迦南幼稚園家長質疑校方故意鼓勵學生 7月回校，變相復課

celinapang

文章來自APPLE DAILY :

【本報訊】豬流感疫情促使全港幼稚園停課以來，家長與學校就學費問題爭拗不休。有迦南幼稚園家長質疑校方故意鼓勵學生 7月回校，變相「復課」以便收取學費。

王太的兒子在九龍塘金巴倫道迦南幼稚園就讀 K1，她數天前接獲校方通知 7月繼續開放校舍，安排校車接送學生，生日會如常舉行，並提醒家長繳交 7月學費，否則不獲發證書。王太透過互聯網聯絡其他家長，初步估計同班逾半數學生將回校。她擔心學生聚集增加豬流感傳播風險，不打算讓兒子回校，「咁多小朋友聚集，同復課冇分別」。王太又質疑校方以通知學生回校之名，實質防止家長砌詞不交學費。
迦南幼稚園表示，根據教育局指引，該校 7月不會復課，但校舍照常開放，讓有需要的家長帶子女回校，校方又會按家長要求派出校車接送。該校的學費分 11期繳交，而且校舍 7月及 8月份照常開放，家長 7月應如常交學費。

kayhywong

你好，
我兩個囡都是讀迦南，他們不是交10個月學費？
因為我個大女現在是LK（k2），上年讀k1都是交10個月學費，幼兒班就要交11個月學費，所以我個細女就要交學費，我都想知是不改了政策，等待回覆！
我都是王太

midcochow

吓, 點解O甘奇怪? 因為我小朋友都係O向金巴倫迦南K1, 但學校只係要家長交10個月學費, 而且不嬲學校K1-K3 都只係交10個月學費, 所以我唔明點解話要11個月學費?
而且星期一我回校攞功課時, 學校仲通知我O黎緊下星期會退回7月份校車車費給我們. 所以我不明這個王太會這樣說?

chanwendy

我囡讀緊 n1, 返唔返七月都係要交學費, 但 k1-k3 即使返學都唔洗交學費架喎.  而且我又唔覺老師好鼓勵學生返學喎, 老師只係電話通知有需要可以返學, 我初時答老師話應該唔會返, 老師都冇講咩, 只係話如果要退學就早通知.  點都唔係王太所講的咁. 而且我見好多幼稚園都有學生返學啦. 再講, 王太堅持唔返, 老師都冇辦法架喎.

fanny豬豬

我睇完E段NEWS, 我覺得都好無理頭。

LovelyBB06

請問你們知唔知學生返學會做d咩? 是否只是托管形式? 還是好像平時上堂一樣? 我有個朋友個女話返去有看電視, 唔知是否屬實呢?

chanwendy

我又冇問亞囡係咪有電視睇喎, 今晚問吓佢先. 不過之前老師話會教埋未教晒的書囉, 所以我諗應該同平時返學差唔多.  至少我聽見亞囡唱新歌囉.

shelleym

I am angry that they don't give me back the n1 graduation photo and the certificate. The school is end on June due to H1N1 and July course is optional to  attend. I think they don't have the right to keep my daughter's photo and certificate if I don't attend July course because my daughter is complete N1 course.

[ 本帖最後由 shelleym 於 09-7-17 14:31 編輯 ]

LovelyBB06

原帖由 shelleym 於 09-7-17 14:19 發表
I am angry that they don't give me back the n1 graduation photo and the certificate. The school is end on June due to H1N1 and July course is optional to  attend. I think they don't have the right to  ...

你是否問清楚老師是否不給與你? 以我所知是會比番, 但要搵日自己去取, 不如你打電話去問清楚

shelleym

yes.. They said they don't give it to me because I did not attend July course. Did you pay July fee?? I think I did not pay for it and they don't give it back to me ??

LovelyBB06

原帖由 shelleym 於 09-7-17 20:15 發表
yes.. They said they don't give it to me because I did not attend July course. Did you pay July fee?? I think I did not pay for it and they don't give it back to me ??

Yes, I did paid the fee.

mandy1003

其實家長一年學費只不過係攤分１０或者１１個月交，如果交唔足就會當中途退學，同埋老師都要出糧㗎（同埋如果有學劵，政府都俾埋啦），所以我覺得中途退學就沒有畢業的物品都好合理嘅！及我自己都唸住唔讀７月都會交學費．大部份學校都係咁做法，所以都唔好咁嬲，或者你問吓學校交番學費有冇得有番呢？

原帖由 LovelyBB06 於 09-7-17 22:45 發表


Yes, I did paid the fee.

shelleym

I pay the fee is for the service, the service is end on June, why I need to pay 1 more month for the certificate. Even I ask the principle and ask her if I pay the July fee and did not attend the july course, can I get the certificate? The principal answer me everything is pass and she will not answer my question. I don't know why being a principal of a school, she can answer me like this.

chanwendy

原帖由 shelleym 於 09-7-18 10:03 發表
I pay the fee is for the service, the service is end on June, why I need to pay 1 more month for the certificate. Even I ask the principle and ask her if I pay the July fee and did not attend the july ...

你比既學費只係一年費平除 11 個月, 而唔係因應每個月的 service 去比的.  所以你既然選擇咗退學, 咁自然係拎唔足一年的 service 架啦.  而且我唔知係咪每班都一樣, 當日班主任打嚟問我會唔會交七月學費或者提早退學時, 都講到明如果提早退學, 係唔會得到畢業相及證書的.  咁的安排其實好合理啫.

jimmycarrie

雖然幼稚園部轉為非牟利，但迦南仍然搵錢至上，幼兒園、playgroup這些不是非牟利就更加不用說，不斷開班，不斷收生，基本上全年無休，完全不理會老師能否應付這樣的工作量，質素難以有保證。