聖心vs瑪利曼, 邊間好啲?

broadband

我囡先k2, 所以我對啲小學未係好熟. 如果唔睇學費問題,又好彩兩間都收, 應該選聖心私小定瑪利曼?

fatgoat

Maybe you are not familiar with the P1 Admission system, normally you need to apply for SH (Private) first and then lucky draw Marymount.  If you have two offers, give up SH (private).

broadband

請問你們點解覺得瑪利曼好些?

但聖心出唔少政經介名人, 例如陳方安生, 任關佩英, 梁愛詞, 恆生CEO, 陳淑莊等.. 我認為睇學校好唔好, 除了看成績, 佢地既事業發展更重要.

而瑪利曼甚至瑪利諾都唔覺有出咁多名人?

velma

你講梗呢班名人好似都幾十年前
以派位嚟講, marymount 近年都已經跑贏幾條街
好多年前好多都好好, 好出名
經過幾十年, 有升有跌
好多新貴都跑贏d 老店
d 老店都未必keep 得到個standard

原帖由 broadband 於 09-11-10 10:57 發表
請問你們點解覺得瑪利曼好些?

但聖心出唔少政經介名人, 例如陳方安生, 任關佩英, 梁愛詞, 恆生CEO, 陳淑莊等.. 我認為睇學校好唔好, 除了看成績, 佢地既事業發展更重要.

而瑪利曼甚至瑪利諾都唔覺有出咁多名人? ...

Sindy

原帖由 wootaitai 於 09-11-10 11:08 發表


--> you have more information on this? how good?

But I did check the HKCEE results on SH, MSS from their website. MSS def. better (thought its not a top school in terms of academic record)

我都覺得用跑嬴幾條街講MSS又太跨張，各有各好，各有長處啫

LS+MCS

原帖由 broadband 於 09-11-10 10:57 發表
請問你們點解覺得瑪利曼好些?

但聖心出唔少政經介名人, 例如陳方安生, 任關佩英, 梁愛詞, 恆生CEO, 陳淑莊等.. 我認為睇學校好唔好, 除了看成績, 佢地既事業發展更重要.

而瑪利曼甚至瑪利諾都唔覺有出咁多名人? ...

MCS :
* 陳美齡 - 歌手
* 胡紅玉 - 平等機會委員會前主席、行政會議成員
* 尤曾家麗 - 政府高官
* 劉慧卿 - 立法會議員

[ 本帖最後由 LS+MCS 於 09-11-10 14:23 編輯 ]

Sumyeema1

聖心私小:
- chinese school
- need to pay school fee
- half day school
- more traditional

瑪利曼
- english school
- no school fee
- whole day school
- p1-p3 : no test
- hard to get a seat

原帖由 broadband 於 09-11-6 18:35 發表
我囡先k2, 所以我對啲小學未係好熟. 如果唔睇學費問題,又好彩兩間都收, 應該選聖心私小定瑪利曼?

Sindy

no test?no exam,換左個名啫,同呃左我半日囉

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 09-11-10 15:04 發表
聖心私小:
- chinese school
- need to pay school fee
- half day school
- more traditional

瑪利曼
- english school
- no school fee
- whole day school
- p1-p3 : no test
- hard to get a seat



...

mamimummy

好多年前好多都好好, 好出名
經過幾十年, 有升有跌
好多新貴都跑贏d 老店
d 老店都未必keep 得到個standard

原帖由 velma 於 09-11-10 11:03 發表
你講梗呢班名人好似都幾十年前
以派位嚟講, marymount 近年都已經跑贏幾條街
好多年前好多都好好, 好出名
經過幾十年, 有升有跌
好多新貴都跑贏d 老店
d 老店都未必keep 得到個standard


...

candietweety

i don't think Sacred heart is a chinese school at all

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 09-11-10 15:04 發表
聖心私小:
- chinese school
- need to pay school fee
- half day school
- more traditional

瑪利曼
- english school
- no school fee
- whole day school
- p1-p3 : no test
- hard to get a seat



...

Sindy

原帖由 candietweety 於 09-11-10 19:28 發表
i don't think Sacred heart is a chinese school at all

教署既資料佢係,佢好似小三(?)有科英文科學(?),英文學校係由一年班開始就係GS,數亦都係英文,以我記得,聖心數學係中文教的

Sindy

原帖由 wootaitai 於 09-11-10 15:38 發表
Sindy

Supposedly everyone said MPS is a "happy" school that is relatively easy....

You think so?

我諗大多數既學生都覺得學校生活係開心的,唔開心只有小部份,就算我地大人覺得係好嚴既學校,裏面既學生都一樣開心

Jack0128

聖心私小,除英文及普通話之外，全部中文廣東話教，數學都係中文。

原帖由 candietweety 於 09-11-10 19:28 發表
i don't think Sacred heart is a chinese school at all

bkychan

In Sacred heart, General Studies is in English starting from P3.  English is one year advance in syllabus starting from P1.

Sindy

原帖由 bkychan 於 09-11-10 23:54 發表
In Sacred heart, General Studies is in English starting from P3.  English is one year advance in syllabus starting from P1.

係General Studies 定Science?我見佢地都叫做Science

Sumyeema1

Sindy is correct, should be "no exam"

my niece now is in MSS.  she graduated from SH KG, then went to SH private session.  she was not that fitin the school. then P3 插班 MPS.  She is very happy now.

of course, both are top girl schools.  

原帖由 Sindy 於 09-11-10 15:20 發表
no test?no exam,換左個名啫,同呃左我半日囉