高主教 vs 聖類斯

diversity

有很多RC的一線尾二線頭的學生才會轉到那些學校 - you mean Queens, St Jo, Kings, Wah Yan, La Salle, DBS??? Are you kidding raimondi fans???

wlks

原帖由 diversity 於 09-11-19 23:07 發表
有很多RC的一線尾二線頭的學生才會轉到那些學校 - you mean Queens, St Jo, Kings, Wah Yan, La Salle, DBS??? Are you kidding raimondi fans???

我指最好成績的未必會走,但有些一線頭以下的會較為進取出去博一博:;pppp: :;pppp: :;pppp: :;pppp:

diversity

原帖由 wlks 於 09-11-19 23:36 發表

我指最好成績的未必會走,但有些一線頭以下的會較為進取出去博一博:;pppp: :;pppp: :;pppp: :;pppp:

I think it's more likely the other way round -
最好成績的出去博一博,一線頭以下的未必會走

wlks

原帖由 diversity 於 09-11-19 23:57 發表



I think it's more likely the other way round -
最好成績的出去博一博,一線頭以下的未必會走

成績好的多會對學校有歸屬感,留在原校升讀,可能如你所說一樣亦有些較反骨的會出去博一博,和你的想法一樣囉

diversity

原帖由 wlks 於 09-11-20 00:05 發表

成績好的多會對學校有歸屬感,留在原校升讀,可能如你所說一樣亦有些較反骨的會出去博一博,和你的想法一樣囉

反骨 - what a funny word to use, it's natural for those with abilities to aspire for better. It's nothing related to 反骨 or not.. You think you are in triad society ah!! Be sensible la die-heart fans!!
[/quote]

wlks

原帖由 diversity 於 09-11-20 00:31 發表



反骨 - what a funny word to use, it's natural for those with abilities to aspire for better. It's nothing related to 反骨 or not.. You think you are in triad society ah!! Be sensible la die-heart f ...

我不是什麼RC Fan,只是發表下自己的見解和分享, 不過對話中亦可看出一個人的人格和本性,正如閣下一樣,可能說中了一些你不喜歡聽的內容,就始終止討論,就你這份人和你再談也是多餘

pcsiauw

我大囡出年會響 RC 讀 p.1, 想請問一下, 男女生每班係點分配? 每班會有女仔, 定係將 d 女仔 group 埋做一班?

另外, 我仲想知, 係咪 p.1 開始, 就乜都用英文教 (except chinese)? 開學前有冇一 d 預備班之類俾準備入學 ge 小一學生?

sorry for so many questions...

原帖由 ononprincess 於 09-10-27 14:01 發表
我囡囡都是今年小一生，RC的確是男多女少，亦非常大班學生(37-38人一班 x 5班)。初時都幾擔心，但想到有那麼多家長願意放棄"大抽獎"而選RC，這所學校一定有她取勝之處，亦相信學生一定幾乖，否則老師怎能控制學生。


現在開學 ...

CFaHB

對不起啊! 我就是親眼見過好多次 rc 小學生 (未搬前) 在明愛圖書館講粗口, 打機 (那裡有電腦), 有一個男仔的媽媽打手提給他, 他大大聲說他在圖書館睇書呢 !

Robinson Road 中學生, 當然我聽過好多次佢地在巴士不停用粗口對話啦

眼見, 2個 rc 優異生, keep 住全級5名入, 中學分別轉左去2間唔同的男名校, 3年了, 2個都始終入唔到精英班, 真係唔知點解 (真心的, 佢地都好乖的)

rc 都是一間好學校, 只因有比較, 個人喜歡 sls 多點

原帖由 wlks 於 09-11-19 22:52 發表

SLS"純"?你要體驗SLS的"純",你只要在放學或食飯時間,你就會見到波鞋款式多過波鞋街的學生在四維奔走,你亦可在以上時間到SLS落兩條街的雷龍遊戲機中心,看到他們在努力"溫習",再走遠D可在佐治五世公園找到他們在"呼吸 ...

waiwaibaba

原帖由 CFaHB 於 09-11-20 14:19 發表
對不起啊! 我就是親眼見過好多次 rc 小學生 (未搬前) 在明愛圖書館講粗口, 打機 (那裡有電腦), 有一個男仔的媽媽打手提給他, 他大大聲說他在圖書館睇書呢 !

Robinson Road 中學生, 當然我聽過好多次佢地在巴士不停 ...

To be fair, I think both schools (and in fact ALL schools) have good and not so good kids, even DBS, there is a swimmer recently reported to have failed drug test. To quote isolated, unverified samples as indication to characteristics of full population will just be misleading. For me, I think U may check the following 2 as reference

1. In 2009 HKCEE RC, according to its school  report, has over 74% students having 14 marks or above in the best 6 subjects (so it can be considered a band 1-mid, if one define band 1-top as 75% or above with 14 marks above); figures for St. Louis- U may check their website or check 升中派位 in BK, I think St Louis is usually ranked as band 1-low to Band-2-top
Just checked their school report - 2008/2009 -55.1% has 14 marks or above; top students - 6A, 1B, 1C; 5A, 2B- as ref RC -top guy  9A, 1C; 8A, 1B,1C + 6 others with 6+A

2. sports results - U can check the website hkssf.org.hk , U can see that the overall sports results of RC is better than St. louis

[ 本帖最後由 waiwaibaba 於 09-11-20 16:37 編輯 ]

diversity

原帖由 wlks 於 09-11-20 00:53 發表

我不是什麼RC Fan,只是發表下自己的見解和分享, 不過對話中亦可看出一個人的人格和本性,正如閣下一樣,可能說中了一些你不喜歡聽的內容,就始終止討論,就你這份人和你再談也是多餘 ...

[quote]原帖由 wlks 於 09-11-20 00:53 發表


There's nothing to do with "可能說中了一些你不喜歡聽的內容". There's nothing I don't like to hear. But I find that you are going too exaggerated. Pls go to page 2 - the existing RC mums mentioned the strategy of 進可攻，退可守 for RC．Their feet vote for what they thought. That's fair enough and I do find this a very pragmatic strategy. But you have distorted the picture and that's why I was prompted to voice out your fallacy. There's also nothing to do with 人格和本性, you are going too far again.

[ 本帖最後由 diversity 於 09-11-20 21:02 編輯 ]

LGA

Sorry, I just want to share my experience and opinion. Three years ago, my son accepted by these two primary school. I chose RC even I had to give up my chance for lucky draw and at that time SL needed not. They were very nice that they said they would reserve the place to me even I participated in the lucky draw.

Why I chose RC? I found it seemed more structured and the form class were bigger, would have more competition to my son. But I knew it was very hard in life. Because of plenty of assessments, study etc.

I think two schools will be good. That's why I chose them in the past. RC is traditional. It will push you to study hard otherwise you will have "hard" life. It's good for my son. It trained him to be more humble and careful. Thanks to RC teachers and principal, really.

william_888

原帖由 diversity 於 09-11-20 00:31 發表



反骨 - what a funny word to use, it's natural for those with abilities to aspire for better. It's nothing related to 反骨 or not.. You think you are in triad society ah!! Be sensible la die-heart f ...

小兒剛由RC小學升讀中一，在過去六年小學生涯，兒子除了功課辛苦Ｄ之外，成績亦能保持頭十名，我很感謝學校和老師們對小兒的教導，在學校很快樂地成長，和同學及學校建立了深厚的感情和歸屬感，因此，我和小兒選擇原校升讀中學，我想讀書除了成績以外，建立良好的價值觀亦相當重要，如以公利為先，而忘記飲水思源的道理，可能到頭來成為無腳的雀仔，連自己的母校也說不出來。
對不起，或許我太感情用事。

norakyng

原帖由 william_888 於 09-11-20 21:58 發表


小兒剛由RC小學升讀中一，在過去六年小學生涯，兒子除了功課辛苦Ｄ之外，成績亦能保持頭十名，我很感謝學校和老師們對小兒的教導，在學校很快樂地成長，和同學及學校建立了深厚的感情和歸屬感，因此，我和小兒選擇原校升讀中學，我想讀 ...

同意。在明愛賣物會看見部分 RC 中學生圍住 RC 小學老師，大家有講有笑，十分開心，可以感受到他們對老師、學校的歸屬感很大。有很多 RC 中學生在賣物會幫手，
學生很有禮貌，很積極參與活動。

kiu_ma

絕對同意 william_888, 其實如果時間許可,家長可以到你們心儀學校周圍視察吓該校學生的生活,不多不少都會有助你們的選擇.  

呢的力唔慳得架! 不要只看我們在網上發表呀!

原帖由 william_888 於 09-11-20 21:58 發表


小兒剛由RC小學升讀中一，在過去六年小學生涯，兒子除了功課辛苦Ｄ之外，成績亦能保持頭十名，我很感謝學校和老師們對小兒的教導，在學校很快樂地成長，和同學及學校建立了深厚的感情和歸屬感，因此，我和小兒選擇原校升讀中學，我想讀 ...

diversity

[quote]原帖由 william_888 於 09-11-20 21:58 發表


How come you need to split your identity for talking the same point ah??  William & wlks

Stand up & contine to defend you point ma. There's no need to change to a new identity. Does this also reflect what you said as reflecting your 人格和本性??

No.Three

只是好奇一問 diversity 您是版主或什麼教育界高人嗎?
因覺得您好像什麼事情都好清楚咁.
如網友身份,各區學校的好與壞,好似通通都好熟,
又好有見地咁o既?

原帖由 diversity 於 09-11-21 09:15 發表
[quote]原帖由 william_888 於 09-11-20 21:58 發表


How come you need to split your identity for talking the same point ah??  William & wlks
...

ononprincess

原帖由 No.Three 於 09-11-21 13:19 發表
只是好奇一問 diversity 您是版主或什麼教育界高人嗎?
因覺得您好像什麼事情都好清楚咁.
如網友身份,各區學校的好與壞,好似通通都好熟,
又好有見地咁o既?

...

他什麼也不是，只是對高主教有偏見 jer，處處針對   好奇怪 !!!

pauline_c

pcsiauw,

每班會有女仔

不是, Maths & General studies 用廣東話和英文, 中文課用普通話, 其他廣東話(德育、音樂、IT、visual arts…), 當然英文用英語。他們頭一個月是適應, 認識學校, 老師, 同學等等, 做些工作紙, 有些像幼稚園的主題教學, 不用擔心

11gk

Hi 大家好, 純我個人喜好我會撰擇高主教, 若論成績我記得好清楚當年政府要立100間英中時, 高記是在名單之列, 而聖類斯則要上訴才能入選; 而論品行, 我見高記仔好似斯文啲, 但間間band 1學校都有壞份子, band 3都有好多好學生, 意見愈聽愈亂, 兩間總有一間是自己比較鐘意的, 忠於自己便OK.