急~St. Paul's Convent vs Maryknoll

lcy1998430

請問如果St. Paul's Convent 同 Maryknoll 揀邊間好？
St.Paul's Convent 要下星期留位，家下心大心細唔知去St.Paul's Convent好定直升Maryknoll好，各位媽媽可唔可以比d意見？

Ms.ChanChan

原帖由 lcy1998430 於 10-3-27 19:05 發表
請問如果St. Paul's Convent 同 Maryknoll 揀邊間好？
St.Paul's Convent 要下星期留位，家下心大心細唔知去St.Paul's Convent好定直升Maryknoll好，各位媽媽可唔可以比d意見？ ...

Are you sure your daughter can get a place in Maryknoll?

If not, I will go ahead to register SPCS.

CrabPincers

原帖由 Ms.ChanChan 於 10-3-27 22:08 發表


Are you sure your daughter can get a place in Maryknoll?

If not, I will go ahead to register SPCS.

人地話直升呀, 如我係我, 我會揀直升

asinai

Hi, Ms ChanChan,

Please check pm.

Thanks.

asinai

BestHKMother

St. Paul's Convent 唔係今日先2nd interview 咩? 咁快知道收既?

Ms.ChanChan

原帖由 CrabPincers 於 10-3-27 23:04 發表


人地話直升呀, 如我係我, 我會揀直升

Sorry for overlook that

Both schools are good!  Maryknoll is many ppl's dream school and most importantly your girl may not want to leave her schoolmates.

asinai

We've the 2nd interview in pm session, and we rec'd the acceptance call in the late afternoon yesterday too.

Yes, both are good schools.  Think over w/yr daughter that why u chose MCS at the very beginning and now why u intend to switch, may give u some hints to make the decision.

[ 本帖最後由 asinai 於 10-3-28 09:09 編輯 ]

claudiaho

Just wonder how come there is 直升 in MCS cuz it's not DSS school or 一條龍學校.

My daughter's classmate also consider to accept St. Paul's Convent's offer although she got the interview with MSC already.  I think it's more comfort to secure a place at the moment rather to wait until July.

原帖由 lcy1998430 於 10-3-27 19:05 發表
請問如果St. Paul's Convent 同 Maryknoll 揀邊間好？
St.Paul's Convent 要下星期留位，家下心大心細唔知去St.Paul's Convent好定直升Maryknoll好，各位媽媽可唔可以比d意見？ ...

mky9842

MCS will give an overall grade to the student indicating her banding which means securing a place in secondary section ie, in other words 直升, it is what the principal told us in the parents' meeting.

It is hard to choose as SPC takes sch fee.  If I were you, I would definitely take SPC.  I remembered the principal at SPC mentioned the wide exposure of their students and this is exactly their merits!  Give yr girl the chance to wide horizons.

melindalsl

What about if comparing St. Paul Convent and St. Mary?

rr

舊年我都是放棄了直上原校, 給阿女入讀了SPCS, 我們十分喜歡這學校, 阿女亦相當開心, 佢而家好直情唔記得晒以前的小學同學.  

兩間都係一級學校, 我會先考慮居住的地區先, 上了中學後, 學生好多時都要夜放學, 有時成6:00 先走, 路途都是一個先決條件.  我知道阿女有同學住青衣, 觀堂呀, 佢地夜左少少返屋企真係好辛苦.  

當時我的另一樣想法, 是給阿女出去第2間學校見下, 直上原有中學有時小朋友可能容易適應, 但有時可能令小朋友停滯原步.不願向前,  佢可以考到其他學校是她能力, 點解唔去試下.


因路遠, 我舊年無幫個女報DGS, 雖然都未必考到, 但我是怕萬一要選擇, 早兩星期我曾經再試探阿女會唔會想試考插班DGS, 佢叫我唔好搞咁多野, 佢很喜歡SPCS, 要佢去考第2間, 佢一定是旦亂黎, 等人地一定唔收佢. 總之佢一定要係呢度.


rr

Maisie

rr,

多謝你的分享!

我都有聽聞中學的生活很繁忙, 遠近真是一個考慮. 請問現在你囡囡的書包是否很重? 我也有聽聞中學的書包也很重, 請問SPCS同學的書包, 一般來說, 重嗎?

我想 SPCS 和 Maryknoll 都是很好的學校. 要我選擇的話, 我會選一間近屋企的.

rr

我女日日都好似搬屋咁, 其實佢地有locker, 但係又怕唔記得d野係學校定屋企,成日都攞黎攞去, 仲好似走難咁.
佢仲未好識安排, 遲d佢自己發現weekday 佢跟本唔會有時間再睇教科書, 佢可能會放d野係locker.

有得佢自己去安排下d野好d. 中學啦, 如果仲要我打點我咪好辛苦, 等佢自己去體會下F.1仔必經之路ar.

小學生父母職責係監督教導, 而家只要監察指導, 她們長大了.

rr

Maisie

rr,

你做得很對, 真的要給小朋友自己體驗一下.

小女今年小五, 年尾就要考升中, 可否分享考SPCS 的時候, 1st in 和 2nd in 問什麼和是用什麼形式呢? 個人present or 小組討論 ? 中英數 ? 普通話 ? 英語 ? 真的很多問題 ...

Maisie

mama.circle

我個女係maryknoll Band 3成績，等大抽獎係米好危?
又冇考他學校，請教教而家該點好？
揀咩學校好呢?

Miranda_Ho

原帖由 lcy1998430 於 10-3-27 19:05 發表
請問如果St. Paul's Convent 同 Maryknoll 揀邊間好？
St.Paul's Convent 要下星期留位，家下心大心細唔知去St.Paul's Convent好定直升Maryknoll好，各位媽媽可唔可以比d意見？ ...

我個姨甥女係Maryknoll讀小五，都唔想直升，想轉校。

如果St. Paul's Convent 同 Maryknoll 揀邊間好？

我會揀St. Paul's Convent 。