今年第一年有小五生, 究竟會否呈分?

virginia_328

今年第一年有小五生, 究竟會否"呈分" 參加升中派位?

Ocwc

小兒來年將人讀EC小一，很想清楚了解學校會否呈分。我打去學校問，沒有會覆。請問有沒有人知道真實情況呢？

freddielau

confirmed "NO"

yy1013

但盧校長係今年2010 簡介會話會呈分既

freddielau

原帖由 yy1013 於 10-11-9 04:58 PM 發表
但盧校長係今年2010 簡介會話會呈分既

but failed, turned down by EDB

Ocwc

It seems to me, the information are very confusing. Big trouble!

freddielau

原帖由 Ocwc 於 10-11-9 05:23 PM 發表
It seems to me, the information are very confusing. Big trouble!

why big trouble ? To most of the parents choosing EC owing to the "Thru-train", right ?

beetle

The problem is people always want to have more choice. From parents point of view.

1. Some may want to switch to gov/subsidized secondary school due to economic reason.

2. Some may want to switch to a girls / boys school when the kids step into teenage.

3. Some may concern about the academic performance of our secondary section.

etc.......

2.

MaMaCandy

原帖由 freddielau 於 10-11-9 17:11 發表

but failed, turned down by EDB

EDB 說呈分與否, 取決於學校.  若學校呈分, 就須放出 15% 學位由中央派位.  這點校長於宣佈呈分時, 理應明解.

一條龍有它的好處, 呈分卻能給家長及學生多個選擇, 多條路走, 總比無得選好.

[ 本帖最後由 MaMaCandy 於 10-11-9 18:12 編輯 ]

kdpeter

我在網上搵來搵去都搵唔到呈分要放出15%學位由中央派位. 請問這資料來源來自何方?

原帖由 MaMaCandy 於 10-11-9 18:11 發表



EDB 說呈分與否, 取決於學校.  若學校呈分, 就須放出 15% 學位由中央派位.  這點校長於宣佈呈分時, 理應明解.

一條龍有它的好處, 呈分卻能給家長及學生多個選擇, 多條路走, 總比無得選好. ...

kdpeter

睇來任何情況下都不是學校的問題! 學校的決定,學校的方向永遠不會有錯的. 問題來自認為有問題的家長而已!

原帖由 freddielau 於 10-11-9 17:34 發表

why big trouble ? To most of the parents choosing EC owing to the "Thru-train", right ?

kdpeter

我覺得校長是有責任向所有家長說明是否呈分! 因為打去學校, 學校職員都不懂回答. 答案要來自個別家長?

假如真的在呈分問題上有轉變, 校長有責任解釋原因!

Ocwc

Yes, this is my important reason!

原帖由 beetle 於 10-11-9 17:53 發表
The problem is people always want to have more choice. From parents point of view.

1. Some may want to switch to gov/subsidized secondary school due to economic reason.

2. Some may want to switch to ...

freddielau

原帖由 kdpeter 於 10-11-9 06:32 PM 發表
我覺得校長是有責任向所有家長說明是否呈分! 因為打去學校, 學校職員都不懂回答. 答案要來自個別家長?

假如真的在呈分問題上有轉變, 校長有責任解釋原因! ...

Why don't you go directly to the Principal ?

Ocwc

Actually, the main concern which in my mind is the situation of the secondary school.  In the primary brief section, I got no related information.  This create a big uncertainty to me.  So, I need to fully understand the status of 呈分.

Emailfamily

其實如果你是EC家長，應該都有聽過校長上星期Parent/Child's Feedback Day嘅presentation，會了解多D呈分及升中問題，當然如果家長miss咗無聽就唔知啦，所以每次都要入去八一下架！

又，如果大家覺得有問題～如行政，呈分，升中，升大等，何不直接於當天問校長反而喺BK留言？ 除非佢唔係EC家長囉！

我想大部份家長揀EC是因為直資一條龍，我就是怕升中要撲學校所以揀佢，但如果你唔想一條龍直升，當初為何唔揀D可參加派位的小學？

Ocwc

My son registered for coming 2011 P1, but I have no chance to learn what MR.LO's explanation on this critical topic!

midcochow

Emailfamily, 你講得好O岩呀, 其實間間直資學校都冇呈分依樣嘢, 而且一開始選得EC 嘅家長都應該知道學校係一條龍上, 我當初選它時都係因為依個原因, 其實幾年前我考依間學校時, 校長係無講過有呈分依樣嘢, 只係近依一兩年, D 家長覺得自己小朋友讀得好出色, 先至想升中想揾間再好D 嘅學校, 所以校長先至嚐試睇吓攪唔攪到呈分! 好似Emailfamily o甘講, 如果唔想一條龍直上, 當初為何唔揀D可參加派位的小學, 而去選EC 呢?

原帖由 Emailfamily 於 10-11-9 22:37 發表
其實如果你是EC家長，應該都有聽過校長上星期Parent/Child's Feedback Day嘅presentation，會了解多D呈分及升中問題，當然如果家長miss咗無聽就唔知啦，所以每次都要入去八一下架！

又，如果大家覺得有問題～如行政，呈分，升中，升大等 ...

Emailfamily

原帖由 midcochow 於 10-11-9 23:26 發表
Emailfamily, 你講得好O岩呀, 其實間間直資學校都冇呈分依樣嘢, 而且一開始選得EC 嘅家長都應該知道學校係一條龍上, 我當初選它時都係因為依個原因, 其實幾年前我考依間學校時, 校長係無講過有呈分依樣嘢, 只係近依 ...

Thanks, Midco!  That's all I thought! 另一位子女將入讀EC的家長,呈分真係你最終所願?但係如果你想學校參加中學派位為何揀一條龍學校?

virginia_328

10月尾俾留位費時, 校務處回覆係應該會"呈分", 因有部份家長都有要求!  2個星期後, 又話無得呈分, 好失落囉!

選EC是因教學理念及欣賞其生命教育課, 因始終沒有成績作參考!

當然經歷過小一選校的心理壓力, 所以才想選"一條龍" 免除升中的煩惱 ! 但六年後的事無人會知, 亦有可能會因經濟問題( 如失業) 而令小朋友未能如願升讀中學部!  有得呈分當然感覺有個"後備", 好似安心D!