DGJS really consider parents' occupation?

Ving

Just wonder if this situation is especially happen in DGJS and DBS.

I just wonder if they want to get rich and famous people son and daughter in, they can simply raise the school fee to a level so that only upper high class and rich people can afford. If so, I am really disappoint about HK education system as good govt, sub school is by counting marks and lucky draw and good DSS is counted by status and level of parents and not with children abilities...

So how about other schools like SPCC, is the situation so worse as well? If so, what good school is good for consideration. Please suggest

原帖由 mat媽 於 10-8-27 16:38 發表


男拔: 我 fd 仔仔讀緊, 完全冇家底, 我相信因為他 interview時表現出眾. 不過佢的同學個個唔係小康就大富, 我睇得出佢有 d自卑.... 酒會要 千幾蚊一位, 朋友唔參加, 小朋友就好唔開心, 擺生日會擺左一年o者, 因為. ...

ysnmama

何謂rich. 很難定義. 但每月學費已經$6000. 大部份家庭一定不會窮. 不過公務員有津貼或可申請學費減免. 但學校會選那些公務員家庭呢? 應該不是一般的.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-8-28 00:00 發表
Just wonder if this situation is especially happen in DGJS and DBS.

I just wonder if they want to get rich and famous people son and daughter in, they can simply raise the school fee to a level so th ...

Johnny@Klnbay

spcc小學可能是有錢人多，中學收約一百多外校生，則以成績為先，我認識有幾個中學家長住公屋，做侍應，並非律師醫生！
反而DBS 和 DGJS大部份小學直升中學，外校生較小，非富則貴的多!

JKTL

SPCC是有錢人多,但是這些人的成績也都很好,(SPCC並不是個個有錢的都取錄)

原帖由 Johnny@Klnbay 於 10-8-28 11:31 發表
spcc小學可能是有錢人多，中學收約一百多外校生，則以成績為先，我認識有幾個中學家長住公屋，做侍應，並非律師醫生！
反而DBS 和 DGJS大部份小學直升中學，外校生較小，非富則貴的多! ...

k.kung

當然不是個個有錢的都取錄, 而係有錢或家庭背景優良再加上成績好才取錄。 普通家庭是很難負擔每月小朋友的開支。 每月學費平均$6,000加上校巴, 午餐, 樂器, 補習............

保守估計每月平均用$10,000, 每年以10個月計, 讀12年要$1,200,000。 未計加學費和通脹。

如果有兩個小朋友讀, 12年使費已經可以買樓。

原帖由 JKTL 於 10-8-28 13:34 發表
SPCC是有錢人多,但是這些人的成績也都很好,(SPCC並不是個個有錢的都取錄)

[ 本帖最後由 k.kung 於 10-8-28 14:16 編輯 ]

Ving

So, is there any good DSS or private that is comparable to DBS, DGS, SPCC but not so require rich parents and money-oriented. Hope to be more focus on children's ability and performance rather than compare with parents' and family wealth.

KK07

原帖由 Ving 於 10-8-28 15:24 發表
So, is there any good DSS or private that is comparable to DBS, DGS, SPCC but not so require rich parents and money-oriented. Hope to be more focus on children's ability and performance rather than co ...

I think St Paul's Convent School may fit yr criterion.

Ving

Anyway, I lose confidence in Hong Kong education system in DSS/private/Govt/Sub for the money game and lucky draw game....

TMMA

原帖由 hellomickey 於 10-8-27 21:03 發表
我有個case想同大家分享:
我老公最近請了位Part time 文員,她有位8歲兒子,所以大家的話題便圍繞着名校面試,她對DBS的1st and 2nd interview非常有認識,..........細問原因下,她認為她倆夫婦只是中五畢業,又住公屋,根本沒法應付DBS的功課,学費及其他雜費對她來說,又實在沉重...

咁佢重去報名?
重去interview?
好得閒?

[ 本帖最後由 TMMA 於 10-8-29 13:59 編輯 ]

ANChan59

原帖由 Ving 於 10-8-28 15:24 發表
So, is there any good DSS or private that is comparable to DBS, DGS, SPCC but not so require rich parents and money-oriented. Hope to be more focus on children's ability and performance rather than co ...

My experience (DBS & SPCC) and other friends experience (DGS) of the mentioned schools focus on students' ability and performance, of course their standards much higher than we expect and potential candidates are very very outstanding. Just an example, SPCC one vacancy (P4) may have more than 100+ applicants, 28 for written tests.......I don't think its talking about social status, dad's profession, full tme mom etc.

Most people critised them may due to misleading "gossip" in different forums or some parents' kids can't get into those schools and justify their cases (Not selected) by various excuses.

tickling

of course it should be "3".

hui3328

在香港如何為有錢人下定義? 我認為身家沒有一億, 都不能叫有錢人?

原帖由 Johnny@Klnbay 於 10-8-28 11:31 發表
spcc小學可能是有錢人多，中學收約一百多外校生，則以成績為先，我認識有幾個中學家長住公屋，做侍應，並非律師醫生！
反而DBS 和 DGJS大部份小學直升中學，外校生較小，非富則貴的多! ...

mat媽

原帖由 miffy 於 10-8-29 09:36 發表
我想講, 我識的名校家長無以金錢品評別人的家長, 因為有些錢多到不得了, 根本唔洗care有錢無錢的問題, 只有名校校長最會品評家長有無錢, 家底配唔配合到學校。

...

家長有錢, 可以俾小朋友去不同類型的 playgroup, 學多d唔同的東西, 去多 d 唔同地方玩下食下, 咁好自然小朋友接觸的東西多左全面左, 眼光闊左, etc. interview表現唔多唔少會好 d 啦...

easybring

spcc有學費減免計劃的, 但入得去的一定成績卓越.  

原帖由 miffy 於 10-8-28 14:09 發表
你個住公屋、待應朋友真的很富貴, spcc一年6萬蚊學費, 加埋校車食飯、課外活動, 剩係比學校每月都成萬蚊, 未計出去補習和學課外活動費用, 剩比小朋友每月起碼$15,000, 另再加生活費和家庭開支, 你朋友份待應都有3-4 ...