最最....差既 ST+ST centre!!!

rvp

what ST centre, dont really know what u mean?
STxx centre??

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-12-2 01:05 發表
I went to this ST centre for doing assessment by a ST. When doing assessment, the ST take some toys out, no demonstrate, no leading, just tell my son to show him how to play & no speech assessment. Si ...

iam

唔好咁勞氣先。你知唔知佢係做咩test, 係咪Symbolic Play Test?

如果係做標準化評估，ST講咩，做咩都要跟足規距，事實上這不是training，所以不可有咩guidance比細路架。

你問清楚這是一個咩test先啦!

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-12-2 01:05 發表
I went to this ST centre for doing assessment by a ST. When doing assessment, the ST take some toys out, no demonstrate, no leading, just tell my son to show him how to play & no speech assessment. Si ...

iam

你pm我啦，我都想知哪一間。

如果係做標準化評估，不外乎係symbolic play test同埋Reynell等，我問係哪一個test，目的係想問你比的金錢係值唔值，因為ST因為要根據評估的要求來做test，同埋比到你一個分數（理解同表達的年歲），咁你比的錢先值囉。而且若做了標準化評估，起碼要隔大半年才可做同一個test，所以就算你谷氣，都唔好咁快找第二個ST做test囉。

現在市場上對ST好渴求，所以有好多green ST，我建議ｄ媽咪找ST時check check 佢地的資歷，特別是否用做小朋友的經驗，臨床經驗比只是一個學位更重要。

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-12-2 12:43 發表
Actually, the purpose for writing this post is: I don't want other mamas will waste their money at this speech therapy centre(it's shame of their behaviour for only commercial purpose, as they will te ...

scholar

樓主不用氣.

assessment是這樣的.他們在過程中會給予不同類型的玩具,從旁評估兒童各方面的表現.

其實小朋友不一定要玩過某玩具才懂得玩.他們對事物的認識,有時只憑看就會學懂,只是你沒給他玩過,就不知他已懂.

如:你沒給孩子玩過燙衣,晾衣的玩具,但可能會驚訝在學校的interview時已經會玩.這是他從日常"看"的過程中學會的.

可能當日的評估,令兒表現了他各方面的delay,才會建議一星期5日的intensive course. Intensive course一般都有齊了3t,所以才會有"no need" ST.

不過如你覺得那個ST是no heart,還是再找一個你覺得可信的吧.

lokmanmama

我都有過同樣既經歷, 所以我好感受到你所講既"谷氣".你嗰個係唔係香港區嫁? 你不如講個名出黎(或暗示),等其他媽咪唔好再上當.

or send pm 交流下,睇下我地係唔係撞到同一個人!

iam

是否在YMT？定係在紅磡，銅鑼灣荃灣有分舖的集團？

我聽過YMT佢地以前每個禮拜係有1:1半小時training, PST, OT, ST輪流做，最近係呢度看到話做1:1要額外加$2000，wow, 寧願再出去buy 1:1 啦！

我估可能佢見做完assessment個result來judge卦。或者理解慢三個月，表達慢半年，先叫你唔駛做1:1 ST training.

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-12-3 00:56 發表
Thank you for your encouraging. I'm not angry for wasting my money, I'm disappointed of their "earing money method"!!!You told me it should usually have 3T at the intensive course, but I can answer u  ...

nokia6300

我都想知邊間呢?可 pm我嗎? 因我最近搵緊 training 比仔仔呀

nokia6300

hi ikebukuro,

不過講返回頭,其實除左heep hong,間間都有comments係commercial 的,even heep hong 唔講係 commercial,咁hoestly 人地真係 business 黎既,係咪?even hh,都有家長comments 有d trainers 都唔係好夾,所以好難你可以搵到 best of the best 的,唯有去try一try,睇下小朋友返左有冇進步啦!

正如我仔返heep hong既pt,個pt唔係唔好,因阿仔好多時都唔合作,而我地好多時林尾個15mins係傾計,不過佢教好多home training 比我,除此之外,比左好多意見我仔應該返d咩,咩servies 係點點點,對於我一個對所有 special education 都唔知既媽媽來說,呢d真係 extra bonus啦!

加油呀,你仔仲好細,可以追的好快,加油加油呀!

[ 本帖最後由 nokia6300 於 09-12-3 11:03 編輯 ]

owl_2046

麻煩你PM比我知, 我都幫緊個仔搵ST, $真係唔易賺, 唔想浪費. Thanks!

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-12-2 01:05 發表
I went to this ST centre for doing assessment by a ST. When doing assessment, the ST take some toys out, no demonstrate, no leading, just tell my son to show him how to play & no speech assessment. Si ...

iam

http://www.speechtherapy.org.hk/search.php

你在這裡可找到香港私人執業的ST清單，但當然夾唔夾，技巧等就要試過先知。

你可以打電話問ST的資歷，esp有無做發展障礙幼兒的經驗，同埋佢full唔full，然後再作決定囉。老實說，在協康等機構做了多年以上的，都會對佢有ｄ信心的。

原帖由 owl_2046 於 09-12-3 11:13 發表
麻煩你PM比我知, 我都幫緊個仔搵ST, $真係唔易賺, 唔想浪費. Thanks!

muimui5

Which centre was it? Can you PM me?

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-12-3 00:56 發表
Thank you for your encouraging. I'm not angry for wasting my money, I'm disappointed of their "earing money method"!!!You told me it should usually have 3T at the intensive course, but I can answer u  ...

Noemie

Can you PM to me which centre?

esy_ng

Please also pm me which centre. Thanks.

原帖由 ikebukuro 於 09-12-3 17:48 發表
nokia6300,
already pm to u la!!!

sze0830

我都想知邊間呢?可 pm我嗎?  Thanks ....

原帖由 esy_ng 於 09-12-4 02:09 發表
Please also pm me which centre. Thanks.