HKPS (AScot) vs St Cat 轉定唔轉?

cyl114

Hi Mcdondon 123,
Will ask my girl? I afraid she can not tell me. She is not smart as your son and Step C's girl.

russia_2018_wc

Better stay at PS! Much smaller class... SC takes in far tooooo many students

micemom

Hi Mcdondon 123 & cyl114,
I believe it's 芝士哥哥 as I remember that the Principal mentioned this name during the first parent meeting.

I've tried to asked my son about what did 芝士哥哥 played with him but he didn't respond at all

One good news is that he has stopped crying today when going into the school...it took him 2 weeks to get back to normal just after a short 3-days holiday...I'm now worrying about the coming 2-weeks school holiday, don't want to go through this again (I felt the teacher were not happy to see him like this:;pppp:)

monkey05

原帖由 janice620 於 10-12-9 00:48 發表
我女上年也在Ascot讀P2,今年轉了去SC讀K1,
個人見解/資料參考作比較:
1.HKPS老師們較親切,唔係教佢嘅老師/主任都會同佢傾計/問候佢,而SC唔會,可能學生太多了
2.HKPS是學校提供茶點, SC要自己準備(包括生日會建議準備 ...

可以幫你補充一下 :
4.HKPS没有課程進度表, SC有4 weeks plan,學校每個月會有通告通知家長下個月會教的課程,而每星期派回手册也清楚列明本星期教過的生字,兒歌,數學...更建議家長跟小朋友回家溫習
hkps 的進度手冊在開學的上學期同下學期已派發比各家長, 果3本小冊子便是, 內頭寫左大概果個月教d 咩內容/歌仔/字...etc...

5.以我所知HKPS在K1開始寫字, SC在K2才開始,我曾經問過班主任話希望先鞏固每位小朋友執筆的基礎,不用太著急寫字
hkps k1 下學期開始寫字, 上學期寫線
6.HKPS在K1的功課不清楚,SC每星期2份,今個星期開始3份,當中不時要搜集資料回校,家長要投放的時間較多
hkps k1 的家課上學期, 一星期兩本 (線+填色), 小朋友自己做, 無親子功課, 無咩野要搞到家長出手.

7.SC著重訓練自信,表達,小朋友每星期要站出來介紹物件/圖片
hkps 也是, 訓練小朋友出playground 唱歌, 也鼓勵同學在課室企出來答問題/唱歌etc.
細校, 感覺上幾親切, 無論係呀姐, 隔離班的老師, 都叫得出我小朋友的名字, 一個電話打去學校, 只講個名, 接電話的小姐也知小朋友係邊個讀咩班.  


[ 本帖最後由 monkey05 於 10-12-11 09:30 編輯 ]

Step_C

Sorry for not responding this thread for a long time cos I got sick in the past few days ah...

Yes, it should be 芝士哥哥ah but I seldom heard my girl mentioned about him... let me ask her about him... I just know the PTH teacher for P2 should be 李老師 since my girl always said 李老師再見,同學們再見 something like that...

We've given up the offer of SC... cos my girl really likes HKPS so much... and one more additional reason... I'm a lazy mum... I feel headache to arrange our daily 3 meals... so my headache will become more serious if I need to arrange my girl's snack food at SC...

Step_C

原帖由 monkey05 於 10-12-11 09:22 發表


可以幫你補充一下 :
4.HKPS没有課程進度表, SC有4 weeks plan,學校每個月會有通告通知家長下個月會教的課程,而每星期派回手册也清楚列明本星期教過的生字,兒歌,數學...更建議家長跟小朋友回家溫習
hkps 的進度手冊 ...

Agree very much your point 4.

And for the last point, I have decided to let my girl to join some PTH speech competitions when she gets older so as to train her confidence and courage of speaking in front of people. My colleague's girl, who is a K3 student of SOKA, did join many PTH speech competitions in the past years and got prizes. The girl has been accepted by both GH and SFA.

russia_2018_wc

Well done! HKPS is so much better!

cyl114

yes, I asked my girl, she said is 芝士哥哥. And, she told me little bit excise tim... so funny!!

Mcdondon123

Hi all,
After visiting the campus and briefing of SC yesterday, I think I will let my son stay in Ascot HKPS.
I think it's more suitable for my son. I like the new curriculum: all K2 & K3 class become 英普班.
Also, I think my son is more suitable for small class teaching.
Like monkey05 said,
細校, 感覺上幾親切, 無論係呀姐, 隔離班的老師, 都叫得出我小朋友的名字, 一個電話打去學校, 只講個名, 接電話的小姐也知小朋友係邊個讀咩班.  
Totally agree with this!

cyl114

Hi Monkey 05,
Thanks for your sharing regarding HKPS.
Do your baby studing at HKPS now? Which grade?

micemom

Hi Mcdondon 123,

Glad you've made a decision, and happy to see your son is staying...hope he enjoys everyday at HKPS!

cyl114

For all HKPS baby!

Step_C

原帖由 cyl114 於 10-12-13 11:32 發表
yes, I asked my girl, she said is 芝士哥哥. And, she told me little bit excise tim... so funny!!

Good!!! Feel very happy for you!!!