

男爵府

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	5511

35^#

發表於 11-1-19 12:01 |只看該作者

真的怕怕不停上中英文班, 考試/比賽, 又要上面試班. <--- 雖然呢d對考小一幫助不大, 但人人去做你又去做, 有好過無的心態. 日子不快樂的!

原帖由 TKma2010 於 11-1-18 19:52 發表
小朋友呢幾年又可以按真正嘅興趣參與ECA,而唔係為考小學而去考證書，一定可以過一個好happy嘅kinder生活呢！

~easybring~

isis_dad

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2551

36^#

發表於 11-1-19 12:14 |只看該作者

剛行過想comments下.
小囡SC K3剛完成p1 admission games.好老實,真係好難玩....就算成績幾好in得幾好都冇十足把握.雖然最後都有成3間收(不算超級名校).
哇.我真係有唔知幾多晚瞓得唔好同佢煩呀.不過有得有失. 我反而覺得阿囡都有因為這個games有所得著.(如同佢分析喜歡什麼學校,喜歡將來學什麼/做什麼,喜歡男女校或女校).而且佢更懂得係人點樣表現自己.學會勇敢係每個陌生環境每個陌生人面前點樣interview. 就算有D學校唔得都學會點樣面對失望.我想這亦是我們將來總要面對的....遲早吧.
而且在玩這個games時你慢慢亦會思考什麼教育最適合你個小朋友...
Anyway..好多sc家長亦會精心步署..就算p1唔得亦會p2再試插班...我覺得sc學生始終見得人.

cherrieshum

男爵府

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	7401

37^#

發表於 11-1-19 12:21 |只看該作者

回復 36# isis_dad 的帖子

多謝分享。很同意。
小一選校是一個很困難的過程，不過可以學到怎樣面對逆境，也可以知道小孩最適合那類學校。

twinstar99

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	179

38^#

發表於 11-1-19 13:18 |只看該作者

回復 33# 國家的帖子

很贊成呢！

pandabonita