幼稚園爆退學潮

Venuscheng

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-23 23:58 發表
講真, 學校如果要玩法律, 我估其實唔係唔可以, 唔好成日諗住人地好蝦, 諗住分道揚鑣就cut auto pay, 一旦出事就算勝訴都變成雙輸啦

學校假若已經按照教育局指示提供服務, 就算唔係家長心目中既全面上課, 都已經仁至 ...

如果玩法律的話, 小朋友無返學, 當然就不用交學費啦! 因為都無用到服務. 醫院每日都提供服務, 咁唔通無入院都要交費用嗎?

Venuscheng

原帖由 hch 於 09-6-24 01:49 發表
阿仔間幼稚園是交10個月學費,要家長寫票交9月份學費當造舊生註冊,還要都好醒目地在6月12日前已過數。記得上年要到10月才過數。

如果交10個月學費, 咁去年9月到今年6月都已經10個月, 7月已不用付錢囉! 我仔個間交12個月學費, 本來7月返個9日學, 要交足一個月, 都要硬住讓學校收的了. 但現在連那9日學都唔洗返, 就要交一個月學費, 真係好傷.

熱血媽媽

Support you Venuscheng

Private kinder used to cheat.  :;pppp:
I need to pay 12 months school fee which including easter, X.mas, new year holiday + 1 months summer.  
But the thing is all the extra activity and school bus service need to pay separately.  Not paying July fee just a concept of "pay as I served" I don't see any problem. or
or 個條數應該政府俾

airforce1

原帖由 avbee 於 09-6-24 09:43 發表
i guess there are many school teachers and principles here..........

Yes, I think so.  many priciple here.  They speak not from parent/consumer point of view.

The contract is, parent pay school fee ONLY if KG provide service.  

  No way KG can win if they did NOT provide service as promise in contract.  

I did not see "Parent need to pay KG even the KG not provide the services".  or just mine contract did not have it?

winsonma

small claim 是可以的, 不過真的很花時間, 我以前工作(提供服務的公司)經常small claim 人, 但就算勝訴, 都唔可以強制還款, 即是話又係得個桔, 學校又點會唔曉得計呢條數? 更何況大家都各有理據, 邊個可以索償都未知!

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 01:58 發表



去小額錢債個度追討呀, 呢d地方係花時間, 但費用不太高

Kendis1

Yes, 講得好啱呀!

Kendis1

me, too.....

dolala

原帖由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 11:27 發表
small claim 是可以的, 不過真的很花時間, 我以前工作(提供服務的公司)經常small claim 人, 但就算勝訴, 都唔可以強制還款, 即是話又係得個桔, 學校又點會唔曉得計呢條數? 更何況大家都各有理據, 邊個可以索償都未知 ...

除非家長走佬或者無力償還, 否則可搵執達主任以扣押債務人財產來還款

http://www.judiciary.gov.hk/tc/crt_services/pphlt/html/sc.htm#12

boilermaker

sounds like you are getting desperate, principal dolala.  

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 12:28 發表


除非家長走佬或者無力償還, 否則可搵執達主任以扣押債務人財產來還款

http://www.judiciary.gov.hk/tc/crt_services/pphlt/html/sc.htm#12

dolala

原帖由 boilermaker 於 09-6-24 12:33 發表
sounds like you are getting desperate, principal dolala.  

我作為旁觀者, 都係希望你地注意下法律風險, 學校假如已依足政府指示開放, 佢打官司勝算係有架

heiheiada

yes! yes! 一定係開左好多個分身去鬧通街!  

原帖由 boilermaker 於 09-6-24 12:33 發表
sounds like you are getting desperate, principal dolala.  

bakusensei

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-23 23:58 發表
學校假若已經按照教育局指示提供服務, 就算唔係家長心目中既全面上課, 都已經仁至義盡啦!.

i m not sure what's the meaning of "按照教育局指示提供服務". Do you mean simply keep the kindergarten open or just give the kids a little assignments for that two wks or the whole 1.5 months?

some kindergartens, like Learning Habitat, continue to send students video recording the lessons (yes, teachers continue to teach) and homework everyday by school bus and continue to collect and "mark" the homework everyday.

a lot of parents there r v. appreciated about the work the kindergartens done. n didn't ve complaints.

kinders simply keep themselves open really can't say sth like 仁至義盡.

熱血媽媽

Yes agreed, you can see LH charge 12 months but done a very good contingency plan on this.  a lot better than those kinders just sending a few worksheets, then declaring they have done a lot of work and charging full fees. :;pppp: :;pppp:

for 打官司,  even勝了, but losing  goodwill.  I think not many kinders will risk themselve for this......

winsonma

Oh, my god! 我真係無諗過你會提議行呢步, 你知道嗎? 我以前公司從來都不會做這個行動, 因為cost大, 但係return 可能係零, 不過還好, 你不是話揾收數公司, 唉...真係得啖笑~

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 12:28 發表


除非家長走佬或者無力償還, 否則可搵執達主任以扣押債務人財產來還款

http://www.judiciary.gov.hk/tc/crt_services/pphlt/html/sc.htm#12

[ 本帖最後由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 16:09 編輯 ]

kaifu

Any school principals who are "smart" enough to do that will definitely get a lot of free publicity in the press.  How would that sound to parents of potential kindergarten applicants?  Lighten up, dolala prinicipal!

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 12:28 發表


除非家長走佬或者無力償還, 否則可搵執達主任以扣押債務人財產來還款

http://www.judiciary.gov.hk/tc/crt_services/pphlt/html/sc.htm#12

dolala

原帖由 kaifu 於 09-6-24 16:47 發表
Any school principals who are "smart" enough to do that will definitely get a lot of free publicity in the press.  How would that sound to parents of potential kindergarten applicants?  Lighten up, do ...

如果告低收入人士, 可能不近人情。但如果係有一定收入的呢? 無能力付和撒賴不付, 可是兩回事啊!

dolala

原帖由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 15:55 發表
Oh, my god! 我真係無諗過你會提議行呢步, 你知道嗎? 我以前公司從來都不會做這個行動, 因為cost大, 但係return 可能係零, 不過還好, 你不是話揾收數公司, 唉...真係得啖笑~

...

殺一儆百, 有何不可? 至少要讓家長明白, 幼稚園有權根據教育條例收取符合規定的收費, 那些欠費家長, 又有沒有辦法證明幼稚園濫收費, 又或者沒根據教育局指示辦學?

dolala

原帖由 熱血媽媽 於 09-6-24 15:03 發表
Yes agreed, you can see LH charge 12 months but done a very good contingency plan on this.  a lot better than those kinders just sending a few worksheets, then declaring they have done a lot of work a ...

問題係, 做多d野, 維持良好校譽, 當然對人對己有好處, 但不等於其他幼稚園不能按規定收費!

請問有那一條例規定幼稚園停課便要減收某月份學費?

[ 本帖最後由 dolala 於 09-6-24 20:48 編輯 ]

Namnam05

各位唔好再比佢借題發揮啦 !

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 20:46 發表


問題係, 做多d野, 維持良好校譽, 當然對人對己有好處, 但不等於其他幼稚園不能按規定收費!

請問有那一條例規定幼稚園停課便要減收某月份學費?