不知所為的聖馬加利

spiderlily

G-Ma,

Absolutely correct.  When I compare the P2 this year Vs P2 last year, obviously, the course is more demanding with more projects.

The another thing we really appreciate is that the school would follow up parents' comments proactively.

Hence, I tend to believe the school would take immediate action if the staff / office is notified of citipeggy's case.  Besides, I still do not believe it is the school's intention / practice to have kids alone in the lift, from what I understand on the school.  

You know my boy was punished at the start of the school term for hiding himself in the classroom while the rest of the class was about to leave the classroom.  I was notified by the class teacher, illustrating degree of importance seen by the school.  You would feel that the teacher / school did care about the safety of the kids (alone in the classroom), not to say intentionally allowing them to take the lift alone.

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-10-29 10:34 發表
citipeggy

我所講既"惡意批評"並唔係話你講既事件, 睇完你既敘述我都認為學校係有疏忽, 唔應該比小朋友一個人坐電梯.  其實學校原意係唔想小朋友行7層樓梯先比佢地坐電梯, 但安排失當先會有咁既情況出現.  不過我 ...

[ 本帖最後由 spiderlily 於 09-10-29 11:05 編輯 ]

catcatmom

我有睇過視學報告, 佢話校長觀課不足, 後期學校請多了一位輔校長, 甘這間學校都不斷去改進. 但都有好評語架!
如學校裡裡外外都聽到學生講英文, 英語envoirnment
很好架.

中文比其他差, 係英小通病. 數學科又比其他科差, 份報告有報告數學都好差咩!無留意喎.
我當年考完出來係老師隻手拖著亞女隻手,fing吓fing吓甘出來, 個老師仲不斷讚佢.
如果個小朋友係一個人搭lift,無工作人員陪, 我一定當時同學校反映.

G-Ma

Hi spiderlily,

係呀, 呢兩年功課真係多左, 壓力都大左d, 不過坦白講相比其他官津smc仍然叫做唔算多功課.  學校想完全愉快教學都無辦法, 始終外間會介懷個視學報告, 如果學校唔加強, 人地又會覺得你有不足, 所以人在江湖, 唔多唔少都要入鄉隨俗.  

原帖由 spiderlily 於 09-10-29 11:03 發表
G-Ma,

Absolutely correct.  When I compare the P2 this year Vs P2 last year, obviously, the course is more demanding with more projects.

The another thing we really appreciate is that the school woul ...

citipeggy

我剛剛昨日同D Mami見面傾開D學校，咪再提St. Margaret囉，大家講開對這間學校的經歷，我越講越嬲，咪上唻同其他家長Share吓囉!

間學校講明要1個內通知，唔通我未夠1個月就上唻講吖！
我上唻講所有都係事實！唔好同我講如果係我我會點做點做.....等等，每個人的處理方法唔同，你如果係街見到個傻佬蝦你個小朋友，可能你會花時間同佢講道理和理論囉，但我會選擇立刻帶個小朋友走，唔會"side"時間同D傻嘅理論，唔想"side"氣囉！正如我見到間學校咁，我都唔想同佢講咁多！

你話我Concern, 我當然concern啦！嗰個係我個仔，再加上BK有好多parent都好似我咁，想了解多D不同學校的資料。你身為學校收得家長的application fee, 又白字黑字寫明會同家長交代面試結果，身為學校寫得出唻就有責任要follow啦！ 你接受D事情無始無終咩？

原帖由 spiderlily 於 09-10-29 10:45 發表
Interesting.

You posted your "unhappy" experience with overwhelming comments after 個幾月, coming from 個幾月都收唔到任何通知.

You said "對間學校失望到連講都唔想講嗰種", "收我都一定唔讀，要即刻走，離開 ...

[ 本帖最後由 citipeggy 於 09-10-30 03:39 編輯 ]

jaycee_mami

原帖由 catcatmom 於 09-10-29 11:25 發表
我有睇過視學報告, 佢話校長觀課不足, 後期學校請多了一位輔校長, 甘這間學校都不斷去改進. 但都有好評語架!
如學校裡裡外外都聽到學生講英文, 英語envoirnment
很好架.

中文比其他差, 係英小通病. 數學科又比其他 ...

份報告無講明數學科好差, 只係話中文和數學這兩科有待改善 (p.20第5點).

flostangraphy

[ 本帖最後由 flostangraphy 於 09-11-11 10:54 編輯 ]

flostangraphy

by the way, is it possible to check this 視學報告of other school??!!
where can we get it?!

thanks a lot in advance!!

ziyi

Yes, I want it

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-10-29 12:35 發表
by the way, is it possible to check this 視學報告of other school??!!
where can we get it?!

thanks a lot in advance!!

shiuchen

"there are some little things that make all wrong with the application of smc for our son...."
Mind telling us what it is please?

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-10-29 12:30 發表
i finally can't wait anymore and called smc...
after the admin lady find out my son's file, seems that my son didn't go through the 2nd round...
she said i will receive letter soon from school...
m ...

iristam

我一聽到聖瑪加利呢幾個字我就驚,有冇人可以話俾我知此聖瑪加利跟彼聖瑪加利是否有關連的,N年前我是就讀九龍城聖瑪加利女書院的,果時係津校來的,讀到中三尾聲時,突然有天告訴我們話九龍正校要結業喇,你地成校要去九龍分校果邊考試,睇吓收邊個,當然最後只收了運動最好果幾個同全級成績最好果幾個,根本唔需要考試啦,做樣咩,其實等如踢我地出校,點解學校結業咁大件事會無聲無色咁進行呢,呢D係咩野政策呢,辦教育的點解可以咁無責任呢,如果一早通知我們,係咪會好好多呢,等我地早日做好打算呢,因為唔係人人都俾得起錢去搵私校讀的,果時出到黎,好難會搵到津校去收的,個個都好慘,已經放暑假了,人人開開心心,我地個個都唔知點算,最後大部份人去了數一數二最差果幾間私校度讀,亦有從此便停學了的...............................(以上只是個人經歷,只想知道此2間學校是否有關係的,因近日也正在幫小朋友揀學校中)

pop-rice

我小朋友無考SMC.
每間學校都有不足, 有時更令家長好勞氣, 但也不要抹殺校長, 老師和同學付出的努力喔. 總之有則改之, 無則嘉勉啦.

diversity

That's why I won't risk my kid in going to those so-called 'new' style schools, which are new in terms of teaching experience, administration, track records.... The best example is the one on news everyday during the past few months....

TKO2040

原帖由 iristam 於 09-10-29 13:18 發表
我一聽到聖瑪加利呢幾個字我就驚,有冇人可以話俾我知此聖瑪加利跟彼聖瑪加利是否有關連的,N年前我是就讀九龍城聖瑪加利女書院的,果時係津校來的,讀到中三尾聲時,突然有天告訴我們話九龍正校要結業喇,你地成校要去九 ...

校董, 校監及校長應該係同一班人.

flostangraphy

[ 本帖最後由 flostangraphy 於 09-11-11 10:54 編輯 ]

shiuchen

flostangraphy,
Thanks a lot for your detailed reply. I now undertsand why you have so many fans here.
Thank you!
My son's 1st interview is on 7 Sept, and I just received the rejection letter today(29 Oct, 2009).
I did call SMC, but they asked me to wait....
Well, anyway, as what you said, maybe my son and SMC is not a perfect match. :loveliness:

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-10-29 14:34 發表
i think mainly the cause is due to me and my wife did not presented as the model parents they are expecting...
1st of all, our son can converse in French (mother tongue), English (daily language) and ...

rachncurtsmom

原帖由 shiuchen 於 09-10-29 15:09 發表
flostangraphy,
Thanks a lot for your detailed reply. I now undertsand why you have so many fans here.
Thank you!
My son's 1st interview is on 7 Sept, and I just received the rejection letter today(29  ...

Ha?  It took the school that long to process the application?  I guess it's a lot more difficult to process on-going applications and interviews like this.

My daughter's 1st interview was on Oct 7.  Maybe I will receive the rejection letter 1 month later.

Sim

Hi,

Mind me to say a word. SMC is not the only school that didn't send out interview result after 1 month from the 1st Interview lah! I haven't received any letter from my 1st interview school since 27th Aug till now. I didn't call them & I'm still waiting for the letter.

shiuchen

Luckily I did not expect much since late September as I heard that accpeted case will be informed within 2 weeks.
Good Luck!

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 09-10-29 15:16 發表


Ha?  It took the school that long to process the application?  I guess it's a lot more difficult to process on-going applications and interviews like this.

My daughter's 1st interview was on Oct 7. ...

G-Ma

其實每年都有過千既應考者, 要小心細閱資料, 分析, 挑選, 過程真係需要花好多時間.  而且smc只收80多位學生, 位真係比較少, 所以競爭比較大.

原帖由 Sim 於 09-10-29 15:35 發表
Hi,

Mind me to say a word. SMC is not the only school that didn't send out interview result after 1 month from the 1st Interview lah! I haven't received any letter from my 1st interview school since ...

Sim

hi,

My 1st interview school is not SMC ( a school in Shatin)