小學叩門成功的小朋友, 是否都是大仔?

bellabella_oh

我個仔是細仔, 一直都ng 想個仔repeat K1 做大仔, 怕sai左佢一年.但最近有朋友說考小學歧視細仔的情況比考幼稚園更嚴重, 有細仔考了10間都fail.我開始很擔心,自己的固執是否是錯的?

所以想請教各位知ng知小學叩門成功的小朋友, 是否都是大仔?

細仔的叩門經歷收否都不愉快? 有mo成功的例子?

lilian926

Bella... I think I will ask this question to the teacher from Stafford... they might be able to answer it for us!!!

I am thinking about this question too... mine is small son too...

Monghar

My child is also a small kid and we successfully knock door to P1 last year.  My kid is the youngest in the class (30th Dec)... hahaha.. we failed all the P1 application and finally knock door to enter one of the top school.  So.. you still have chance.. do not worry but to prepare well for the knock door process.

elmolly

hope this can help you parents

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2210541&extra=page%3D7

bellabella_oh

原帖由 Monghar 於 10-7-12 22:17 發表
My child is also a small kid and we successfully knock door to P1 last year.  My kid is the youngest in the class (30th Dec)... hahaha.. we failed all the P1 application and finally knock door to ente ...

Hi  Monghar,

Sorry to ask but I am not very familiar with the P1 application process.  You said "we failed all the P1 application and finally knock door to".  Did you mean that you failed at applying "直資&私校" and then successfully knock the door of the "官津”？

[ 本帖最後由 bellabella_oh 於 10-7-13 09:49 編輯 ]

bellabella_oh

原帖由 lilian926 於 10-7-12 22:08 發表
Bella... I think I will ask this question to the teacher from Stafford... they might be able to answer it for us!!!

I am thinking about this question too... mine is small son too...

Hi lilian926, are you abe to let me know the results after you have asked the school?  Or may be we can go together!  

Are you going to the orientation day this Fri?

brrbaby2007

樓主是否肯定仔仔k1-k3都不及人？樓主是否覺得大多幾個月就會叻d？我諗關鍵是你點樣培育而唔係將個波踢翻俾學校去repeat多1年。如果我係小學校長我覺得幾負面

bellabella_oh

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-7-13 10:02 發表
樓主是否肯定仔仔k1-k3都不及人？樓主是否覺得大多幾個月就會叻d？我諗關鍵是你點樣培育而唔係將個波踢翻俾學校去repeat多1年。如果我係小學校長我覺得幾負面 ...

I don't question my son's learning ability.  I just question about whether primary schools prefers big boy than small boy, like what's happening now in the KG environment.

brrbaby2007

原帖由 bellabella_oh 於 10-7-13 10:08 發表


I don't question my son's learning ability.  I just question about whether primary schools prefers big boy than small boy, like what's happening now in the KG environment.

我覺得有KG prefer大B唔係因為能力問題，而係因為行政及收足學費等，到小學就冇呢d考慮，主要睇performance呢:loveliness:

spmok1999

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-7-13 10:25 發表


我覺得有KG prefer大B唔係因為能力問題，而係因為行政及收足學費等，到小學就冇呢d考慮，主要睇performance呢:loveliness:

我覺得有KG prefer大B唔係因為能力問題，而係因為行政及收足學費等 <-- 唔明, 咩行政同點樣收唔收足學費呢?

9284

其實樓主問的問題有點兒那個....如果比你係考官, 一個12月出世的小朋友, 性格開朗, 三文兩語好, 品德好, 愛看書, 又聽教.....另一個1月出世, 成日頭dup dup, 問咩唔應, kg成績唔好, 睇電視多過睇書......你係考官, 你仲會唔會選大仔? 凡事無絕對, 你個fd見十間, 十間都唔收, 你有無留意過佢小朋友本身係咩"材料"? 我相信叩門時的表現, 小朋友自己本身的質素, 勝過一切, 為人家長的, 請不要太短視, 亦不要將收生與否的責任, 再歸咎於大仔細仔的問題, 呢個情況, 在幼稚園會出現, 但小學叩門的話, 你未免看得太過兒嬉了

bellabella_oh

原帖由 9284 於 10-7-13 10:56 發表
其實樓主問的問題有點兒那個....如果比你係考官, 一個12月出世的小朋友, 性格開朗, 三文兩語好, 品德好, 愛看書, 又聽教.....另一個1月出世, 成日頭dup dup, 問咩唔應, kg成績唔好, 睇電視多過睇書......你係考官,  ...

gum 你又知ng 知有學校是不收8月後出世的小朋友? 依你的見解, 又認為是什麼原因呢?

spmok1999

面試時表現係好重要, 若面試時大仔與細仔的表現差不多的話, 先取錄大仔的可能性係較高, 除o左小朋友面試時表現外, 可能仲有其他因素影響....可能如識邊個邊個或者同邊個邊個有關係甚至乎可能係咩名人/上流可能唔洗interview都收???

B.B.BaBa

以我認識的朋友，考直資私小時，細仔的確比大仔難考得入。

當中有位非常叻的細仔(12月出世)，家住何文田山，考o左十間直資私小，只有一間收。佢係沙士年出世的，投考時的競爭其實不算大......

叩門的情況就唔清楚......

B.B.BaBa

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-7-13 10:25 發表


我覺得有KG prefer大B唔係因為能力問題，而係因為行政及收足學費等，到小學就冇呢d考慮，主要睇performance呢:loveliness:

其實 kg 真係因為能力問題而唔收細仔，尤其自理能力方面。d 老師淨係教都已經夠辛苦啦，仲點會想幫人湊 b 呢？

lilian926

原帖由 bellabella_oh 於 10-7-13 09:39 發表


Hi lilian926, are you abe to let me know the results after you have asked the school?  Or may be we can go together!  

Are you going to the orientation day this Fri?

Um... I think I will ask the teacher later on after the school has started for few months..

Yes.. I will go to the welcoming party on Friday... at 10am, right?  Let's meet up at the party!!!

bellabella_oh

原帖由 lilian926 於 10-7-14 22:26 發表


Um... I think I will ask the teacher later on after the school has started for few months..

Yes.. I will go to the welcoming party on Friday... at 10am, right?  Let's meet up at the party!!!

Hi lilian926,

Did you went to the orientation party?  My son was so happy and I had also took the opportunity to ask Ms Chan about my queries.  

Which class is your son going to join?

lilian926

Hi.. Bella,

My son enjoyed the welcoming party so much too!!!!  O.. you did ask about that?  Can you tell me what Ms. Chan said?

My son is in NCC.... How about you?  :D

原帖由 bellabella_oh 於 10-7-19 09:45 發表


Hi lilian926,

Did you went to the orientation party?  My son was so happy and I had also took the opportunity to ask Ms Chan about my queries.  

Which class is your son going to join?

bellabella_oh

原帖由 lilian926 於 10-7-20 22:57 發表
Hi.. Bella,

My son enjoyed the welcoming party so much too!!!!  O.. you did ask about that?  Can you tell me what Ms. Chan said?

My son is in NCC.... How about you?  :D

Hi hi,

My son is in NCC too!!  Can you describe how did you and your son looked like on that day?  I wore a white lace style dress-length top with blk leggings.  My son is tall and wore blue checkers shirt.

Actually I asked both Ms Chan and Ms Fan (class teacher) separately.  Both of them said that they have never heard of any small kids having problems with the primary school admission.  This year, they have around 42 graduates and they are being admitted by schools like 男拔, La Salle, 英華, 陳守仁,蔡繼友, SFA etc...So this strenthen my thoughts not having my son to repeat.  What  about u?

lilian926

Hi Bella...

Hello... I wore jeans plus a black t-shirt and my son wore a blue polo shirt plus jeans... There were too many people at the Welcoming party... I think it's difficult to recognize each other!!!!

Really?  um... I really think Big son has more advantage than Small son!!!  Anyway, let's see how's K1 go and then make decision again!!!  

So glad that our son are classmates... cool..... Keep in touch!!!

原帖由 bellabella_oh 於 10-7-21 09:48 發表


Hi hi,

My son is in NCC too!!  Can you describe how did you and your son looked like on that day?  I wore a white lace style dress-length top with blk leggings.  My son is tall and wore blue checke ...