(急)香港華仁 vs 救恩，應該怎取捨

4eyesDad

To ykha:
I see you have your own thinking on all my points.
Point 1 is a difficult one to consider. You have no obligation to consider the happiness of the world at all in relation to your choice of a primary school for your son.
However, logically, it is not impossible to measure the happiness between two families.
The reason why I think freeing a place in an aided school will create more happiness in the world is that those who need (and hence have no other choice, due to financial constraint, ignorance, or location, etc.) to go to an aided school have only one hope. By comparison, those who can choose (or can afford to choose among different types of schools) have more than one hope.
So the former group will be happier if their one hope be fulfilled.

mow-mow

ykha,
Why don't you bring your son to attend a church service in Wah Yan on a Sunday?
You might even be able to talk to some current students / parents as well.

ykha

Thank you for your feedback.  I really cherish your sharing (and comments of all people who have responded to this topic in detail).  I take all the comments seriously and try to consider them thoroughly.

It is a difficult comparison.  That's why I invited parents who have children studying in those schools or know people whose children are studying there to share their experience.  We are somewhat aware of the styles of the schools, but I want to get more information to ascertain the "details" so that I can put proper weights to my concerns and make a more sensible decision.

原帖由 4eyesDad 於 10-11-24 15:42 發表
To ykha:
I see you have your own thinking on all my points.
Point 1 is a difficult one to consider. You have no obligation to consider the happiness of the world at all in relation to your choice of a ...

ykha

I don't belong to any religion...I feel odd to attend a church service just to talk to others and extract info from them...

原帖由 mow-mow 於 10-11-24 15:53 發表
ykha,
Why don't you bring your son to attend a church service in Wah Yan on a Sunday?
You might even be able to talk to some current students / parents as well.

thomasha

我咁o岩都係要揀呢兩間，好彩你開個主題先，我就可以揩o下油水。

大部分BK外的朋友都建議我地揀華仁，因為佢有名氣，有直屬中學 (不過直升比率只有六成左右)，校風又唔錯，不過亦有幾位基督徒家長就極力推薦救恩，話佢校風好，教得活，不過升中往績就只係一般。


我都係等到聽日先至最後決定，希望你決定後上黎講聲，等o個d等緊你放棄個位o既家長開心o下。

markBB

Perhaps the world really changed, i never expect parents will compare WY with 救恩, honeslty Ieven don't know where is this school.
I agree that WY may not be able to produce the best students, but at least it has a good tradition and students there in general are more "pure" than its competitor schools nearby.
One disavantage I warned my wife and my friends about WY is its relatively weak English standard, lots of the graduates have difficulties in this area when they move up to WYCHK.

diversity

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-24 16:24 發表
我咁o岩都係要揀呢兩間，好彩你開個主題先，我就可以揩o下油水。

大部分BK外的朋友都建議我地揀華仁，因為佢有名氣，有直屬中學 (不過直升比率只有六成左右)，校風又唔錯，不過亦有幾位基督徒家長就極力推薦救恩，話佢校風好，教得 ...

bet you will choose WY at last!!

thomasha

Any opinion?

原帖由 diversity 於 10-11-25 00:31 發表


bet you will choose WY at last!!

milkonline2

duplicated

[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 10-11-25 00:50 編輯 ]

milkonline2

duplicated

[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 10-11-25 00:50 編輯 ]

milkonline2

duplicated

[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 10-11-25 00:50 編輯 ]

milkonline2

Thomas, you should choose WY in order to suit HK educational system.  OTherwise, you will suffer again after 6 years.  Just personal feeling!

panbaby

救恩現在真的咁好?  以前真的好少見用港華同佢比較, 今天竟然可以一較高下?  我真的很有興趣知道.

我就會選港華了.  俗語說 : 瘦死的駱駝比馬大.  港華再不濟亦是男名校, 質素即使與以前不同只要你肯去讀, 軟件仍在, 想讀好書不難. 而且最最重要的是佢有名氣, 升中做人都有著數, 而且又有中學又免費...名校是細佬一生的cv 之一呀! 第時有人問你, 你讀邊間學校？ 答:港華　都大聲啲呀。


三思呀.

milkonline2

有人問你, 你讀邊間學校？ 答:港"大"　都大聲啲呀...........

原帖由 panbaby 於 10-11-25 12:55 AM 發表
救恩現在真的咁好?  以前真的好少見用港華同佢比較, 今天竟然可以一較高下?  我真的很有興趣知道.

我就會選港華了.  俗語說 : 瘦死的駱駝比馬大.  港華再不濟亦是男名校, 質素即使與以前不同只要你肯去讀, 軟件仍在 ...

markBB

if 救恩 is your choice, why not just stay at Victoria primary school at Sham Wan.

thomasha

I have no offer from Victoria. :(

Do you think the style of VSA and Kau Yan are similar?  I believe character development is much better in Kau Yan than VSA.

原帖由 markBB 於 10-11-25 01:27 發表
if 救恩 is your choice, why not just stay at Victoria primary school at Sham Wan.  

[ 本帖最後由 thomasha 於 10-11-25 08:18 編輯 ]

輝輝的媽媽

I am a Wah Yan mum, my wahyanite is enjoying his school very much. The school though is consider to be a traditional school, uses a lot of encouragement methods to help the children to grow and work hard.

The school treat us parents as part of the school, we are free to visit our children and attend their assemblies, you can feel that you are growing hand in hand with your children.

The father, headmaster and teachers are all very caring to the children. The old father ( I think more than 70 years old) even come down to play football with the children during recess time.

Of course you can't compare the campus with a Y2k campus, but it is small and cosy, the children can't tell the difference, they enjoy and make good use of every space in the school.

backtohome2005

原帖由 Gogojuly 於 10-11-24 01:31 發表


KYS是基督教小學.
佢地會有些慈善活動希望小朋友及家長参與.如買奬券,耆老餅,現今進行的"善普施聖誔禮物行動"就會將籌集的禮物盒送往經歷過天災的四川及青海.
我不是教徒,但覺得這些活動好有教育意義.且全是自願 ...

絕對同意ＫＹＳ是一間好學校。我個仔是Ｋ１插班生，佢本來是在一間出名幼稚園就讀ＰＮ，因搬家關係，Ｋ１轉到同幼稚園的分校，但兩間學校給我的感覺很不一樣｟可能是地區不同｠，校內由校長、部份家長、ＳＴＡＦＦ、、、、給我的印象是階級觀念重、提倡競爭、比較、，總括來說似辦公室政治那般，其後仔仔轉到ＫＹＳ讀，由面試那天我巳經感覺到他們的愛心、對小朋友的關愛、對教育的熱誠、，絕對沒有上述的辦公室政治ＦＥＥＬ。

至於小一選校，我只報了一間直資，其實是針對現實問題：一條龍，加上傳統或活動教學的取捨，在這兩開學校的ＯＦＦＥＲ中，我選擇了直資，坦白而言，一條龍給予的保障是很實在的；加上仔仔不是太適合活動教學，而我自問亦沒有太大信心可以引導他作活動教學【本人認為活動教學更需要家長的引導及監察】。所以華仁及救恩兩者的考慮是一條龍及教學方法。

markBB

Oh sorry i thought most kids in Victoria got offer from VSA. my wife loves VSA since she is a fan of facilities. i agree that the campus of WY is ugly, but I do like old stuff and this is why i am against the development of the new hall at WYCHK. anyway dont go too far. I do feel the care and creativities from VSA, so it's one of our top pick outside traditional schools. but too bad I am too bias to WY so didnt really think about other alternatives.

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-25 08:15 發表
I have no offer from Victoria. :(

Do you think the style of VSA and Kau Yan are similar?  I believe character development is much better in Kau Yan than VSA.