收到2nd in既DBS小朋友, 係用咩語言interview?

Teresa

朋友個仔讀CCKG, 考左DBS, 用英文interview, 未收到2nd in信.

想問下收到2nd in信既係咪用廣東話做1st in?

點算? 唔通讀CCKG都唔岩佢地要求?

fsforth

我個仔是用廣東話, 在一間唔多出名既幼稚園讀書, 一樣有 second in, 佢入到DBS second in 我已經好開心, 證明我當年無幫佢選錯學校!

Cherishvalue

我個仔則是用廣東話 1st and second interview， 不過他以前是讀 international school （有點怪獸吧！）。

我見CCKG 的孩子的確是有優勢， 不過是否百分百有offer則不得而知。  聽CCKG 的同學仔家長說， 男仔都有七八成機會。

原帖由 Teresa 於 09-11-9 22:20 發表
朋友個仔讀CCKG, 考左DBS, 用英文interview, 未收到2nd in信.

想問下收到2nd in信既係咪用廣東話做1st in?

點算? 唔通讀CCKG都唔岩佢地要求?

monkeydog

we chose cantonese but my son ended up being interview in full english as per my son. No 2nd interview call.

Therefore cant really see any direct relationship of language chosen/used for interview

im_cyt

That's not so fair in your case...do you plan to appeal (or discuss with) to the school?

原帖由 monkeydog 於 09-11-9 23:04 發表
we chose cantonese but my son ended up being interview in full english as per my son. No 2nd interview call.

Therefore cant really see any direct relationship of language chosen/used for interview

makmak615

原帖由 im_cyt 於 09-11-9 23:26 發表
That's not so fair in your case...do you plan to appeal (or discuss with) to the school?

Would like to know how to appeal, ie. whom should we talk to?   Is there a formal mechanism for appeal?

OnHo

我係DBSPD家長, 我想講俾大家知道:揀廣東話或英語作答係唔會影響評分!  只要你既小朋友係邊種語言下作答會表現得自然同真我d, 咁係就應該揀果種語言!

我兩小朋友當年都係揀廣東話作答, 而佢地好多同學仔都係一樣!  試想下:小朋友平時都少講英語, 係咁緊張既環境下(我係指2nd interview既"三師會面"), 又點可以發揮到佢地平時應有既表現?

至於係咪cckg一定佔優, 我諗真係唔係, DBSPD 同 DGS唔同, DGS係收好多cckg學生, 但DBSPD真係唔一定, 我同好幾個監考老師同羅校長傾過下, 發覺佢地真係好睇小朋友即場表現多過來係自邊間名校!  所以鼓勵仔仔們當日盡情發揮!  謹記有禮貌兼有反應, 就算係比較有創意既答案都唔拘!最緊要係表現得有自信同淡定!

呢幾年, 我知道有d弟弟去應考, 雖然入到2nd interview, 但因為唔出聲答問題, 所以校長話想俾分都俾唔到, 最後真係無收到個弟弟!

以上意見, 純係我個人見解同經驗分享, 並唔代表學校立場!

monkeydog

First, I am not sure what my son told me is 100% correct. (maybe 80% English 20% Cantonese etc.). Second, DBS will use english as a main teaching language and it is undertandable for them to test the kids' English standard. Third, my son only described she was an Asian but speaking full english to him...dont know who she is.

If that is meant to happen, just let it happen.

原帖由 makmak615 於 09-11-10 08:13 發表


Would like to know how to appeal, ie. whom should we talk to?   Is there a formal mechanism for appeal?

siufo

用廣東話interview, 比得你揀, 我估未必係睇你language, 而係比d人可以用返母語去答題

traeh

唔知DGJS情況，但我都傾向相信CCKG考DBSPD未必有優勢，面試真係睇臨場表現．

我比較相信CCKG考小學考得好，唔係因為D小學偏好呢間幼稚園，而係因為佢K2先收生，已經睇到小朋友大概係點（唔同pre-nursery或K1咁BB），又大概知道熱門小學收生要求，咁CCKG就可以用同樣criteria選學生．佢年年成千人報名，個pool咁大，點都會收到一批醒目聰明有禮decent兼反應快的小朋友．但係如果真係考小一面試時，臨場表現失準，都會一樣危．

原帖由 OnHo 於 09-11-10 09:12 發表
至於係咪cckg一定佔優, 我諗真係唔係, DBSPD 同 DGS唔同, DGS係收好多cckg學生, 但DBSPD真係唔一定, 我同好幾個監考老師同羅校長傾過下, 發覺佢地真係好睇小朋友即場表現多過來係自邊間名校!  所以鼓勵仔仔們當日盡情發揮!  謹記有禮貌兼有反應, 就算係比較有創意既答案都唔拘!最緊要係表現得有自信同淡定!

PMma

Monkeydog,

I think what happened to your son was not an accident.  It also happened to my son, and there may be many more others......

We chose Cantonese as the language for interview and was assigned in"Group C", according to their letter.  However, my son said he was led by a student helper - "prefect"into a room labelled as "D" in which the teacher spoke in Putonghua.

He told the teacher that he should be in "Group C" (as I told him just before leaving him in the covered playground).   The teacher did not response, but played a story play-back inPutonghua and asked him to listen.  Then, the teacher only used Putonghua asking himquestions.   My son understands Putonghua but not too fluent in speaking Putonghua.  But, he found the teacher doesn't speak or understand Cantonese at all.  

We were in the first time-slot on the first day.  They seemed not well prepared and made a lot of mistakes in the management.......

My son, of course, doesn't have chance to have 2nd interview but we don't want to appeal.  We found the 1st interview of DBS is totally "nonsense", so as many other arrangements of this school.   

The impressions we got were too bad that we really have no interest to let my son studying there and we don't want to waste our time and energy to make any appeal. Just wonder how many of these "accidents" happened during the two days of first interview in DBS!

原帖由 monkeydog 於 09-11-9 23:04 發表
we chose cantonese but my son ended up being interview in full english as per my son. No 2nd interview call.

Therefore cant really see any direct relationship of language chosen/used for interview

Angelina1

chinese - 1st interview

monkeydog

By the way, we were in first time slot 9am on Oct 10.

原帖由 PMma 於 09-11-10 11:59 發表
Monkeydog,

I think what happened to your son was not an accident.  It also happened to my son, and there may be many more others......

We chose Cantonese as the language for interview and was assign ...

lin624

這就證明讀CCKG 唔係100%考到DBS 同DGS

就算讀寶山都唔係100%入SPCC

原帖由 Teresa 於 09-11-9 22:20 發表
朋友個仔讀CCKG, 考左DBS, 用英文interview, 未收到2nd in信.

想問下收到2nd in信既係咪用廣東話做1st in?

點算? 唔通讀CCKG都唔岩佢地要求?

bowling68

中文幼稚園, 用英文 interview, cos 仔仔十分喜歡睇英文書 & 聽英文 CD

Ipapa

中文 interview !

Teresa

朋友話佢尋日收到電話, 有得2nd in喇, 放下心頭大石.

PMma

Yes, I do think that there are numerous kids, out of that 2200 applicants, happened to be interviewed like that.......   

Perhaps, it's just a general policy of the school and it's not an "accident".  So, it's useless to make any complaint or appeal!

In fact, since the moment leaving DBSPD after the 1st interview, I just hope that "we shall never come back to this school again"!

原帖由 suilangmui 於 09-11-11 12:39 發表
I think the same happened to many kids cus I heard a lady complaining about this when we were waiting to pick up our kids after the 1st interview.