想買琴，Yamaha定Kawai 呢？

kitty0303

我個仔試過Kawai K series, 佢話K8最好，要~$5x000，其他好似綿花糖琴咁，重有d聲好似走走地，有d奇怪咁。
佢再試埋Yamahi series, 就話YUS5非買不可。但係我預算之外。

於是周圍打聽，話U5都好好，但係TomLee已無得賣。
呀仔個老師話佢個調音師傅有部2手3年貨，細佬用，話好新，無咩點彈過，只係右手d key用過，要$4x000。

請問可以嗎？

又問多條，靜音琴用唔用得過？貴多~1萬。

謝謝!

bebebe12345

Yamahi
U3都可以彈到FTCL

foolish.mom

I used U1 to practise for FTCL.  U1 is already good enough

文文媽媽

原帖由 kitty0303 於 09-5-4 00:36 發表
我個仔試過Kawai K series, 佢話K8最好，要~$5x000，其他好似綿花糖琴咁，重有d聲好似走走地，有d奇怪咁。
佢再試埋Yamahi series, 就話YUS5非買不可。但係我預算之外。

於是周圍打聽，話U5都好好，但係TomLee已無得賣。
呀仔個 ...

你睇下呢度http://hk.f2.page.auctions.yahoo.com/hk/show/qanda?aID=b10560177

daddygary

其實YAHAMA 同KAWAI 兩個brand 都好，但係因為yahama在tomlee 旗下，咁多分行咁多promotion, 所以會貴d囉... 個人買左第二個琴，都係KAWAI ... 手感比yahama 重少少，對考琴都有好處既!!

如果你要買yahama/kawai 新琴我都可以幫到你... please check pm

Pianokc

I personally think in the recent years, since Yamaha's "manufacturing" factor has changed.... that Kawai's upright pianos now have advantage over Yamaha.

I like Yamaha's YUS 1. But you are looking at much more $$$ than U1.

U1- don't bother buying it, then go for Kawai's upright pianos. Kawai-'s touch is better, and sound is more "mellow" while Yamaha is more SHARP.

This is purely my personal opinion, Yamaha and Kawai are both good brands, will not go wrong with either one, if you want to resell, very easy too.

It really depends what your budget is.

Ask your teacher to get you the "best" price through teacher's discount.

Used pianos are a good option, if the piano has no technical/mechanism problem, I would purchase a piano that is either brand new, or about 10 years old, because then you are really saving money. A good condition upright about 10 years old, either Yamaha or Kawai, should be about $ 18 000.00

If you are saving only $ 10 000 or $ 20 000, then why buy used, buy brand new.

Just my opinion.

Good luck.

Pianokc

BTW, of course you can use a U1 up to FTCL... or whatever level you want. However, it's like using a bicycle in a race against motorcycle. You just have to TRY harder than others who have the right equipment.

Personally speaking, I don't recommend any of my students playing above Grade 8, on anything less than U3. U3 is minimum, the touch, the tone, the pedal, the action/reaction of the keys, the senstive touch.... no way on a U1 can you play anything beyond Grade 8 to its best.

There is a reason for having grand pianos, and remember, your child takes exams, and performs in competitions ONLY on Grand pianos.

Silent pianos- it's good for practicing for the child in HK because of the limitations we have here with apartments. In Canada, we never bothered with it.

You can get it, but won't add to your resell value because anything "electronic" depreciates in value the moment it is 2nd hand.

RedHeart

原帖由 daddygary 於 09-5-25 01:41 發表
其實YAHAMA 同KAWAI 兩個brand 都好，但係因為yahama在tomlee 旗下，咁多分行咁多promotion, 所以會貴d囉... 個人買左第二個琴，都係KAWAI ... 手感比yahama 重少少，對考琴都有好處既!!

如果你要買yahama/kawai 新琴我都 ...

又係度鬼鼠sell嘢, 唔通有佣收??