學鋼琴

BigKidKid

最細幾多歲開始學鋼琴比較好?

rho153

有d老師話6歲,但我daughter starts around 4歲, 都ok. i think it depends on whether your kid can sit for half hour.

原帖由 BigKidKid 於 09-11-23 14:20 發表
最細幾多歲開始學鋼琴比較好?

Sandy-Fion

要１０歲前學，因為１０歲前既手指係最靈活，個腦都吸收得最快，基本上４﹣６歲開始學就ok，要視乎你小朋友既性格和成長情況。早d學仲有個好處係多d時間搵老師，因為而家好多老師就算考到演奏級都唔識教琴，我幫個囡搵左幾年先搵到

chole媽媽

我個囡3.5y已經學,其實都要視乎個小朋友個性格.
搵老師都係一個問題,真係架,演奏級老師,又未必適合教小朋友.所以要注意一下.

edwardmama

我囝34個月, 我本來想搵d 音樂啟蒙班比佢上, 但有朋友話呢d 班係多餘, 到 3 歲就比個囝正式學琴就可以, 所以到e家都無報名學 music, 其實小朋友有需要讀音樂啟蒙班嗎?
如果真的有需要, 邊一間會好d 呢?

原帖由 Sandy-Fion 於 09-11-27 12:04 發表
要１０歲前學，因為１０歲前既手指係最靈活，個腦都吸收得最快，基本上４﹣６歲開始學就ok，要視乎你小朋友既性格和成長情況。早d學仲有個好處係多d時間搵老師，因為而家好多老師就算考到演奏級都唔識教琴，我幫個囡搵左幾年先搵到 ...

Sandy-Fion

原帖由 edwardmama 於 09-11-27 16:01 發表
我囝34個月, 我本來想搵d 音樂啟蒙班比佢上, 但有朋友話呢d 班係多餘, 到 3 歲就比個囝正式學琴就可以, 所以到e家都無報名學 music, 其實小朋友有需要讀音樂啟蒙班嗎?
如果真的有需要, 邊一間會好d 呢?


...

我個人覺得如果個老師係好既，根本唔雖要音樂啟蒙班，因為老師比較了解小朋友既狀況，由佢做啟蒙既工作比較好，有d老師除左教琴仲會教埋小朋友一d音樂歴史，教佢地聽古典音樂，仲會教埋佢地一d聲樂知識同埋唱歌技巧，咁樣個小朋友對音樂就會有比較全面既認識，比起音樂啟蒙班更有效

Pianokc

I am a piano teacher of over 20 years, I send both my kids to JMC. They also have to learn private piano lessons too.
The results of the positive effects from JMC is evident clearly after 2 years.

My daughter's musical sense, and rhythm and pitch are clearly better and more developed than my students who didn't take JMC.

I recommend all kids who have time, and parents who can afford time and money to allow their kids to take JMC and private piano at the same time.

Be patient, you will see the results.

SkyPenguin

有冇好嘅上門私人老師介紹? Thanks.

SuggieC

I'm now facing a problem as my son joined Tom Lee's music wonderland, JMC and now JXC. He enjoys the classes so much and has good sense of music. But I found that the traditional piano tuitor could not arouse his interest to learn piano by 1to1 teaching. My son get use the sf name but slow to convert it to chords. We have stoped his private piano class now and queuing for Tom Lee's one.

How can you soft such problem with your daughter?

SuggieC  

原帖由 Pianokc 於 09-12-1 22:40 發表
I am a piano teacher of over 20 years, I send both my kids to JMC. They also have to learn private piano lessons too.
The results of the positive effects from JMC is evident clearly after 2 years.

M ...

Pianokc

Ah ha! I had the same problem with my daughter. She was struggling with Doh Re Me, and C- D -E Problem at first.

What I did was each time she played Yamaha, we would sing Do Re Me, but when it's private piano playing time, I say C-D-E, and Doh Re Me, (alternating) after 3 months, she understand and got used to switching both back and forth with no problems.

I also made her write notes spellers, so I explained to her, Doh is C, Re is D... we always recite in the car, in the washroom, before sleeping...

Glad I didn't give up.

dandau

I agree that JMC can train kids good on musical sence that not all private teaching can do.  But not good on reading notes and fingers posture, that is very important, for long term on learning piano and muisc.

To my opinion, kids about 3.9 yrs should go JMC first.  Around studying book 2, I would recommend to start 1-to-1 private teaching as well.

If you start 1-to-1 private teaching after JMC, then the kid is almost 6 yrs, I think the kid need to take long time to overcome translating do-re-me to C-D-E.  Just like younger kid can learn more different languages easier than the elder.

All the above is just my opinion sharing that is also my experience from my son's music learning.

SuggieC

You are right, we let my son to go for 1to1 piano learning at Tom Lee since JMC book 2. He was fine and only need longer time to get use to the Chord. Problems came after we moved. Tom Lee could not offer seats of private piano class (FULL) and then we went for somewhere else. The teacher use traditional method to teach him and he was totally lost and no interest to learn. We then stop the class and go back to Tom Lee to queue  . Now we only keep JXC for him.

SuggieC   

原帖由 dandau 於 09-12-3 15:08 發表
I agree that JMC can train kids good on musical sence that not all private teaching can do.  But not good on reading notes and fingers posture, that is very important, for long term on learning piano  ...

mom5354

原帖由 edwardmama 於 09-11-27 16:01 發表
我囝34個月, 我本來想搵d 音樂啟蒙班比佢上, 但有朋友話呢d 班係多餘, 到 3 歲就比個囝正式學琴就可以, 所以到e家都無報名學 music, 其實小朋友有需要讀音樂啟蒙班嗎?
如果真的有需要, 邊一間會好d 呢?


...

You can let him participate the music playgroup before 4

rho153

In fact, i heard my daughter sang both do-re-me and CDE alternatively wor....i asked why and she said teacher asked her to practise like this....is it ok? or she needs to study separately?

原帖由 ha! 於 09-12-3 08:42 發表
pianokc,

thanks for your info. i also considered to give both to my kid but thinking the timing...coz the private teacher teaches DEF, and JMC teaches sofa name, if the kid learns two different names ...

Pianokc

rho153,

Your daughter is practicing perfectly correct! In time, she will be able to use these Do Re Mi and CDE interchangeably.

Good luck !

原帖由 rho153 於 09-12-5 23:30 發表
In fact, i heard my daughter sang both do-re-me and CDE alternatively wor....i asked why and she said teacher asked her to practise like this....is it ok? or she needs to study separately?