幼稚園爆退學潮

minma

原帖由 yanyanbee 於 09-6-22 10:40 發表
講真…無啦啦交學費，小朋友又唔洗理…真係好難講…
不過如果個個都唔交…可能來緊個學年會有好多學校執…

咁又係, 可能好多學校會執, 都唔想發生在自己仔的母校

Gremlin

yesi... totally agree for your point of view... what a super work done by our Government, that she should take the responsibility, not just us or KG.

原帖由 cheng713 於 09-6-21 23:59 發表
To those parents who support their KGs and will keep paying school fees, we understand why you would do that and guess perhaps you have more financial freedom than others.....

But for most of the wo ...

dolala

其實分期付款既野, 你唔交只係攞幼稚園著數, 如果你買左野唔按期供款, 出面商業機構肯定唔會放過你啦!

dolala

>我今日剛剛停了幼稚園的自動轉帳了

點解咁多家長咁鍾意樹立壞榜樣呢? 雖然細路未必理解有呢一回事, 但你做既野係反映個人既價值觀, 肯定會影響番將來小孩的價值觀, 有d野去得咁盡, 係咪真係好事呢?

hongchung

部份內容由版主刪除!

本討論區歡迎各家長自由發表意見,但請各家長注意用詞,保持網絡禮儀,勿再出攻擊他人言論,謝謝各位合作!

Red2008
當日又要學英文，喜歡死讀書，於是讀"極牟利"幼稚園。
現在教育局不准上學，於是就這種家長覺得自己作為消費者，損失好大。

其實全港800間幼稚園，牟利幼稚園只約180間，這裡家長猛鬧的，只是極少數。
其實你食得咸魚要抵得渴喇，你點解當日要讀 "極 牟利幼稚園"？ 講明牟利，兼且無學券的。

幼稚園收費有收10個月或12個月，牟利幼稚園當然是收12個月好，看來極便宜呀，就是你這種家長喜歡囉。

唔好交學費囉，我都想牟利幼稚園去死的。

[ 本帖最後由 Red2008 於 09-6-24 13:52 編輯 ]

avbee

我都覺得如果一間幼稚園(牟利嗰種)會因為一兩個月收唔足
學費而導致出唔到糧俾員工, 甚至經營困難, 實在好難令人信服! support x2

掉轉個小朋友家庭有困難.  幼稚園會否有情講?
support x 2 ....i had problem before, and the school didn't help...so i am going to another kinder

my kid's kinder gave a photo copy of print out only and no phone calls is for following up.

and i called the school for quit for this year, and she said "you have to pay July's fee, and if you really want to quit which you have to one month advance to notice us. Any by the way, we are open everyday, for someone who need help...." actually i don't know the school open because the school didnt tell us, and also they said only "open for someone who need help (the kinder make decision who need help)"

for such service, do you think that i need to pay?

actually i found all the kinders in HK just like a private company, they are selling service to us, just like those Wharf T&T, PCCW, HKbroadband......

if you have any problems, they won't help you.  They only need you pay the school fee, and promote their after-school activities.

Please check your child's school fee, they increase every year,,,,,like my kid, it was 2800 per month now is $3300 per month.......actually all the service are the same.  If the school can control accurately, and has heart, they can control the school fee at certain level.  

so i am not supporting to pay for those Company KINDER

chanyeehang

我覺得交唔交學費決定當然在於閣下，但將心比心，如果你自己因工受傷,公司因為你返唔到工，而唔俾人工你，你都發佢老脾啦！  情不得而既話，我覺得都要交啦，一早都知要收咁多架啦！

ioi

原帖由 chanyeehang 於 09-6-23 23:21 發表
我覺得交唔交學費決定當然在於閣下，但將心比心，如果你自己因工受傷,公司因為你返唔到工，而唔俾人工你，你都發佢老脾啦！  情不得而既話，我覺得都要交啦，一早都知要收咁多架啦！ ...

其實是次事件, 幼稚園和學生家長都是受害者, 老師當然要照支薪, 家長也有責任繼續交學費.

然而, 點解大家唔諗下, 要求政府作出某程度上的補償, 以減輕幼稚園方面和家長的損失呢?

豬流感是天災, 正如地震等天災後, 政府也要經濟上承擔重建校園等等的責任. 又正如禽流感要殺雞時, 政府也經濟上補貼雞販的損失的.

我們的茅頭應該一致指向政府, 而不是幼稚園辦學團體和家長這兩方.

boilermaker

****************************************

[ 本帖最後由 boilermaker 於 09-7-6 12:31 編輯 ]

dolala

你要人地賣人情, 如果係大機構大善堂開既仲可能(但唔一定)易話為d, 但得幾廿個學生既屋邨幼稚園係咪真係咁容易賣人情呢?

[ 本帖最後由 dolala 於 09-6-23 23:44 編輯 ]

dolala

原帖由 avbee 於 09-6-23 22:41 發表
我都覺得如果一間幼稚園(牟利嗰種)會因為一兩個月收唔足
學費而導致出唔到糧俾員工, 甚至經營困難, 實在好難令人信服! support x2

掉轉個小朋友家庭有困難.  幼稚園會否有情講?
support x 2 ....i had problem befo ...

政府公布都有講要係原定暑假前照常開放校舍, 總不成每間幼稚園發公告俾傳媒, 傳媒都好難逐一刊登啦

boilermaker

afterall, it is the parents who "control" the payment.  many K3 parents have already cancelled the autopay arrangement while those writing checks for sure won't mail them automatically next month.  it is entirely up to the schools whether they want to do something sincerely to change the hearts of parents.  

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-23 23:43 發表
你要人地賣人情, 如果係大機構大善堂開既仲可能(但唔一定)易話為d, 但得幾廿個學生既屋邨幼稚園係咪真係咁容易賣人情呢?

dolala

講真, 學校如果要玩法律, 我估其實唔係唔可以, 唔好成日諗住人地好蝦, 諗住分道揚鑣就cut auto pay, 一旦出事就算勝訴都變成雙輸啦

學校假若已經按照教育局指示提供服務, 就算唔係家長心目中既全面上課, 都已經仁至義盡啦! 同家長玩民事, 理論上絕對可以......

[ 本帖最後由 dolala 於 09-6-24 00:03 編輯 ]

winsonma

我諗學校唔會玩法律, 因為法律係有錢人嘅玩意, 學校都話財困, 連糧都出唔到, 點玩?

至於玩民事就更加

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-23 23:58 發表
講真, 學校如果要玩法律, 我估其實唔係唔可以, 唔好成日諗住人地好蝦, 諗住分道揚鑣就cut auto pay, 一旦出事就算勝訴都變成雙輸啦

學校假若已經按照教育局指示提供服務, 就算唔係家長心目中既全面上課, 都已經仁至 ...

[ 本帖最後由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 01:30 編輯 ]

hch

阿仔間幼稚園是交10個月學費,要家長寫票交9月份學費當造舊生註冊,還要都好醒目地在6月12日前已過數。記得上年要到10月才過數。

dolala

原帖由 winsonma 於 09-6-24 01:26 發表
我諗學校唔會玩法律, 因為法律係有錢人嘅玩意, 學校都話財困, 連糧都出唔到, 點玩?

至於玩民事就更加

去小額錢債個度追討呀, 呢d地方係花時間, 但費用不太高

boilermaker

if schools have the same atitude as yours, no parents will be willing to pay any fees.  in fact, you do sound like a kindergarten official.   

原帖由 dolala 於 09-6-24 01:58 發表



去小額錢債個度追討呀, 呢d地方係花時間, 但費用不太高

dolala

原帖由 boilermaker 於 09-6-24 07:16 發表
if schools have the same atitude as yours, no parents will be willing to pay any fees.  in fact, you do sound like a kindergarten official.   

唔係願意唔願意既問題, 而係家長要明白唔交學費, 幾低都好, 都係有風險既

BabyAlexander

My son is studying K1 in a non-profit making kindergarten, we PTA just discussed "July school fee issue", the Principal strongly mentioned that "the stduents have not been to the school becasue of the suspension, why need to pay. "

You see the difference of 牟利嗰種, not even a cent, they need you to pay immediately.  

avbee

i guess there are many school teachers and principles here..........