崇真和王錦輝你會點選

hungchan1234

本人小女有崇真及王錦輝收她讀小一，大家可否給我一些意見。

hungchan1234

從課程看，王錦輝英語 環境比較好些。

kc_01k

崇真英語環境比WKF好好多.

3lamma

Yes, NET teachers but they are not necessarily 'blonde' hair type.

IS, computer, PE are taught in English.

Chi teachers do not speak Cantonese to students but speak Cantonese in parents day. Some of their mother - tongue language is Mandarin but some are not.

Hope these info is helpful.

IWAT

Which one ?  WKF?

edwinho123

請問祟真係直資定政府學校﹖是否要交學費﹖

hungchan1234

但據我所知，崇真只是有部份課程是用英語教，但WKF就大部份用英文教，我想會好一點。

hohoho2003

hungchan1234：你應該多認識wkF多些，有家長只說他的子女上學快樂，程度不知？

kc_01k

我都想知WKF英語環境好唔好.  同學仔哥哥讀WKF P.2, 今年轉咗去TTS, 佢話英語唔夠, 多係本地教師, 而且教師流失量高, 我有點擔心.

返咗TTS2個月, 佢話英語已好大改進.  本身佢仔幼稚園時係讀雙語, 佢話發覺佢大仔於WKF時, 英語對答明顯退步, 因為講英語機會少.

好想知究竟WKF有幾多NET, 定係無.

hungchan1234

Ha!I also got the same information.

motherotk

quite a many parents have this comments, you need to explore more and understand more....

原帖由 hohoho2003 於 10-11-5 20:46 發表
hungchan1234：你應該多認識wkF多些，有家長只說他的子女上學快樂，程度不知？

mother904

原帖由 kc_01k 於 10-11-6 00:50 發表
我都想知WKF英語環境好唔好.  同學仔哥哥讀WKF P.2, 今年轉咗去TTS, 佢話英語唔夠, 多係本地教師, 而且教師流失量高, 我有點擔心.

返咗TTS2個月, 佢話英語已好大改進.  本身佢仔幼稚園時係讀雙語, 佢話發覺佢大仔 ...

WKF最好的地方就是英語環境好，課程設計是教學生真正掌握語言的用法，而不是死記文法和深字。和家長交流，大部份都覺得小朋友的英語進步了，人變得自信，敢公開交流。

WKF的英語老師是NET，但大部份不是金髮綠眼的外國人，而是ABC, CBC, BCC或者是在外國居住很長時間的華人。雖然外表看起來像本地人，但她們有些是完全聽不懂廣東語的，和家長交流也是用英文。只要和老師們對談，便會知道她們的口音是不是native，根本不必要找個真正的「外國人」。但WKF始終不是國際學校，上課時間一定是用英文，但小息午飯OLE class之類，小朋友之間也是說廣東話，所以說英文的機會一定不會像國際學校般多，也不會說得像1st lang般native。

小朋友吸收的程度和喜歡的環境都不同，所以你朋友的經驗也是可以理解的。至於教師流失，我看到今年好像只有兩、三位教師走了，算是正常的自然流失，我就覺得不算嚴重了。

jackymom

My nephew is studying WKF. He has been there for 5 years and is now in Grade 7. His parents are native Chinese but his English is excellent (including his accent) without attending any extra classes or tutorials. All subjects are taught in English except for Chinese and Liberal Arts. I am totally convinced that it is a good school and am also sending my child there in the upcoming year.

I think WKF is very different from TT. If you opt for traditional kind of education, TT is more suitable. If you want your child to study in a comparatively less stressful but well disciplined environment, WKF is a good choice.

原帖由 ha! 於 10-11-6 08:03 發表
What i know from BK forum before :

TT :There are two streams in TT, local stream and international stream.  International stream is teaching in Eng and Mand, eng level is higher surely.  Local stream ...

catcatmom

黃X輝有別於傳統學校, 要認同黃既的理念, 先至好入去讀. 我鄰居兩兄妹, 都是讀黃, 我見佢地真係好開心, 日日放學, 著住件校服, 係公園玩很久才回家, 而其他讀傳統小學既鄰居小朋友個個係閱讀室做緊功課, OR睇緊書. 佢亞媽話間學校係無MUG壓力. 以前都有D朋友係度讀, 而加都走曬, 走既原因就唔知啦! 每間學校年年都有學生走. 不過黃年年都有好多家長報讀OR插班既! 始於間學校校舍又好靚. 家長有唔錯既職業,考到入去既機會都好大, 家長都要面試埋.

至深水步祟真係有好多外籍老師, 入到去, 行兩步,已經見到幾個金頭髮老師拿著書入課室, 不過係幾年前既事, 而加就唔知.

兩間真係好唔同既學校, 好難比較.

fotk

They leave because:

Some kids need more structured, some do not
for those need more structured environment and learning they left as the teachers have not trained up to support the "unstructurede learning" which is more difficult to achieve, needs a lots of skills and educational philosophy.

Those teachers they themselves were trained in "traditional and structured model of education", how can they understand what is "unstreuctured but supportive learning"??

I have come to their interview and see the questionnaires they asked for parents. Not a very good questions and the seminars they held for the parents are not that really interesting..no special...

原帖由 catcatmom 於 10-11-8 00:06 發表
黃X輝有別於傳統學校, 要認同黃既的理念, 先至好入去讀. 我鄰居兩兄妹, 都是讀黃, 我見佢地真係好開心, 日日放學, 著住件校服, 係公園玩很久才回家, 而其他讀傳統小學既鄰居小朋友個個係閱讀室做緊功課, OR睇緊書.  ...